General & Others Next Straw Hat Crew Members and the Grand Fleet
- Thread starter Uncle Van
- Start date
- Tags #c4ng2g carrot fans are still losers carrot haters are real losers seethe at the rabbit carrot is doing nothing because she doesn't matter carrot will never join the straw hats carrot's story never even began cry about carrot everyone else in the verse neg diffs the bunny imagine thinking stussy won't join its over furry bros keep the bunny on zou nobody else needs her let it go furry bros momo is breeding yamato no character is less relevant than carrot oden larper fans can't read stussy > carrot & yamato stussy supremacy who will be the next nakama of the week? yamato always had a better chance than carrot yamato story is over
Name a grand fleet member who's will directly relates to that of Luffy and had a mentor die to ensure Luffy fulfills that Goal?
Did she accept being queen of the minks? No. Why would Oda make her queen of the minks but leave it unconfirmed?
Explain these to me sugar. There's no reason for her to join the "Grand fleet" when none of their wills align with Luffy's. Pedro's sacrifice meant much more than Grand Fleet. That's why Luffy mentioned Pedro against Kaido.
As I said, Jinbei and Carrot have similar wills. In the fact they take the old Captain of the crew's Will, as well as the entire Crew's Goal. Do you think it's a coincidence that the Nox Pirates = Night and the Sun Pirates = Day? Do you think it's weird that the Sun Pirates = Fishmen and the Nox Pirates = Minks. Do you find it weird that Carrot and Jinbei are practically the Opposite of one another? But both share the Same Goal in wanting Luffy to become the Pirate King and bring the Dawn? Carrot's Dream after gaining Pedro's will is going to be seeing the dawn that Luffy brings. Pedro did tell her to Keep Moving Onward while she was on the Ship of the Pirate King.
Trust me honey there's no Wrong Place to be Correct.
Did she accept being queen of the minks? No. Why would Oda make her queen of the minks but leave it unconfirmed?
Explain these to me sugar. There's no reason for her to join the "Grand fleet" when none of their wills align with Luffy's. Pedro's sacrifice meant much more than Grand Fleet. That's why Luffy mentioned Pedro against Kaido.
As I said, Jinbei and Carrot have similar wills. In the fact they take the old Captain of the crew's Will, as well as the entire Crew's Goal. Do you think it's a coincidence that the Nox Pirates = Night and the Sun Pirates = Day? Do you think it's weird that the Sun Pirates = Fishmen and the Nox Pirates = Minks. Do you find it weird that Carrot and Jinbei are practically the Opposite of one another? But both share the Same Goal in wanting Luffy to become the Pirate King and bring the Dawn? Carrot's Dream after gaining Pedro's will is going to be seeing the dawn that Luffy brings. Pedro did tell her to Keep Moving Onward while she was on the Ship of the Pirate King.
Post automatically merged:
Trust me honey there's no Wrong Place to be Correct.
Was it to betray her brothern and pop out of a random barrel just to appease her fans? lmao
This is not 2018 anymore dude, if she was gonna follow Pedro's will and protect the crew by joining she would have done that already. And she didn't. Stop coping over Pedro's will. It was a valid argument for her 5 years ago, but nothing ever came from it.
Not being there. But for getting as much screentime as she did. All she was meant to be was the white rabbit from Alice and Wonderland, a cute gimmick. But then Naito came along with his weird ass fetishes and most likely begged Oda to give her more time. You can debunk that bit all you want, but I ask again what happened to Carrot's screentime after a change in editors?
The kid literally had the same amount of panel time as Jack the drought. A very important and memorable character during the Wano arc known his massive amount of screentime and focus, who did so much during the raid.
Only thing I can think of for this is a spoiler so I can't say anything here.
I'm only saying what happened
That's not how you handle a character you have future plans to incorporate into the crew. No strawhat was written that way. Oda didn't change his style with Yamato, he's sure as fuck isn't doing it with an equally useless character.
People also believed there was no other direction for Yamato's story to go other than join the crew, and of course they were dead wrong. Why is Carrot remotely special?
This is not 2018 anymore dude, if she was gonna follow Pedro's will and protect the crew by joining she would have done that already. And she didn't. Stop coping over Pedro's will. It was a valid argument for her 5 years ago, but nothing ever came from it.
Not being there. But for getting as much screentime as she did. All she was meant to be was the white rabbit from Alice and Wonderland, a cute gimmick. But then Naito came along with his weird ass fetishes and most likely begged Oda to give her more time. You can debunk that bit all you want, but I ask again what happened to Carrot's screentime after a change in editors?
The kid literally had the same amount of panel time as Jack the drought. A very important and memorable character during the Wano arc known his massive amount of screentime and focus, who did so much during the raid.
Only thing I can think of for this is a spoiler so I can't say anything here.
I'm only saying what happened
That's not how you handle a character you have future plans to incorporate into the crew. No strawhat was written that way. Oda didn't change his style with Yamato, he's sure as fuck isn't doing it with an equally useless character.
People also believed there was no other direction for Yamato's story to go other than join the crew, and of course they were dead wrong. Why is Carrot remotely special?
Was it to betray her brothern and pop out of a random barrel just to appease her fans? lmao
This is not 2018 anymore dude, if she was gonna follow Pedro's will and protect the crew by joining she would have done that already. And she didn't. Stop coping over Pedro's will. It was a valid argument for her 5 years ago, but nothing ever came from it.
Not being there. But for getting as much screentime as she did. All she was meant to be was the white rabbit from Alice and Wonderland, a cute gimmick. But then Naito came along with his weird ass fetishes and most likely begged Oda to give her more time. You can debunk that bit all you want, but I ask again what happened to Carrot's screentime after a change in editors?
The kid literally had the same amount of panel time as Jack the drought. A very important and memorable character during the Wano arc known his massive amount of screentime and focus, who did so much during the raid.
Only thing I can think of for this is a spoiler so I can't say anything here.
I'm only saying what happened
That's not how you handle a character you have future plans to incorporate into the crew. No strawhat was written that way. Oda didn't change his style with Yamato, he's sure as fuck isn't doing it with an equally useless character.
People also believed there was no other direction for Yamato's story to go other than join the crew, and of course they were dead wrong. Why is Carrot remotely special?
This is not 2018 anymore dude, if she was gonna follow Pedro's will and protect the crew by joining she would have done that already. And she didn't. Stop coping over Pedro's will. It was a valid argument for her 5 years ago, but nothing ever came from it.
Not being there. But for getting as much screentime as she did. All she was meant to be was the white rabbit from Alice and Wonderland, a cute gimmick. But then Naito came along with his weird ass fetishes and most likely begged Oda to give her more time. You can debunk that bit all you want, but I ask again what happened to Carrot's screentime after a change in editors?
The kid literally had the same amount of panel time as Jack the drought. A very important and memorable character during the Wano arc known his massive amount of screentime and focus, who did so much during the raid.
Only thing I can think of for this is a spoiler so I can't say anything here.
I'm only saying what happened
That's not how you handle a character you have future plans to incorporate into the crew. No strawhat was written that way. Oda didn't change his style with Yamato, he's sure as fuck isn't doing it with an equally useless character.
People also believed there was no other direction for Yamato's story to go other than join the crew, and of course they were dead wrong. Why is Carrot remotely special?
Jinbei didn't join right as he was introduced either, he was introduced in the Impel Down arc and only got the invitation during Fishman Island. That's 200+ Chapters from the introduction, and then it took Jinbei 400 more chapters to even officially join the crew in Wano. What does this mean!? There's no determined or set time for someone to come to their character conclusion or have a realization about the will they just gained. Everytime someone goes "Ohh she didn't join now so she can't" is just stupid. There's clearly a plan with her character, and if there wasn't Oda would've simply left her to be the leader of Zou and have her accept the role. BUT HE DIDNT! He then continuously brings Rabbits into the next arc, highlights her in a cover page, and highlights the lack of a Lookout in chapter 1061.
The time Carrot got in Wano is different from Jack, everything Carrot did was focused on Her and Pedro. When jack was present, it was focused on other characters. Carrot during Onigashima/Wano was a character we saw with the Minks and the Strawhats constantly. Oda included her in the massive hug scene during 977, where she was placed directly in the middle....? She even starts the raid with the strawhats, and only loses track of them after she finds Perospero.
The whole "She was only relevant because of the editor" bullshit is so wild. Y'all don't know anything??? You're taking this from Naito saying he likes Carrot and wants to have children with her in a perfect world. What the hell does this have to do with One Piece or the story you're reading? Stop taking random nonsense from real world events and trying to implement it into your logic. It simply doesn't have a place. The fact you have to do that in the first place just shows you don't care about the Writing but care about your Agenda. It's awkward.
Was it to betray her brothern and pop out of a random barrel just to appease her fans? lmao
This is not 2018 anymore dude, if she was gonna follow Pedro's will and protect the crew by joining she would have done that already. And she didn't. Stop coping over Pedro's will. It was a valid argument for her 5 years ago, but nothing ever came from it.
Not being there. But for getting as much screentime as she did. All she was meant to be was the white rabbit from Alice and Wonderland, a cute gimmick. But then Naito came along with his weird ass fetishes and most likely begged Oda to give her more time. You can debunk that bit all you want, but I ask again what happened to Carrot's screentime after a change in editors?
The kid literally had the same amount of panel time as Jack the drought. A very important and memorable character during the Wano arc known his massive amount of screentime and focus, who did so much during the raid.
Only thing I can think of for this is a spoiler so I can't say anything here.
I'm only saying what happened
That's not how you handle a character you have future plans to incorporate into the crew. No strawhat was written that way. Oda didn't change his style with Yamato, he's sure as fuck isn't doing it with an equally useless character.
People also believed there was no other direction for Yamato's story to go other than join the crew, and of course they were dead wrong. Why is Carrot remotely special?
This is not 2018 anymore dude, if she was gonna follow Pedro's will and protect the crew by joining she would have done that already. And she didn't. Stop coping over Pedro's will. It was a valid argument for her 5 years ago, but nothing ever came from it.
Not being there. But for getting as much screentime as she did. All she was meant to be was the white rabbit from Alice and Wonderland, a cute gimmick. But then Naito came along with his weird ass fetishes and most likely begged Oda to give her more time. You can debunk that bit all you want, but I ask again what happened to Carrot's screentime after a change in editors?
The kid literally had the same amount of panel time as Jack the drought. A very important and memorable character during the Wano arc known his massive amount of screentime and focus, who did so much during the raid.
Only thing I can think of for this is a spoiler so I can't say anything here.
I'm only saying what happened
That's not how you handle a character you have future plans to incorporate into the crew. No strawhat was written that way. Oda didn't change his style with Yamato, he's sure as fuck isn't doing it with an equally useless character.
People also believed there was no other direction for Yamato's story to go other than join the crew, and of course they were dead wrong. Why is Carrot remotely special?
And why didn't Jinbei join the strawhats during Marineford or why didn't Luffy ask him to join after Marineford?! Because it wasn't the right time for him lmao. Oda does things the way HE WANTS. The reason Oda left her storyline unfinished and even why he left her answer to "You're leading zou" undone, is because she clearly ain't going to be doing that...?
When Carrot comes back and Oda wants to highlight on the reason why she didn't join during Wano, he can do that.
Just because something didn't go the way the Fandom wants, doesn't mean the event itself won't ever happen. You have yet to even combat the fact that her storyline during Wano was left uncomplete, and that Oda didn't have her answer for a reason. In fact, the last thing she said was "pedro...". So for what reason do you believe that means Yea. She leads Zou. This makes sense. Correct. This is what Oda has had planned since day one....... like what?
Shishillian and Wanda again, have both been given the leadership development since their INTRODUCTIONS. While Carrot got nothing but Lookout, Dawn of the World, Dying Mentor (Pedro), and Strawhat development. This is the difference.
And Jinbei and Carrot's stories do share similarities. In the fact both of them share the wills of their fallen mentors, but as well as the Pirate Crews those mentors captained.
The Sun and Nox Pirates. Day and Night... Fishman and Mink... Old and Young... Again boo it ain't rocket science, simply read.
When Carrot comes back and Oda wants to highlight on the reason why she didn't join during Wano, he can do that.
Just because something didn't go the way the Fandom wants, doesn't mean the event itself won't ever happen. You have yet to even combat the fact that her storyline during Wano was left uncomplete, and that Oda didn't have her answer for a reason. In fact, the last thing she said was "pedro...". So for what reason do you believe that means Yea. She leads Zou. This makes sense. Correct. This is what Oda has had planned since day one....... like what?
Shishillian and Wanda again, have both been given the leadership development since their INTRODUCTIONS. While Carrot got nothing but Lookout, Dawn of the World, Dying Mentor (Pedro), and Strawhat development. This is the difference.
And Jinbei and Carrot's stories do share similarities. In the fact both of them share the wills of their fallen mentors, but as well as the Pirate Crews those mentors captained.
The Sun and Nox Pirates. Day and Night... Fishman and Mink... Old and Young... Again boo it ain't rocket science, simply read.
Move over @CarrotForNakama , there's a new number one Carrot fan. I hope we can look forward to at least a year of 10000 word essays on why a minor appearance on a single color spread means Carrot is still joining the crew
Truly cannot believe we’re still getting new militant Carrot fans, or that there are even this many to begin with…at least the Yamato folks knew when to let go, but the brain rot that continues coming from the rabbit’s camp is astonishing 
I mean my man is out here writing essays about absolutely nothing
You'd think they'd learn after all the "Yamato has to join, she can't possibly be the guardian of Wano. You're coping if you don't think she's joining, read the story without your agenda" Only for Yamato not to do it and everyone got clowned on. History's literally repeating itself.
I mean my is out here writing essays about absolutely nothing
I mean my is out here writing essays about absolutely nothing
Move over @CarrotForNakama , there's a new number one Carrot fan. I hope we can look forward to at least a year of 10000 word essays on why a minor appearance on a single color spread means Carrot is still joining the crew
Here's the thing tho, everyone in this forum already made up their mind about Carrot. If you're a Carrot fan noone can change your mind and you want her to join/get a better ending, if you're a Carrot hater or don't like her, you'll still hate her and not convince anyone.
In fact in 2 more replies you're going to get 2 mods involved to join the same merry go round that always happens here, and as per usual every Carrot fan is going to be labeled a dogshit inbred monkey that can't tell their head from a toilet bowl. I mean just look at the tags in this thread.
But if you wanna get quote tagged and dogpilled be my guess, gl bro
In fact in 2 more replies you're going to get 2 mods involved to join the same merry go round that always happens here, and as per usual every Carrot fan is going to be labeled a dogshit inbred monkey that can't tell their head from a toilet bowl. I mean just look at the tags in this thread.
But if you wanna get quote tagged and dogpilled be my guess, gl bro