General & Others Next Strawhat Crew Members and the Grand Fleet

[Animangaboy]

No one needed to know. The staff put denjiro at the one place where he had a little relevancy at the time, that's all. The story of Kojirou was deeply connected to the scabbard so it's logical that he was put with them.



Yes it did, if not Oda wouldn't have spent two entire page on it.

When would you stop with the lies mn it's getting pathetic

 

[Logiko]

When would you stop with the lies mn it's getting pathetic

This is just basic analysis dude... I don't know what to tell you.

 

[Animangaboy]

Good point, but she was more impressed with the status of the fight rather than what Luffy could do.

Didn't she say that Luffy was the only 1 that can beat kaido? Where are you getting these from??

 

[Logiko]

Didn't she say that Luffy was the only 1 that can beat kaido? Where are you getting these from??

This is not enough to follow Luffy in my opinion.

 

[Animangaboy]

This is just basic analysis dude... I don't know what to tell you.

YOU SUCKS AS A ANALYSIS so idk why u trying to prove that you are the best at it cause that carrot triangle shit you do really prove, you aren't a real person

 

[RobinsFeet]

both sides are stubborn with their stances and won't back down so what's exactly the point of continuing this debate??

Reality vs delusion. This will never end. Only end of Wano can end this...

But even then most Carrot fans are so extremely delusional, I wont be surprised if even end of Wano will not end this delusion.

Its really sad if you try to understand all of this. Hoping for something that will never happen...

 

[Animangaboy]

This is not enough to follow Luffy in my opinion.

Hmmm, C4N cause at least Yamato has more than your bunny in this arc more action and character moment just like a straw hat should 😊.

 

[Blizz532]

This is not enough to follow Luffy in my opinion.

If that's not enough then I wonder what Larrot's suppose to be...

 

[Logiko]

YOU SUCKS AS A ANALYSIS so idk why u trying to prove that you are the best at it cause that carrot triangle shit you do really prove, you aren't a real person

I don't try to prove anything. You either believe me or not. I can't put knowledge into the mind of someone who doesn't want to listen.

Reality vs delusion. This will never end. Only end of Wano can end this...

But even then most Carrot fans are so extremely delusional, I wont be surprised if even end of Wano will not end this delusion.

Its really sad if you try to understand all of this. Hoping for something that will never happen...

I already explained that there was a endpoint to the CarrotforNakama theory. Go read my blog dear.

Post automatically merged: Mar 12, 2022

Ok, this is it for me for tonight, I need to sleep. I expect a lot of notification explaining to me why I'm a bad analysis so I'm not worried..

Can't wait!

Good night

 

[Animangaboy]

I don't try to prove anything. You either believe me or not. I can't put knowledge into the mind of someone who doesn't want to listen.

Because no other top YouTubers see that one hug scene and make something out of it when it's nothing but you carrot fans always trying to prove something where Oda doesn't show

 

[AL sama]

Yes it did, if not Oda wouldn't have spent two entire page on it.

oda's own setup made the fight very anticipated so he had to do that much at the very ;east

it doesn't mean carrot's defeat was the important part

 

[Ballel]

Here is a more accurate deconstruction of this panel:

Point of focus in Yellow
Line of sight in red
Composition construction in blue
And Focus helpers in black.

See, the problem is that I'm both a writer and an artist. I don't like to brag, but with you guyz I don't have a choice. I possesse both knowledge to understand properly storytelling AND composition to a high degree. So when someone like you or Sigran tries to put my back against the wall on storytelling with the antagonist or composition with that.. I usually bites hard.

Here is the proof that your analysis is (partially) wrong. Carrot is INDEED a focus in this panel. Not the only one, but A focus nonetheless. She is here the secondary subject. Much like a hidden clew.

In a panel of this importance, this is not normal. This is in fact really odd and SHOULD raises eyebrows.

Oh Btw! I forgot to add that Carrot's head (and the sun of Jinbe) are PRECISELY at the center of this panel.

 

[Animangaboy]

oda's own setup made the fight very anticipated so he had to do that much at the very ;east

it doesn't mean carrot's defeat was the important part

Thank you to give him a reality check

 

[Ballel]

what's exactly the point of continuing this debate??

The lulz

 

[Kuruka]

No. The animes shows a LASER. (Kaido's one). A rail gun is firing PROJECTILES. Stop listening to this "the anime is spoiling the manga" conspiracy bullcrap.




No. I would love to but I don't think Carrot can hurt him.. UNLESS she shows a news skill.




Yes




I didn't do anything but show the composition here.




I'm not using perpendicular lines




Yes they are



Jinbe is just the main subject not the only focus.




No. Either you believe me or not.





Me too, for both field.




Oda is known to bend his composition rule as well as the narrative ones. The golden Triangle is added to a simple centering rule here.




If this panel is just before a flashback of Pedro's words, yes. Because this panel would have an important meaning for the story.

no you showed what you WANTED TO SEE in the composition. I understand you are obseesed with carrot...I used think she had a chance as well but I never let that cloud what the manga is saying and the analysis...which you are doing...though I wouldn't even call what youre doing analysis at this point...

you drew franky's, sanji's and nami's perpendicular and you withheld(in bad faith) giving carrot a line even though her whole body is directed toward jinbe...

I notice how you keep avoiding that nami nullifies your whole arguement...

WRONG..if Carrot was the secondary focus like you said then her line would not be pointed towards jinbe...

if you're not gonna prove you're this expert on analysis then stop bringing it up. you CANT prove it thats why you won't...lol

show the art then lmao...You're all bark no bite.

carrot is not at the center of the panel only part of her is. if Oda added centering then her whole body would be front and center.. and it is not.

 

[Ballel]

more impressed with the status of the fight rather than what Luffy could do.

What kind of mental gymnastics isthis?

 

[AL sama]

This is not enough to follow Luffy in my opinion.

I thought its very obvious that yamoto wants to follow luffy cause he is ace's brother rather then anything power related

 

[TEACH D TEACH]

Cant believe you guys wasted pages on replying to dizyy and that new guy, obvious trolls. Makes the thread unreadable

 

[Finalbeta]

67 folks picking Tama as next nakama is the most shocking thing in this bailamme of a thread. In before it's not really 67.... I hope.

 

[Jew D. Boy]

A much overused meme, but by God is it applicable here

Dammit, I’m the Sunny fan here, I was gonna post this!!