Who will be the next SH?


  • Total voters
    134
Bonney is the new Carrot. She looked certain to join in the last arc, then stayed for the next island and got sidelined. It's too late for her. Vivi is just cope. She's obviously going to be queen of alabasta, to think otherwise is sheer delusion. I bet she'll sail with them again later, but that's it. It's Loki or no one.
Carrot's mugi agenda while had a footing at first; ultimately was flawed because it was thought Carrot's bond with Luffy would lead to her joining but as it turns out it's to mirror them. And her role is a lot bigger.

Well I don't know why you people still read cover stories...



I always skip the cover stories (in summary and chapter):optimistic:
They can be intriguing and set up future plot threads.
 
Last edited:

Reborn

Throughout Heaven & Earth,I alone am d Honored One
So why you wont join us then?
:myman:
I don't Know....

I don't feel any connections with Loki....

I actually don't care much if he joins or not.

All I remember is...I checked this thread... saw you, reloaded and van making posts about "how Loki won't join" and I was like...okay I will argue "Loki will join".

Might be due to the fact that whenever I see reloaded name...furry image comes up in my head.

It was after this that I actually looked for the reasons why he can join....
 
Soon Yamato maybe

Going back to my poneglyph = strawhat theory


So Jinbe is already part of the crew and is from fishman island. FMI being the location of a road poneglyph and ancient weapon
He has connections with Sanji with him being a short of duo with him and fmi likely having ties to Sanji’s dream


Yamato might officially join post elbaf. Being from wano the location of an ancient weapon and road poneglyph. Wano coincidentally also has Zoro’s dream to become the wss and I can definitely see them making a duo as well. Yamato even knows his uncle


Now we got Loki another candidate to join the crew. Loki obviously being from elbaf an island potentially tied to nika and has potential to be a duo with Luffy being the Kuzan to his Blackbeard. While we don’t know if there was ever an ancient weapon or road poneglyph on the island it’s definitely possible that big mom and Imu stole them


All that being said Loki could be a red herring and not actually join due to being too important
Kinda like vivi, momonosuke, shirahoshi, and potentially carrot with their ties to the void century
Even made a thread on it in regards to carrot


If Loki and carrot are too important then who from those islands? Idk
:handsup:


They should have ties to Nami and Usopp tho. The mink being to Nami and giant Usopp


Outside of carrot and the dukes the most relevant mink to the strawhats would be Pedro Wanda and pekoms. Wanda while close with Nami isn’t so much with Luffy and the rest of the crew so that leaves Pedro and Pekoms. Both of which are definitely alive just like the fishmen pirates, vinsmoke, and pound

Zou could also tie into Nami’s dream of making a map of the whole world considering zunesha has walked the whole world. She was also given a national treasure and it’s an island in the sky


The only relevant giants to luffy besides Loki and the giant captains is colon and ripley. Maybe mosa if they’re from the heaven realm idk
:handsup:
We already know Usopp’s dream is very connected to elbaf
 
The Yamato story did not in fact end with her leaving Ulti and Pay Pay to protect Wano nor did it end with her just sailing from the country. And Blackbeard didn't invade, so that's a whole plotline down the drain.

Yamabros are you finally done? :kawak:
Not only are yamasisters done but so am i with odas ass cover stories :josad:

Easily the most boring cover story in the history of the series. Even worse than the Jinbei one, but at least that one had cute little sea kitties and sea dogs. So many more relevant characters to cover with unresolved fates and we get a year or so of Yamato screwing around just to learn that Ulti and Page One are her lapdogs now and Moria is retconned as hailing from Lano has always been a proud son of the glorious nation of Wano. Buy more overpriced Wano-themed One Piece merchandise today for a chance to get a complete set of Oniwabanshu and Hyougoro Yakuza figures and keychains at triple the initial price!

:kaidowhat:
 
Those who say loki will join bb
Lol you want giants in crew
It doesn't make sense.
...
Loki seems really has no place to go he hate elbaf citizens and they hate him and he want the world.
Unlike Yamato who loves wano even she is not from wano lol the are the opposite characters
....
So loki has to leave wano at end of elbaf arc unlike Yamato.
Unless he will have character shift like his father.
....
No better place for him other than SHs
But knowing oda I will not bet on in it.
 
Top