General & Others Next Strawhat Crew Members and the Grand Fleet
- Thread starter Guan Yu
- Start date
- Tags #carrot4prison #furries4carrot #larrot #yamato4nakama #yamatofansunite #yamatoisnakama carrot blows cry about carrot furries for nakama furries scurries i need my support carrot body pillow oni princess and the pirate king this thread stupid we're here for jew vs dizzy who wants rabbit stew yamato > carrot yamato best girl yamato finds the one piece yamato hype yamato is the last crew mate
- Status
Bruh...
Tama was included in all panels of Yamato's first meeting with the crew for no apparent reason...
She was also front and center on that goodbye panel, getting a more prominent spot than even Yamato, without even having to appear in the rest of the chapter. :cheers:
Correct me if I'm wrong, but after losing to Perospero, was Carrot ever seen with the strawhats again outside that bath background appearance that had Tama on the foreground saying she wanted to be like Nami?
She was also front and center on that goodbye panel, getting a more prominent spot than even Yamato, without even having to appear in the rest of the chapter. :cheers:
Correct me if I'm wrong, but after losing to Perospero, was Carrot ever seen with the strawhats again outside that bath background appearance that had Tama on the foreground saying she wanted to be like Nami?
Tama was included in all panels of Yamato's first meeting with the crew for no apparent reason...
She was also front and center on that goodbye panel, getting a more prominent spot than even Yamato, without even having to appear in the rest of the chapter. :cheers:
Correct me if I'm wrong, but after losing to Perospero, was Carrot ever seen with the strawhats again outside that bath background appearance that had Tama on the foreground saying she wanted to be like Nami?
She was also front and center on that goodbye panel, getting a more prominent spot than even Yamato, without even having to appear in the rest of the chapter. :cheers:
Correct me if I'm wrong, but after losing to Perospero, was Carrot ever seen with the strawhats again outside that bath background appearance that had Tama on the foreground saying she wanted to be like Nami?
Last edited:
Tama was included in all panels of Yamato's first meeting with the crew for no apparent reason...
She was also front and center on that goodbye panel, getting a more prominent spot than even Yamato, without even having to appear in the rest of the chapter. :cheers:
Correct me if I'm wrong, but after losing to Perospero, was Carrot ever seen with the strawhats again outside that bath background appearance that had Tama on the foreground saying she wanted to be like Nami?
She was also front and center on that goodbye panel, getting a more prominent spot than even Yamato, without even having to appear in the rest of the chapter. :cheers:
Correct me if I'm wrong, but after losing to Perospero, was Carrot ever seen with the strawhats again outside that bath background appearance that had Tama on the foreground saying she wanted to be like Nami?
Didn't we see her during Momo's speech while Tama was crying in Nami's arms?
Didn't we see her with the Minks during the party? (where Tama was later seen with Nami and Zeus I might add)
I do sympathize with Carrot fans, Oda really did you guys dirty by ending her story with her obeying Perospero like that. Forming the new nox pirates would have been a more dignified end.
But you just have to accept that Oda really likes his villains. This is exactly the same thing as the arguments around Yamato not staying to guard Wano because that would be doing exactly what Kaido told her to do.
Didn't we see her with the Minks during the party? (where Tama was later seen with Nami and Zeus I might add)
Post automatically merged:
I do sympathize with Carrot fans, Oda really did you guys dirty by ending her story with her obeying Perospero like that. Forming the new nox pirates would have been a more dignified end.
Post automatically merged:
But you just have to accept that Oda really likes his villains. This is exactly the same thing as the arguments around Yamato not staying to guard Wano because that would be doing exactly what Kaido told her to do.
Last edited:
What double standard? I just listened her appearances after the raid since he said she didn't have time during the raid. I took the opportunity to compare it to Tama's appearances at a similar time since the evnsater guy implied Tama didn't appear with the stawhats as much with his "coming from a Tama fan" post. I also compared Carrot and Yamato's moments in equal footing.
Please explain what you mean by double standards. The only thing I can think of is that one panel of Tama with the gifters, but using that would be disingenuous since Tama was also seen with Nami during the festival.
Please explain what you mean by double standards. The only thing I can think of is that one panel of Tama with the gifters, but using that would be disingenuous since Tama was also seen with Nami during the festival.
Last edited:
We back to Carrot? She has many glaring issues when it comes to being a SH.
1) She completely lacks a backstory. All of the SHs didn't have an easy past and their struggles shaped them into who they are today, along with being a big part of the themes of their recruitment arc. Carrot seems to have been completely happy with Zou with the biggest conflict among the Minks being the Dukes' bickering.
2) Each SH was a major part of their recruitment arcs in both execution wise and thematically. They contrasted the main villain and needed Luffy and the SHs to solve their problems. Carrot's biggest role was in WCI and she was a supporting character at best, having little to do with the overarching themes. In Wano, she has even less to do with the themes and was completely separated from the main conflict along with getting off paneled. The 2 closest things she had to an arc villain, being Jack and Perospero, were supporting villains who got beaten by other characters.
Carrot so far lacks the biggest things that all the other SHs share, and the best arguments for Carrot so far is that either Carrot is so special that she'll be the first SH who doesn't need them, or that Oda might do something later to swerve the reader.
1) She completely lacks a backstory. All of the SHs didn't have an easy past and their struggles shaped them into who they are today, along with being a big part of the themes of their recruitment arc. Carrot seems to have been completely happy with Zou with the biggest conflict among the Minks being the Dukes' bickering.
2) Each SH was a major part of their recruitment arcs in both execution wise and thematically. They contrasted the main villain and needed Luffy and the SHs to solve their problems. Carrot's biggest role was in WCI and she was a supporting character at best, having little to do with the overarching themes. In Wano, she has even less to do with the themes and was completely separated from the main conflict along with getting off paneled. The 2 closest things she had to an arc villain, being Jack and Perospero, were supporting villains who got beaten by other characters.
Carrot so far lacks the biggest things that all the other SHs share, and the best arguments for Carrot so far is that either Carrot is so special that she'll be the first SH who doesn't need them, or that Oda might do something later to swerve the reader.
- Status