General & Others Next Strawhat Crew Members and the Grand Fleet

[Kurodiamondo]

I already explained the CP0 stuff in the post and accounted for the worst case. I also never said Wano isn't special. I'm asking who else would:
A) Know about what makes Wano special? Not something vague like the ghost that told Kaido
B) Be a danger to Wano that isn't the WG and Blackbeard?

No matter what the poneglyphs say, it's not gonna be something that prevents Yamato from going out to sea. Oda has never made someone give up their passion in favor of responsibility, duty or whatever that keeps them from it. After all, the story is about people overcoming what chains them from the freedom to do what they dream of and I hope we both agree on what Yamato's dream is.

Atleast you're honest lol. I respect it.

I have theory about what can be a danger to wano and why wano has something to counter it. But I wont go full theory mode and blow things up.

Im not saying yamato wont going to the sea. She will. Eventually everybody will going to the sea. But the question what become of yamato? As a nakama or ally it's still debatable

Honestly there's a lot that I keep than I share for the sake of not possibly spoiling

 

[Red Night]

Trust me, any respectable OR self-respecting Carrot fan abandoned this thread a long time ago, we’re left dealing with the lowest common denominators now

:laughmoji:

 

[Sigran101]

I have theory about what can be a danger to wano and why wano has something to counter it. But I wont go full theory mode and blow things up.

Im not saying yamato wont going to the sea. She will. Eventually everybody will going to the sea. But the question what become of yamato? As a nakama or ally it's still debatable

Honestly there's a lot that I keep than I share for the sake of not possibly spoiling

Please share your theory. We need something that's not utter nonsense to discuss.

 

[Logiko]

thanks for proving my point..lol
googles definition, and yours are NOT the same...
like i said...you made it up

first you said the definition was simply "acting for the crew" now your CHANGING it to "participated to the life of the crew by being the lookout"
can we please just stick to ONE definition...or take your own advice and go to google...
either way...it doesnt matter because Law acted as a combatant for the strawhats fighting beside them. hell johnny and yosaku have acted as lookout, koby navigated for a time etc..
does the fact that kureha cured nami of her sickness make her the "acting-crewmember" as a doctor at that time?

and how does that even make her chances better than yamato's when most(if not all) the strawhats were never your made up term,"active-crewmate", before they joined either?

and you do know that contributing to the "life" of the crew does not only entail ship positions right?
(fyi im playing devils advocate your term is still made up)

Google more, you obviously didn't search anything. And I'm sorry if I use different word it's simply to avoid repeating myself. But the core of the message is the same: "Participating to the life of the crew" = "acting as a crewmate.

You are using wording to avoid the fact. Carrot was a crewmate.. period.

Combattant is not an active post in a ship. Look-out is.

Again, you are trying to avoid the fact by twisting the narrative ^^
Johnny and Yosaku never acted as Look-out.
And Coby never acted as a navigator.

Plus you are comparing side cahracter with Carrot who was drawn to the look-out post more than 40 time. This is a clear case of bad faith.... again.

How does this fact makes Carrot chances better than Yamato, you are really asking me that ??

Isn't it obvious ???

It's something that never happened and there is a great argument FOR Carrot recruitment.

 

[Kurodiamondo]

Please share your theory. We need something that's not utter nonsense to discuss.

I will when it's close and its plot is picking up lol

 

[Staticshadic]

Google more, you obviously didn't search anything. And I'm sorry if I use different word it's simply to avoid repeating myself. But the core of the message is the same: "Participating to the life of the crew" = "acting as a crewmate.

You are using wording to avoid the fact. Carrot was a crewmate.. period.

Combattant is not an active post in a ship. Look-out is.

Again, you are trying to avoid the fact by twisting the narrative ^^
Johnny and Yosaku never acted as Look-out.
And Coby never acted as a navigator.

Plus you are comparing side cahracter with Carrot who was drawn to the look-out post more than 40 time. This is a clear case of bad faith.... again.

How does this fact makes Carrot chances better than Yamato, you are really asking me that ??

Isn't it obvious ???

It's something that never happened and there is a great argument FOR Carrot recruitment.

https://onepiece.fandom.com/wiki/Straw_Hat_Pirates
Oh look I did it. Carrot is not crew member nor a former crew member.

Post automatically merged: Dec 4, 2021

https://onepiece.fandom.com/wiki/Straw_Hat_Pirates
Oh look I did it. Carrot is not crew member nor a former crew member.

Well look at that carrot and Pedro are allies

https://onepiece.fandom.com/wiki/Straw_Hat_Pirates/Allies

 

[jordin]

:laughmoji:

Got anything to add for Carrot besides an emoji? No one here is making a good case for her .

 

[Kurodiamondo]

Anw since I refuse to discuss some topic, I guess I need to share something in return

After luffy asking jinbe to join, in dressrosa, gatz told that BB has 10 titanic captain

I think the 10th captain of BBP is a shipwright. After marineford arc, BBP broke their raft (parallel to merry) then ask for the marine ship in exchange of bonney. But they fail. So possibly the 10th captain is a shipwright

Shiryu give BB and crew some antidote parallel to robin giving antidote to luffy

BB releasing level 6 prisoner parallel to luffy releasing jinbe

We know aokiji is BB's ally after luffy-law alliance

After WCI, barto and cavendish openly giving information to the world that luffy has fleet/captain under SH flag. After some time, pinkbeard is introduced as captain under BB.

So what become of moria maybe give us some hint for SHs development. Still dont know what moria will do. Join as a crew or as ally or even refuse the invitation. Maybe BB asking "you also like party, right?" Is the clue

 

[Ravagerblade]

Google more, you obviously didn't search anything. And I'm sorry if I use different word it's simply to avoid repeating myself. But the core of the message is the same: "Participating to the life of the crew" = "acting as a crewmate.

You are using wording to avoid the fact. Carrot was a crewmate.. period.

Combattant is not an active post in a ship. Look-out is.

Again, you are trying to avoid the fact by twisting the narrative ^^
Johnny and Yosaku never acted as Look-out.
And Coby never acted as a navigator.

Plus you are comparing side cahracter with Carrot who was drawn to the look-out post more than 40 time. This is a clear case of bad faith.... again.

How does this fact makes Carrot chances better than Yamato, you are really asking me that ??

Isn't it obvious ???

It's something that never happened and there is a great argument FOR Carrot recruitment.

Again you are so wrong... Sir do you even have a kindergarten level of education? Because even they'd be able to tell the difference.

 

[Kuruka]

Google more, you obviously didn't search anything. And I'm sorry if I use different word it's simply to avoid repeating myself. But the core of the message is the same: "Participating to the life of the crew" = "acting as a crewmate.

You are using wording to avoid the fact. Carrot was a crewmate.. period.

Combattant is not an active post in a ship. Look-out is.

Again, you are trying to avoid the fact by twisting the narrative ^^
Johnny and Yosaku never acted as Look-out.
And Coby never acted as a navigator.

Plus you are comparing side cahracter with Carrot who was drawn to the look-out post more than 40 time. This is a clear case of bad faith.... again.

How does this fact makes Carrot chances better than Yamato, you are really asking me that ??

Isn't it obvious ???

It's something that never happened and there is a great argument FOR Carrot recruitment.

stop it lol...
I searched through google pretty extensively...none matched up to your definition..TBF maybe I missed it so link the definition if you found one that matces up, if not then stop acting like what youre saying is fact when you have to resort to lying about a simple definition.

-jonny and yosaku were literally the lookout for the ship for baratie before nami took the ship for them
-koby built the boat him and luffy used to escape alvida and navigated him to the next island
-combattant IS an active post thats literally what oda confirmed is zoro's literal position...it's even on the official onepiece website
https://one-piece.com/log/character/detail/zoro.html
carrot IS a side character and so is Yamato...the only main characters there are in the story are the current OFFICIAL members of the strawhats...carrot is a side character just like Kureha...so don't get mad because I debunked your arguement using a character that abides by YOUR OWN made up term.don't change the goal post now lol, kureha still abides by your made up definition the length of time doesn't really matter kureha was a "active-crewmate".

you're embarrassing yourself, if a strawhat has NEVER joined in that way how does that make it MORE likely to happen? weve never seen a main antagonist join yet... i guess crocodiles chances just went up
that sounds dumb
Strawhats generally follow a pattern on how they join and if being an "active crewmate" has NEVER been shown to be a requirement or EVEN a clue then it does not increase her chances in any way.

 

[YouReadItWrong]

To be honest, Carrot and Yamato have no real role in the crew.
Caribou 4 Inventory
Tama 4 Fancier

 

[Logiko]

stop it lol...
I searched through google pretty extensively...none matched up to your definition..TBF maybe I missed it so link the definition if you found one that matces up, if not then stop acting like what youre saying is fact when you have to resort to lying about a simple definition.

-jonny and yosaku were literally the lookout for the ship for baratie before nami took the ship for them
-koby built the boat him and luffy used to escape alvida and navigated him to the next island
-combattant IS an active post thats literally what oda confirmed is zoro's literal position...it's even on the official onepiece website
https://one-piece.com/log/character/detail/zoro.html
carrot IS a side character and so is Yamato...the only main characters there are in the story are the current OFFICIAL members of the strawhats...carrot is a side character just like Kureha...so don't get mad because I debunked your arguement using a character that abides by YOUR OWN made up term.don't change the goal post now lol, kureha still abides by your made up definition the length of time doesn't really matter kureha was a "active-crewmate".

you're embarrassing yourself, if a strawhat has NEVER joined in that way how does that make it MORE likely to happen? weve never seen a main antagonist join yet... i guess crocodiles chances just went up
that sounds dumb
Strawhats generally follow a pattern on how they join and if being an "active crewmate" has NEVER been shown to be a requirement or EVEN a clue then it does not increase her chances in any way.

Lmao you are seriously comparing what Coby or the Yosaku brothers did with what Carrot did during the whole arc of Totland ? Seriously ? Damn..

No, Those brother did nothing. And Koby did nothing. As for combattant, it will be a role the moment Oda officialized it IN THE STORY. Zoro is narratively a first mate, nothing else.

Weither you like it or not. Carrot was a crewmate.. And this is the first time it happen that way in the story. PERIOD.

And yes .. the fact that it happened increase her chances by miles. Only foolish people would look at 40+ panel of Carrot being a look out and say:

"yeah.. nothing happened"

---

Again you are so wrong... Sir do you even have a kindergarten level of education? Because even they'd be able to tell the difference.

Sir, you lost your self respect in the sea.

---

https://onepiece.fandom.com/wiki/Straw_Hat_Pirates
Oh look I did it. Carrot is not crew member nor a former crew member.

Post automatically merged: Dec 4, 2021

Well look at that carrot and Pedro are allies

https://onepiece.fandom.com/wiki/Straw_Hat_Pirates/Allies

Noone is talking about crew member. We are talking about crewmate.

To be honest, Carrot and Yamato have no real role in the crew.
Caribou 4 Inventory
Tama 4 Fancier

Yamato has no real role.

Carrot has been drawn more than 40 time at the look out post. Saying that she doesn't have a role is foolish at best.

 

[YouReadItWrong]

Carrot has been drawn more than 40 time at the look out post. Saying that she doesn't have a role is foolish at best.

And why a pirate crew would need a look out post?

 

[Logiko]

And why a pirate crew would need a look out post?

Because it's usefull.

 

[Outlaw]

Everyone who steps onto the Merry Go/Sunny Go is a crewmate with the asinine logic of @CarrotForNakama

Johnny and Yosaku, they are crewmates.

Mr.9 is a Crewmate along with Mr.2

Gan Fall is a crewmate

Camie and Pappang are crewmates.

Hachi is a crewmate took a bullet for Luffy

Kuma protected the Sunny for nearly 2 years they are a crewmate what the hell did Brook do for the crew he was there for five minutes before the split up, less of a crewmate then Kuma

@Garp the Fist @Van

 

[Logiko]

Everyone who steps onto the Merry Go/Sunny Go is a crewmate with the asinine logic of @CarrotForNakama

Johnny and Yosaku, they are crewmates.

Mr.9 is a Crewmate along with Mr.2

Gan Fall is a crewmate

Camie and Pappang are crewmates.

Hachi is a crewmate took a bullet for Luffy

Kuma protected the Sunny for nearly 2 years they are a crewmate what the hell did Brook do for the crew he was there for five minutes before the split up, less of a crewmate then Kuma

@Garp the Fist @Van

I can accept "compagnons" for those characters. But people who are active on the crew, like it was shown with Carrot ARE crewmates by definition.

It DOESN'T mean that they are "crew members" it's different. One is is temporary, the other is absolute

Post automatically merged: Dec 4, 2021

And why a pirate crew would need a look out post?

And before you say "no it's not Usefull".. here is a quote from my last article about the look out post:


"
A good look-out must be able to see with precision very far. For that reason, the best look-out will be the one with the best vision possible. And, if we assume that the One Piece's world is similar to our earth with it's curvature, the best look-out is the one that can go the highest.

Here are the differences of distance to hozizon in relation to the eyesights levels (if we assume that we are on a clear sky):


- A strawhat on the deck (around 5 meters above sea level): 7,98 Kilometers
- A strawhat on the lookout (around 56 meters above sea level): 26,7 Kilometers
- A strawhat that can jump high and fast (around 156 meters above sea level): 44,6 Kilometers

This is the importance of a look-out. The higher the protagonist can go, the better the job.
"

 

[RobinsFeet]

@CarrotForNakama

Imagine this scenario:

Wano is finished. Yamato is leaving Wano with the straw hats. Carrot goes back to Zou. Im not saying it will happen, just imagine it.

What would your message be to us if that happens?

 

[Logiko]

@CarrotForNakama

Imagine this scenario:

Wano is finished. Yamato is leaving Wano with the straw hats. Carrot goes back to Zou. Im not saying it will happen, just imagine it.

What would your message be to us if that happens?

Nothing special. "I was wrong" maybe "gg" I don't know.

 

[JoSeungHun7335]

Then Viola should be the look-out since her view is 4000 kms away. It really isn’t that hard to comprehend

 

[Logiko]

Then Viola should be the look-out since her view is 4000 kms away. It really isn’t that hard to comprehend

What the point of a Look-out if you can see everything ? Carrot's arc is all about discovery the world through her eyes. Viola has no wonder in her eyes.