General & Others Next Strawhat Crew Members and the Grand Fleet

[JoSeungHun7335]

I don't think it requires a devil fruit. It could just be really good vision. Observation Haki could work too but she's never going to surpass Ussop or Sanji at that. It's obviously just not that impressive of a job, so it's not going to be as flashy as some of the others, but to be fair, people are arguing that Yamato should be the chronicler, and that takes even less skill. I think they're in a similar position to be honest.

Edit: I think it's funny that Yamato fans are calling me out for Carrot bias over an argument that started with me posting a giant wall of text about why Yamato has a better chance than Carrot.

@JoSeungHun7335 when did I ever hate on Yamato? The problem with arguing for two characters that are competing in some people's eyes is that everyone assumes I'm arguing against the other. I have never and will never hate on Yamato because I'm a huge Yamato fan. Don't generalize. And I never said Ussop is nothing special I said he was nothing special when he first joined, which I stand by. His shot on Sugar will probably go unrivaled by anyone else in the series, and he will no doubt go down in history as the greatest sniper who ever lived. It doesn't change the fact that he was a pretty unimpressive kid when the story began.

I never said it was you who’s hating on Yamato, but other Carrot fans here. They compared like “if you guys think Carrot is nothing special, so is Yamato” while clearly Yamato is main character in Wano arc. Carrot has never been a main character in her arc. Even Vivi who is very weak, is the main character in Alabasta arc. Yamato has extreme durability, and also has haki which is very important in NW.

And for Usopp, it’s not you also. I watched it in some youtube comment about Carrot joining, and started to hate on Usopp because Carrot fan there said that “if Carrot is nothing special, so is Usopp”. Usopp wasn’t that special, but to think of it back then most of SHP were close ranged combatants. Usopp as a sniper although he was pretty unimpressive & weakest, his far ranged combat style is important. It’s like Zoro is officially the close-ranged combatant, while Usopp is the far-ranged combatant. That’s why I didn’t reply/quote you because I wasn’t talking about you.

 

[Rootbeer]

I don't think it requires a devil fruit. It could just be really good vision. Observation Haki could work too but she's never going to surpass Ussop or Sanji at that. It's obviously just not that impressive of a job, so it's not going to be as flashy as some of the others, but to be fair, people are arguing that Yamato should be the chronicler, and that takes even less skill. I think they're in a similar position to be honest.

Helmsman is not a flashy job but Oda made it one, Musician is not either though Brook is the complete opposite of ordinary, his music can sway people, he's a talking skeleton, etc.. The Lookout if there's one will most definitely have the skill to scout further than binoculars, Oda will make extraordinary.. Robin can fly for 1 minute that's not enough.

I personally don't approve of chronicler, sake brewer or whatever..

Edit: I think it's funny that Yamato fans are calling me out for Carrot bias over an argument that started with me posting a giant wall of text about why Yamato has a better chance than Carrot.

It has nothing to do with Yamato, i hate Carrot.. She's beyond mediocre

 

[Jew D. Boy]

Yes, it literally does it Canon...
Stop creating a difference between the Anime and the Manga.
First because the Anime KNOWS THE STORY OF OP
Second Because Oda intentionally doesn't write some kind of things and let the work to the anime team
Third Because ODA writes in some circumpstances scripts for some parts of the anime and gives them details.

Like it or not, the anime is canon, and will be canon just if it doesn't contradict the manga.

Man, do you know what a false equivalence is?? Of course the anime knows what they can and can’t do, Oda tells them NOT to do certain things before he can precisely because the anime is not canon, his manga is. There’s simply no justifiable argument that’s based on anything that only happens in the anime, I’m not gonna entertain that notion.

 

[ShinmenTakezo]

I never said it was you who’s hating on Yamato, but other Carrot fans here. They compared like “if you guys think Carrot is nothing special, so is Yamato” while clearly Yamato is main character in Wano arc. Carrot has never been a main character in her arc. Even Vivi who is very weak, is the main character in Alabasta arc. Yamato has extreme durability, and also has haki which is very important in NW.

And for Usopp, it’s not you also. I watched it in some youtube comment about Carrot joining, and started to hate on Usopp because Carrot fan there said that “if Carrot is nothing special, so is Usopp”. Usopp wasn’t that special, but to think of it back then most of SHP were close ranged combatants. Usopp as a sniper although he was pretty unimpressive & weakest, his far ranged combat style is important. It’s like Zoro is officially the close-ranged combatant, while Usopp is the far-ranged combatant. That’s why I didn’t reply/quote you because I wasn’t talking about you.

Usopp is nothing special, but still better lookout than her.

 

[thedarkdragon11]

With the exception of Zoro and Sanji (which were likely included to even up early recruits), the combat level of the successive recruits after Chopper are getting higher (not necessarily more powerful than the former)... I believe that is intended for the combat level progress of each members to even up closer and closer as the story progress...

Yamato is a perfect recruit next to someone like Jinbe... I doubt Carrot and Caribou are in the same caliber as Jinbe... Those 2 need miracles to catch up...

About a lookout, Viola could've been the best candidate... Give her a CoO the way Usopp and Sanji use it, she'll be the perfect lookout...

 

[TEACH D TEACH]

Guys, Usopp uses a slingshot since he was introduced. A. Fucking. Slingshot. If that itself isnt imprrssive i dont know what is. Its like Zoro becoming WSS with Sanjis kitchen knives

Post automatically merged: Jul 4, 2021

With the exception of Zoro and Sanji (which were likely included to even up early recruits), the combat level of the successive recruits after Chopper are getting higher (not necessarily more powerful than the former)... I believe that is intended for the combat level progress of each members to even up closer and closer as the story progress...

Yamato is a perfect recruit next to someone like Jinbe... I doubt Carrot and Caribou are in the same caliber as Jinbe... Those 2 need miracles to catch up...

About a lookout, Viola could've been the best candidate... Give her a CoO the way Usopp and Sanji use it, she'll be the perfect lookout...

Momo is the GOAT lookout

 

[Finalbeta]

I don't think Usopp was exactly a Grandmaster of shooting when he joined. Not even Zoro was exactly the Grandmaster when he joined. It's obvious they improved their skill over time. If we type about potential then oh yeah...

 

[thedarkdragon11]

I don't think Usopp was exactly a Grandmaster of shooting when he joined. Not even Zoro was exactly the Grandmaster when he joined. It's obvious they improved their skill over time. If we type about potential then oh yeah...

But they've been decent with their craft when they joined, they're no average... Besides, they joined early in the series, so much room for improvement...

 

[JoSeungHun7335]

Usopp is nothing special, but still better lookout than her.

He was, but now he is. He is the Go D Usopp

 

[Finalbeta]

But they've been decent with their craft when they joined, they're no average... Besides, they joined early in the series, so much room for improvement...

Yea I don't doubt that.

 

[Roo]

Man some people spedread One Piece and it shows lol.

 

[dizzy2341]

Our complete straw hat crew

 

[Un-amed]

Our complete straw hat crew

The Anime is literally the nº1 pro-Carrot XDXD

 

[humanbeing]

If Carrot ever joins the crew she will do the same way Inu and Neko did as a stowaway

 

[Zihark95]

If Carrot ever joins the crew she will do the same way Inu and Neko did as a stowaway

Nah she already did that now she need to prove that she can be a straw hats

 

[humanbeing]

Nah she already did that now she need to prove that she can be a straw hats

Neko and Inu did it twice once as they joined WB and once as they joined Roger.

 

[Zihark95]

Neko and Inu did it twice once as they joined WB and once as they joined Roger.

So i still think that her story would more satisfiying if she joins legitimately the crew after proving her worth

 

[Sigran101]

I never said it was you who’s hating on Yamato, but other Carrot fans here. They compared like “if you guys think Carrot is nothing special, so is Yamato” while clearly Yamato is main character in Wano arc. Carrot has never been a main character in her arc. Even Vivi who is very weak, is the main character in Alabasta arc. Yamato has extreme durability, and also has haki which is very important in NW.

And for Usopp, it’s not you also. I watched it in some youtube comment about Carrot joining, and started to hate on Usopp because Carrot fan there said that “if Carrot is nothing special, so is Usopp”. Usopp wasn’t that special, but to think of it back then most of SHP were close ranged combatants. Usopp as a sniper although he was pretty unimpressive & weakest, his far ranged combat style is important. It’s like Zoro is officially the close-ranged combatant, while Usopp is the far-ranged combatant. That’s why I didn’t reply/quote you because I wasn’t talking about you.

Oh, okay sorry I completely misunderstood! Given that I was just in an argument about those exact two things I thought you were talking about me

 

[JoSeungHun7335]

Oh, okay sorry I completely misunderstood! Given that I was just in an argument about those exact two things I thought you were talking about me

No worries. Maybe it was just a coincidence, and those Carrot fans started comparing Carrot to Usopp for some reason; one of them is being weak. It’s like, it’s okay being weak in a crew because there are Weak Trio; or Usopp in general. They even say that Carrot is stronger than Usopp, because she is faster, has Sulong form & Electro. Back again, none of those matters if she doesn’t have Haki.

 

[Un-amed]

You have to be stupid, clearly stupid to say Carrot is Weak.

Just compare who damaged more Perospero.
Chopper+Brook or Wanda+Carrot.
And there you'll find how weak she is damaging a 700mb guy...

OFC it's not as strong as Yamato, or Sanji, or Luffy, or Jimbe or Zoro...But to say she's weak...