General & Others Next Strawhat Crew Members and the Grand Fleet
- Thread starter Guan Yu
- Start date
- Tags #carrot4prison #furries4carrot #larrot #yamato4nakama #yamatofansunite #yamatoisnakama carrot blows cry about carrot furries for nakama furries scurries i need my support carrot body pillow oni princess and the pirate king this thread stupid we're here for jew vs dizzy who wants rabbit stew yamato > carrot yamato best girl yamato finds the one piece yamato hype yamato is the last crew mate
- Status
Thanks so much for this, it's really well put together.
So I have a few thoughts on this:
So I have a few thoughts on this:
- Yamato fits the pattern for 2nd recruit very well.
- Something that was left out is that the 2nd recruit has been female (and the only female recruited in the sea).
- In contrast, the 3rd recruit has been male.
- I guess Yamato can technically qualify for both of them given her ambiguous gender.
- Something that was left out is that the 2nd recruit has been female (and the only female recruited in the sea).
- I think the 3rd recruit pattern is a bit stretched/forced. There are some parallels that I'm not sold on:
- Yamato was not introduced accompanied by her subordinates.
- Yamato was introduced defeating Ulti and rescuing Luffy.
- Momonosuke isn't Yamato's friend.
- Luffy is the one that tasked Yamato with protecting Momonosuke.
- A caveat is that Yamato regretted that she could not save Momonosuke.
- Yamato was not introduced accompanied by her subordinates.
- I guess both can actually work. If Carrot joined the crew as the 2nd recruit and Yamato as the 3rd, I wouldn't feel cheated.
- I find this very reassuring for the Yamato 4 Nakama agenda. That said, it's not something I would base the entirety of my argument upon.
- It's reassuring in the sense that: "it's a relief that Yamato fits the pattern for other female recruits" as opposed to: "this confirms Yamato 4 Nakama".
So here's a question for Yamato haters. If she's going to just decide to stay with momo and not connect more with Luffy or follow through on her dream of going out to sea, then what was the point of setting up the Ace connection and spending a whole chapter on the flashback? Why set up a different dream in a flashback when it's already supposedly irrelevant now that she can protect momo? Why involve Ace at all if that's not going to be a point of connection with Luffy?
I’m not gonna translate word for word coz my japanese isn’t perfect and it would take me forever, but he just talks about her popularity, inheriting pedros will, possibly being a lookout or apprentice, her name being a play on words (986 & ninjin), Sulong being a graceful/unique fighting style that differs from other SHs, her similarities to goku from dragon ball, and something about cards that I didn’t entirely understand (comparing each SH to tarot cards and saying the only one missing is carrot, the wild card, because the minks are wild/native people? It’s pretty dumb). Nothing that hasn’t already been said on this forum for the most part.
Also the guy in the video thinks law, Yamato, and carrot could all join at the end of wano
Also the guy in the video thinks law, Yamato, and carrot could all join at the end of wano
Last edited:
Idk why he brought up 986 because he also says chapter 986 of the manga is unrelated to carrot.
ninjin means “Carrot” in Japanese but also “2 people” and nin = 2 jin =2 which leads to chapter 22 where the cover page has luffy with white rabbits. So it’s not really a convincing theory more of just a coincidence
ninjin means “Carrot” in Japanese but also “2 people” and nin = 2 jin =2 which leads to chapter 22 where the cover page has luffy with white rabbits. So it’s not really a convincing theory more of just a coincidence
- Status