General & Others Next Strawhat Crew Members and the Grand Fleet
- Thread starter Guan Yu
- Start date
- Tags #carrot4prison #furries4carrot #larrot #yamato4nakama #yamatofansunite #yamatoisnakama carrot blows cry about carrot furries for nakama furries scurries i need my support carrot body pillow oni princess and the pirate king this thread stupid we're here for jew vs dizzy who wants rabbit stew yamato > carrot yamato best girl yamato finds the one piece yamato hype yamato is the last crew mate
- Status
seems like your only way to argue at this point is to change the goal post...
you still have yet to take your own advice and use google (or link the definition that matches yours)
and I even took the liberty to play devils advocate...your arguement truly died at that made up definition.
but even still.. all the people I listed abided by the made up definition YOU gave.
law is a combatant, which is a defined role by oda himself law is WAY more important thn carrot at this point
kureha was the doctor
johnny and yosaku were with the strawhats for two whole arcs.
there are more...
the amount of time really doesn't matter..they adhere to YOUR definition(unless you change it again)
all of this doesn't matter still because This was NEVER shown to be a requirement or even a pattern or clue to being a strawhat.
I understand you want carrot to join and I actualy wouldnt mind her either but at this point she has not been relavent to wano's plot at all and the subplot that she was supossed to have(being her revenge) was not payed off sufficiently.
she and wanda lost to perro pretty easily.
neko came in with a fight that lasted one chapter and beat him
thats it..
compare that to ANY other strawhat with how Luffy himself had to come in there and deal with the main villian and literally SAVE his crewmates from the main villian and perro isn't even a main villian.
if that was the conclusion to carrots arc she has little chance of joining
you still have yet to take your own advice and use google (or link the definition that matches yours)
and I even took the liberty to play devils advocate...your arguement truly died at that made up definition.
but even still.. all the people I listed abided by the made up definition YOU gave.
law is a combatant, which is a defined role by oda himself law is WAY more important thn carrot at this point
kureha was the doctor
johnny and yosaku were with the strawhats for two whole arcs.
there are more...
the amount of time really doesn't matter..they adhere to YOUR definition(unless you change it again)
all of this doesn't matter still because This was NEVER shown to be a requirement or even a pattern or clue to being a strawhat.
I understand you want carrot to join and I actualy wouldnt mind her either but at this point she has not been relavent to wano's plot at all and the subplot that she was supossed to have(being her revenge) was not payed off sufficiently.
she and wanda lost to perro pretty easily.
neko came in with a fight that lasted one chapter and beat him
thats it..
compare that to ANY other strawhat with how Luffy himself had to come in there and deal with the main villian and literally SAVE his crewmates from the main villian and perro isn't even a main villian.
if that was the conclusion to carrots arc she has little chance of joining
I gave no real definition, you can find those on google. Type "crewmate".
A combattant is not a role on a ship. Kureha was not on a ship and Johnny and Yosaju never acted as crewmate on the ship.
you won't find any more crewmate. Beside Carrot and Pedro, there are none.
The amount of time really doesn't matter..they adhere to YOUR definition(unless you change it again)
all of this doesn't matter still because This was NEVER shown to be a requirement or even a pattern or clue to being a strawhat.
all of this doesn't matter still because This was NEVER shown to be a requirement or even a pattern or clue to being a strawhat.
I understand you want carrot to join and I actualy wouldnt mind her either but at this point she has not been relavent to wano's plot at all and the subplot that she was supossed to have(being her revenge) was not payed off sufficiently.
she and wanda lost to perro pretty easily.
neko came in with a fight that lasted one chapter and beat him
thats it..
compare that to ANY other strawhat with how Luffy himself had to come in there and deal with the main villian and literally SAVE his crewmates from the main villian and perro isn't even a main villian.
if that was the conclusion to carrots arc she has little chance of joining
she and wanda lost to perro pretty easily.
neko came in with a fight that lasted one chapter and beat him
thats it..
compare that to ANY other strawhat with how Luffy himself had to come in there and deal with the main villian and literally SAVE his crewmates from the main villian and perro isn't even a main villian.
if that was the conclusion to carrots arc she has little chance of joining
And if we take Whole cake into account. Carrot is way ahead of Yamato as I explained here in a post on my blog:
Post
Pretty sure I already told you NONE of the definitions on google match up with yours. so unless your gonna link me the one you found that matches up with yours...your arguement is done
why is commbatant not a role on the ship? because you said so?
ok im sorry buddy but your word holds no weight over Oda himself or the official one piece website which lists zoro as that.
if not, then tell me then what is Zoro's OFFICIAL role?
and don't even say first mate because NONE of the crew are obligated to take orders from zoro, as a proper 1st mate is supposed to do.
again what is zoros role?
and as I said before both johnny and yosaku were with the crew for TWO whole arcs and served as a lookout same as carrot.
changing the goal post again...this is getting old.
I never said BEING able to act as a post isn't a requirement. having a role is pretty important.
I said being an "active-crewmate" is not a pattern to become a strawhat...hence why NONE of the current strawhats were an "active-crewmate" before they joined.
are you seeing how your arguements are literally changing on the fly...telltale sign of someone thats losing
Carrots character arc was based on her revenge for her bond to pedro right? It doesn't matter which arc it took place in( and yes carrot was relavent in WCI) but carrots arc, which was based on her revenge for pedro was concluded INSUFFIECIENTLY. Unless pedro comes back theres no where left for her character to go to match up to the IMPACT literally every other strawhats story has made.
Yamato still has room being this is still an arc centered around her.
why is commbatant not a role on the ship? because you said so?
ok im sorry buddy but your word holds no weight over Oda himself or the official one piece website which lists zoro as that.
if not, then tell me then what is Zoro's OFFICIAL role?
and don't even say first mate because NONE of the crew are obligated to take orders from zoro, as a proper 1st mate is supposed to do.
again what is zoros role?
and as I said before both johnny and yosaku were with the crew for TWO whole arcs and served as a lookout same as carrot.
changing the goal post again...this is getting old.
I never said BEING able to act as a post isn't a requirement. having a role is pretty important.
I said being an "active-crewmate" is not a pattern to become a strawhat...hence why NONE of the current strawhats were an "active-crewmate" before they joined.
are you seeing how your arguements are literally changing on the fly...telltale sign of someone thats losing
Carrots character arc was based on her revenge for her bond to pedro right? It doesn't matter which arc it took place in( and yes carrot was relavent in WCI) but carrots arc, which was based on her revenge for pedro was concluded INSUFFIECIENTLY. Unless pedro comes back theres no where left for her character to go to match up to the IMPACT literally every other strawhats story has made.
Yamato still has room being this is still an arc centered around her.
5 seconds..
why is commbatant not a role on the ship? because you said so?
Zoro has no official role. If it was the case, it would be in the story. His narrative role is First mate. Nothing less, nothing more. A first mate is not always the one who gives order. In One Piece, a first mate, is the one who keep his captain straight. He is the voice of reason of the captain and the crew. So Zoro has the NARRATIVE role of first mate. It only needs to be officialized. Period.
Yes this is a requierement. For example, Nami was an actual active crewmate before her real recrutment on Arlong Park. Same for Robin.
Carrot's arc is not based on revenge, but the hardship of the sea. You can see that by the line Perospero gave to Carrot. Carrot still has to understand how the see can be both a wonderland and something very dangerous. By doing that, she will be good to go.
I’ve never seen you say a bad word about anyone else on this forum, really speaks volumes about dizzy as a “person” 
Lmfao. Well, well. If it isn't Roboto. The guy infamous to OJers for actually going to people's profiles and begging them to go and like his bot posts. Then after everyone got sick of his shit he took his sorry little ass to reddit to farm karma with Oda wank.
@Den_Den_Mushi remember when the whole server was laughing their asses off on discord about his reddit rage, crying over how no one on OJ liked him cuz he was a cringey spammer?
Having checked your profile it seems you're still doing the same shit here, lmao. 96 whole flipping pages of botty trash??! Oml
They don't have any likes on them this time though... Better start the begging!!
As for myself, I'm disliked by EXACTLY the right sort. Wouldn't have it any other way. Though maybe I should've just accepted Bog's request and become a mod from the very start just like he asked. Would've saved a whole lot of nonsense. I assume it's kinda too late now though lmao. Oh well. Not like any of this matters lol.
@Den_Den_Mushi remember when the whole server was laughing their asses off on discord about his reddit rage, crying over how no one on OJ liked him cuz he was a cringey spammer?
They don't have any likes on them this time though... Better start the begging!!
As for myself, I'm disliked by EXACTLY the right sort. Wouldn't have it any other way. Though maybe I should've just accepted Bog's request and become a mod from the very start just like he asked. Would've saved a whole lot of nonsense. I assume it's kinda too late now though lmao. Oh well. Not like any of this matters lol.
Pretty sure I already told you NONE of the definitions on google match up with yours. so unless your gonna link me the one you found that matches up with yours...your arguement is done
why is commbatant not a role on the ship? because you said so?
ok im sorry buddy but your word holds no weight over Oda himself or the official one piece website which lists zoro as that.
if not, then tell me then what is Zoro's OFFICIAL role?
and don't even say first mate because NONE of the crew are obligated to take orders from zoro, as a proper 1st mate is supposed to do.
again what is zoros role?
and as I said before both johnny and yosaku were with the crew for TWO whole arcs and served as a lookout same as carrot.
changing the goal post again...this is getting old.
I never said BEING able to act as a post isn't a requirement. having a role is pretty important.
I said being an "active-crewmate" is not a pattern to become a strawhat...hence why NONE of the current strawhats were an "active-crewmate" before they joined.
are you seeing how your arguements are literally changing on the fly...telltale sign of someone thats losing
Carrots character arc was based on her revenge for her bond to pedro right? It doesn't matter which arc it took place in( and yes carrot was relavent in WCI) but carrots arc, which was based on her revenge for pedro was concluded INSUFFIECIENTLY. Unless pedro comes back theres no where left for her character to go to match up to the IMPACT literally every other strawhats story has made.
Yamato still has room being this is still an arc centered around her.
why is commbatant not a role on the ship? because you said so?
ok im sorry buddy but your word holds no weight over Oda himself or the official one piece website which lists zoro as that.
if not, then tell me then what is Zoro's OFFICIAL role?
and don't even say first mate because NONE of the crew are obligated to take orders from zoro, as a proper 1st mate is supposed to do.
again what is zoros role?
and as I said before both johnny and yosaku were with the crew for TWO whole arcs and served as a lookout same as carrot.
changing the goal post again...this is getting old.
I never said BEING able to act as a post isn't a requirement. having a role is pretty important.
I said being an "active-crewmate" is not a pattern to become a strawhat...hence why NONE of the current strawhats were an "active-crewmate" before they joined.
are you seeing how your arguements are literally changing on the fly...telltale sign of someone thats losing
Carrots character arc was based on her revenge for her bond to pedro right? It doesn't matter which arc it took place in( and yes carrot was relavent in WCI) but carrots arc, which was based on her revenge for pedro was concluded INSUFFIECIENTLY. Unless pedro comes back theres no where left for her character to go to match up to the IMPACT literally every other strawhats story has made.
Yamato still has room being this is still an arc centered around her.
with his logic like that, Robin has never been a Straw Hat since archaeologist is not an active role on the ship or the sea. You only lower your intelligence trying to give common sense into him. I seriously pity French people to acknowledge him as one of them.
there are 2 rules:
1. Carrot4nakama is always right
2. If Carrot4nakama is wrong, read rule number 1
Last edited:
Mr. 9 says hi
Temporary crewmate, traveling companion or whatever, its irrelevant for Carrot joining you don't have a point..
Temporary crewmate, traveling companion or whatever, its irrelevant for Carrot joining you don't have a point..
No. Being a crewmate for Carrot (and I mean being drawn more than 40 time on a single post) is a first and one of the BIGGEST clew for Carrot's recrutement. There is no debate here.
You can't just say: "meh it didn't happened" or "meh it doesn't mean anything"
It would be insulting the intellect of Oda who put hours of his time to draw Carrot at the post.
Post automatically merged:
What would you expect from someone who forced the idea to everyone that Robin was never been a Straw Hat (although since joining Robin has been Straw Hat’s archaeologist or 考古学者) before Enies Lobby while Carrot was just to fulfill his agenda? He said that the role title on each manga doesn’t matter because we (or him) must see within the story
with his logic like that, Robin has never been a Straw Hat since archaeologist is not an active role on the ship or the sea. You only lower your intelligence trying to give common sense into him. I seriously pity French people to acknowledge him as one of them.
there are 2 rules:
1. Carrot4nakama is always right
2. If Carrot4nakama is wrong, read rule number 1
with his logic like that, Robin has never been a Straw Hat since archaeologist is not an active role on the ship or the sea. You only lower your intelligence trying to give common sense into him. I seriously pity French people to acknowledge him as one of them.
there are 2 rules:
1. Carrot4nakama is always right
2. If Carrot4nakama is wrong, read rule number 1
You would make wonders in the complosphere and the altright @JoSeungHun7335
No I won't debunk your lies again, this is just pathetic.
- Status