General & Others Next Strawhat Crew Members and the Grand Fleet

Who will be the next Strawhat

  • Total voters
    895
Status
Not open for further replies.
LANJI CUCKSMOKE

LANJI CUCKSMOKE

SIMPJI
‎
#8,421
#8,421
carrot's lack of focus doesnt hinder much imo

pedro's last words to her
I think she will continue to follow them.


yamato's story reminds me so much of oden
doesnt want to be shogun
rogue child of the person ruling wano
desperate to set out to sea in a closed country

I hate forced parallels but nothing is more clear than yamato and oden.
I sincerely hope folks dont think she remains in wano after her father loses.
Post automatically merged:

grand fleet options outside of this arc

well crocodile is a possibility but personally unpopular opinion
I think the grandfleet is fixed . Not getting any larger
the current ones will get stronger offscreen and thats about it
now he can have allies endgame but they wont be under his grandfleet .
 
Un-amed

Un-amed

‎
#8,423
#8,423
LANJI CUCKSMOKE said:
carrot's lack of focus doesnt hinder much imo

pedro's last words to her
I think she will continue to follow them.


yamato's story reminds me so much of oden
doesnt want to be shogun
rogue child of the person ruling wano
desperate to set out to sea in a closed country

I hate forced parallels but nothing is more clear than yamato and oden.
I sincerely hope folks dont think she remains in wano after her father loses.
Post automatically merged:

grand fleet options outside of this arc

well crocodile is a possibility but personally unpopular opinion
I think the grandfleet is fixed . Not getting any larger
the current ones will get stronger offscreen and thats about it
now he can have allies endgame but they wont be under his grandfleet .
Click to expand...
I definitely think she won't stay in Wano, but I can not see her with the mugis.
So I better wait for her resolution at this point, because everything it's unclear with Yamato xD
 
Un-amed

Un-amed

‎
#8,426
#8,426
LANJI CUCKSMOKE said:
who else would she leave wano with ......
Click to expand...
I don't care.
But Yamato doesn't want to be with Luffy because of any kind of relation with him. He just wants to be with Luffy because he's the chosen one, and I can not see any character like that as a nakama...
Yamato wanted to sail with Ace (Her first choosen one), and after he died, his second choosen one Luffy...
That's not a Nakama...

Yamato doesn't want to live an adventure, does want to live the promised adventure with the Choosen One.

Yamato has a lot of chances to join, but I prefer to wait for her resolution, because it could surprise us.
 
LANJI CUCKSMOKE

LANJI CUCKSMOKE

SIMPJI
‎
#8,427
#8,427
jmena said:
I don't care.
But Yamato doesn't want to be with Luffy because of any kind of relation with him. He just wants to be with Luffy because he's the chosen one, and I can not see any character like that as a nakama...
Yamato wanted to sail with Ace (Her first choosen one), and after he died, his second choosen one Luffy...
That's not a Nakama...

Yamato doesn't want to live an adventure, does want to live the promised adventure with the Choosen One.

Yamato has a lot of chances to join, but I prefer to wait for her resolution, because it could surprise us.
Click to expand...
think you will be disappointed man but we'll see
 
thedarkdragon11

thedarkdragon11

‎
#8,428
#8,428
jmena said:
You have to be stupid, clearly stupid to say Carrot is Weak.

Just compare who damaged more Perospero.
Chopper+Brook or Wanda+Carrot.
And there you'll find how weak she is damaging a 700mb guy...

OFC it's not as strong as Yamato, or Sanji, or Luffy, or Jimbe or Zoro...But to say she's weak...
Click to expand...
Between WCI and Wano? Nah, better compare Wano and Wano...

Chopper did better opposing Queen+Peros than Wanda+Carrot opposing Peros...

She's weak... A liability... You don't get into NW just to recruit someone like Carrot...

jmena said:
Chopper relies in Drugs...He's weak...
Zoro relies in his swords, he's weak...
Robin relies on her fruit, she's weak...
Jimbe relies on the water, he's weak...

That's bullshit, without Sulong she's as strong as Brook, Robin, Nami with the new PU, Choppah...
Click to expand...
They have those with them all the time, Carrot only have full moon once a month if it's not covered... So she's weak at most times...

Brook and Robin, really? Again, Chopper did better against Queen+Peros by not losing but Carrot+Wanda in Sulong were easily stomped by Peros solo...

jmena said:
I don't care.
But Yamato doesn't want to be with Luffy because of any kind of relation with him. He just wants to be with Luffy because he's the chosen one, and I can not see any character like that as a nakama...
Yamato wanted to sail with Ace (Her first choosen one), and after he died, his second choosen one Luffy...
That's not a Nakama...

Yamato doesn't want to live an adventure, does want to live the promised adventure with the Choosen One.

Yamato has a lot of chances to join, but I prefer to wait for her resolution, because it could surprise us.
Click to expand...
Robin was not a nakama before EL eh?
 
Walreyn

Walreyn

‎
#8,429
#8,429
jmena said:
She showed how good she was as a lookout on her introduction...She was able to jump a lot, and was able to see the mugis Inside of a forest...

I don't mind if y'all don't like the character, but denying her strength is being a lookout on the crew is funny af, when on the Raid we saw how she saw Perospero being outside the dome while she was inside...
Click to expand...
These isnt lookout feat stuff.

Being able to jump high doesnt equate to being an excellent look out, and being able to see Peros doesnt equate to that as well.

It was a feat of carrot's physical strength, but it was not a feat as a lookout. And oda didnt even make that lookout post exclusively for carrot, pedro was also shown to be a good lookout, probably even better than her.

So, nope, Carrot is inst shown excellent or remarkable as compared when doing that lookout feats, on the other hand, each current strawhats were excellent and was clearly highlighted by oda, by hinting that no one can do better than how each sh is doing with their jobs
Post automatically merged:

jmena said:
If the anime is Canon:
-Carrot has a scene where she ASKS Luffy to sail with them praising the ENTIRE crew.
-Luffy never answered so she came as a "surprise" getting on board without a yes btw.
-Has a filler arc for her +Luffy +Nami ( And I think Chopper too) Literally a filler with her "trio" xD
-Toei always put her on the same status as the crew, but because of not being an official member, isn't on the main titles etc


Toei is literally putting her as a SH always, since almost her appearance ...
Click to expand...
Who cares about toei though?
 
Electricmastro

Electricmastro

‎
#8,430
#8,430
jmena said:
I don't care.
But Yamato doesn't want to be with Luffy because of any kind of relation with him. He just wants to be with Luffy because he's the chosen one, and I can not see any character like that as a nakama...
Yamato wanted to sail with Ace (Her first choosen one), and after he died, his second choosen one Luffy...
That's not a Nakama...

Yamato doesn't want to live an adventure, does want to live the promised adventure with the Choosen One.

Yamato has a lot of chances to join, but I prefer to wait for her resolution, because it could surprise us.
Click to expand...
Well, Yamato got to see how kind Luffy is in giving her freedom and is willing to go up against strong forces like an Emperor for his sake, so it’s definitely not just her following him because of the journal, and that there’s a strong basis for a potential friendship there.
 
Garp the Fist

Garp the Fist

Bwahahahaha
‎
#8,432
#8,432
The argument has never moved on for Carrot past “next arc, I promise, it’s her time to shine!”

Her plot with Perospero will finish, there’s going to be an exposition dump at some point tying up Pedro’s last words (probably at the fire festival party celebrating the dead) then a life as a cover story awaits.

And Oda could always to back to his good old “fuck death, we’re having a party” attitude and Pedro and Pekoms will show up in time for the party instead.

And Yamato will be the one that actually becomes a member of the crew, representing the big Kozuki alliance and plotline, of which Carrot and the Minks are only one part.
 
RobinsFeet

RobinsFeet

‎
#8,434
#8,434
Tai long said:
she has not yet being introduced to the story
Click to expand...
I know. But @dizzy2341 wrote: "Our complete straw hat crew" Which is wrong because there is no Yamato there.

ShinichiMugi said:
People: "Carrot will join! No,Yamato will join! No,Momo!"
Oda: *Makes Buggy get randomly on Wano while he is escaping from World Government,and makes him join the crew*
Click to expand...
Buggy is way too op for the straw hats lol. You forgot Marineford? Mihawk could not do anything to him. Akainu and all of the Marine shit his pants when Shanks appeared, and Buggy made clear he and Shanks are on the same level. You think someone as strong as a Yonko will join the crew? Bruh
 
thedarkdragon11

thedarkdragon11

‎
#8,435
#8,435
Walreyn said:
pedro was also shown to be a good lookout, probably even better than her.
Click to expand...
Yes, Pedro is a better "lookout", being able to sense an enemy in front of them in Pudding...

Walreyn said:
Who cares about toei though?
Click to expand...
To be fair, Carrot fans do care because their being baited a lot...

ShinichiMugi said:
People: "Carrot will join! No,Yamato will join! No,Momo!"
Oda: *Makes Buggy get randomly on Wano while he is escaping from World Government,and makes him join the crew*
Click to expand...
Having Usopp in the crew is already hax, what more with Buggy on their side? That would be legendary...

RobinsFeet said:
I know. But @dizzy2341 wrote: "Our complete straw hat crew" Which is wrong because there is no Yamato there.
Click to expand...
This is more canon that the image posted:
https://twitter.com/i/web/status/1411958029533147137
 
Un-amed

Un-amed

‎
#8,436
#8,436
thedarkdragon11 said:
Yes, Pedro is a better "lookout", being able to sense an enemy in front of them in Pudding...



To be fair, Carrot fans do care because their being baited a lot...



Having Usopp in the crew is already hax, what more with Buggy on their side? That would be legendary...



This is more canon that the image posted:
https://twitter.com/i/web/status/1411958029533147137
Click to expand...
1st:
PEdro is Dead, Carrot can surpass him as a Lookout.
2nd:
Yeah that image is more Canon OFC, but just a little reminder...
CARROT ISN'T PART OF THE STRAWHAT Yet.
So what do you want for her?
To be included on that promos? To be on the Openings as a Mugi?
To be on the Color Spreads as a Mugi???

Why are you expeting Carrot to be treated as a Mugi on the comercials and marketing when she's not?
And when you got her treatment as a Mugi on the anime (And on the manga too), y'all be disrespecting the situation and saying the Anime doesn't mean anything, or the Manga just put's her as a side-character...But never recognizing she has a (big) lot of chances to be a Mugi...
 
thedarkdragon11

thedarkdragon11

‎
#8,437
#8,437
jmena said:
1st:
PEdro is Dead, Carrot can surpass him as a Lookout.
2nd:
Yeah that image is more Canon OFC, but just a little reminder...
CARROT ISN'T PART OF THE STRAWHAT Yet.
So what do you want for her?
To be included on that promos? To be on the Openings as a Mugi?
To be on the Color Spreads as a Mugi???

Why are you expeting Carrot to be treated as a Mugi on the comercials and marketing when she's not?
And when you got her treatment as a Mugi on the anime (And on the manga too), y'all be disrespecting the situation and saying the Anime doesn't mean anything, or the Manga just put's her as a side-character...But never recognizing she has a (big) lot of chances to be a Mugi...
Click to expand...
How can Carrot surpass him? The series is nearing its end, if she's not able to surpass Pedro in Wano then she doesn't deserve being a SH... That's exactly why the crew don't need someone half baked at this point...

Are you mad just by someone sharing an official promo photo?
 
Z

Zihark95

‎
#8,438
#8,438
Garp the Fist said:
The argument has never moved on for Carrot past “next arc, I promise, it’s her time to shine!”

Her plot with Perospero will finish, there’s going to be an exposition dump at some point tying up Pedro’s last words (probably at the fire festival party celebrating the dead) then a life as a cover story awaits.

And Oda could always to back to his good old “fuck death, we’re having a party” attitude and Pedro and Pekoms will show up in time for the party instead.

And Yamato will be the one that actually becomes a member of the crew, representing the big Kozuki alliance and plotline, of which Carrot and the Minks are only one part.
Click to expand...
If the story of carrot end up like that i will not consider oda a good author the build up has to payoff. Her character has been written so differently from other characters, she was a lot of the time represent like a straw hat. The story tell us that she will have her moment to shine if she does not then the story is not consistent. That my problem with people that often woth people who say carrot eat grass and she will stay a background character because they don't care about having a good story they just do not want a character they do not like to appear more often.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top