General & Others Next Strawhat Crew Members and the Grand Fleet
- Thread starter Guan Yu
- Start date
- Tags #carrot4prison #furries4carrot #larrot #yamato4nakama #yamatofansunite #yamatoisnakama carrot blows cry about carrot furries for nakama furries scurries i need my support carrot body pillow oni princess and the pirate king this thread stupid we're here for jew vs dizzy who wants rabbit stew yamato > carrot yamato best girl yamato finds the one piece yamato hype yamato is the last crew mate
- Status
Yup, that's literally what said, and it's literally not what I was accused off. Now look in the mirror and read the rest of your post.
I mean, Yamato fans have been attacking me all day, but have yet to address my point about her backstory.
So you tell me...
I mean, Yamato fans have been attacking me all day, but have yet to address my point about her backstory.
So you tell me...
You skipped something
Post automatically merged:
Nami was already a SH, dumb comparassion
Since when does the character flashbacks play a role in their joining? Luffy doesnt know or cares about the past of any of his nakama, and Tama barely had a flashback at all, it was like, 6 panels and all focused on Ace. The flashbacks are there to show why they are the way they are, from their dream to why it makes sense for them to join, and Yamato's flashback absolutely does that
my point was that her character was sidelined to be Momo's cheerleader/reaction buddy when she was still a capable fighter
Her plot about being imprisoned by her father seemed like an afterthought and was never brought up while Kaido was fighting Luffy, or after he went down. In her own arc, getting this kind of treatment doesn't feel like a strawhat for me at all.
It becomes even weirder when you think that Luffy might have killed her father, all she does is smile to momo and luffy like :) and you realize that just last arc, Sanji not being able to leave his abuse family behind was portrayed in a very positive light.
It's no about the flashback, it's about how her character is treated during "her arc" that doesn't seem like she's being set up to become a SH
Caribou has his spot guaranteed, he doesn't need to bother with showing up in the chapters
No, he fought Krieg because he wanted and to pay his debt to Zeff
What would you want her to do? She had already saved the whole raid twice and fought a Yonko 1v1, and all strong combatants were down already, plus she is one of the only people that actually saw Kaido's full on defeat
Did you forget how big Zoro's flashback was? or Usopp's? plus theres no reason to assume we cant get more later this arc or in another
Why would it? Luffy doesnt know shit and its not relevant to the fight, plus we are only now starting to get the closure to the raid
Cant do anything for you in that regard
Its almost like they are 2 different characters, and while Sanji was mistreated he managed to leave and find a new father while Yamato spent 20 years living with a monster, plus Kaido is definitely not dead
Post automatically merged:
What would you want her to do? She had already saved the whole raid twice and fought a Yonko 1v1, and all strong combatants were down already, plus she is one of the only people that actually saw Kaido's full on defeat
Did you forget how big Zoro's flashback was? or Usopp's? plus theres no reason to assume we cant get more later this arc or in another
Why would it? Luffy doesnt know shit and its not relevant to the fight, plus we are only now starting to get the closure to the raid
Cant do anything for you in that regard
Its almost like they are 2 different characters, and while Sanji was mistreated he managed to leave and find a new father while Yamato spent 20 years living with a monster, plus Kaido is definitely not dead
Last edited:
You're asking me how I would write it, but I'm only pointing out how things played out, she was sidelined
Again, it's not about the size of the flashback, but it and her character overall relevance to this arc conclusion.
Luffy knew about how her father treated her, and this fight should be the most important thing to happen in her life, but it doesn't feel like it
I get they are a different character, but my point is how the morals of the story would seem conflicting, it's not a hard refutation, like I said it would just feel really weird
I know damn well that you were full of shit lol
hinting at something once a week ago, and never having mentioned it before or after, is not "to keep saying" something.
You still can't back up what you said with further proves that you really thought that lying about it would be an easy way to dismiss my post.
Again, it's not about the size of the flashback, but it and her character overall relevance to this arc conclusion.
Luffy knew about how her father treated her, and this fight should be the most important thing to happen in her life, but it doesn't feel like it
I get they are a different character, but my point is how the morals of the story would seem conflicting, it's not a hard refutation, like I said it would just feel really weird
I know damn well that you were full of shit lol
hinting at something once a week ago, and never having mentioned it before or after, is not "to keep saying" something.
You still can't back up what you said with further proves that you really thought that lying about it would be an easy way to dismiss my post.
You're asking me how I would write it, but I'm only pointing out how things played out, she was sidelined
Again, it's not about the size of the flashback, but it and her character overall relevance to this arc conclusion.
Luffy knew about how her father treated her, and this fight should be the most important thing to happen in her life, but it doesn't feel like it
I get they are a different character, but my point is how the morals of the story would seem conflicting, it's not a hard refutation, like I said it would just feel really weird
I know damn well that you were full of shit lol
hinting at something once a week ago, and never having mentioned it before or after, is not "to keep saying" something.
You still can't back up what you said with further proves that you really thought that lying about it would be an easy way to dismiss my post.
Again, it's not about the size of the flashback, but it and her character overall relevance to this arc conclusion.
Luffy knew about how her father treated her, and this fight should be the most important thing to happen in her life, but it doesn't feel like it
I get they are a different character, but my point is how the morals of the story would seem conflicting, it's not a hard refutation, like I said it would just feel really weird
I know damn well that you were full of shit lol
hinting at something once a week ago, and never having mentioned it before or after, is not "to keep saying" something.
You still can't back up what you said with further proves that you really thought that lying about it would be an easy way to dismiss my post.
- Status