General & Others Oda is a good or bad writer?
- Thread starter Shadow Asgard
- Start date
Actually I dont.
Why?
Because on several other threads I've said my mind on things I don't like on Oda's writing, decisions he make that serves no purpose, etc.
I'm not gonna repeat myself each time someone asks me to do it.
You think I'm your high school teacher or something?
Want an example?
The scabbards fight against Kaido is completely useless.
It builds up to Zoro scarring Kaido only to be reduced to a middle of chapter thing that immediately gets overshadowed by Luffy mastering CoC coating 1 page later.
More?
The "stairs climb" that lasted multiple chapters for the sole reason of dragging the story enough so we would get Luffy's chapter at the 1000 milestone.
Why?
Because on several other threads I've said my mind on things I don't like on Oda's writing, decisions he make that serves no purpose, etc.
I'm not gonna repeat myself each time someone asks me to do it.
You think I'm your high school teacher or something?
Want an example?
The scabbards fight against Kaido is completely useless.
It builds up to Zoro scarring Kaido only to be reduced to a middle of chapter thing that immediately gets overshadowed by Luffy mastering CoC coating 1 page later.
More?
The "stairs climb" that lasted multiple chapters for the sole reason of dragging the story enough so we would get Luffy's chapter at the 1000 milestone.
Like who ?
state one
Man , oda is the best story writer
He is flaws is nearly not seen
انت مفروض عربى
بالعكس ارك الكعكة اكتر ارك اندرريتد
و فعلا ارك عظيم بس الناس بتكرهه عشان اسباب تافهة
Lol they are waiting for this moment to revenge but they just lost , and it was the first time we saw kaido fight seriously
By your logic you can say that marineford is useless 😂
Why separating the streahats is bad?
it eas a sneaking mission
It is not a war , so they dont have to take full squad
I wonder how it is a one piece blogger and only two knowa that oda ia a genius 😂
state one
Man , oda is the best story writer
He is flaws is nearly not seen
Post automatically merged:
انت مفروض عربى
بالعكس ارك الكعكة اكتر ارك اندرريتد
و فعلا ارك عظيم بس الناس بتكرهه عشان اسباب تافهة
Post automatically merged:
Actually I dont.
Why?
Because on several other threads I've said my mind on things I don't like on Oda's writing, decisions he make that serves no purpose, etc.
I'm not gonna repeat myself each time someone asks me to do it.
You think I'm your high school teacher or something?
Want an example?
The scabbards fight against Kaido is completely useless.
It builds up to Zoro scarring Kaido only to be reduced to a middle of chapter thing that immediately gets overshadowed by Luffy mastering CoC coating 1 page later.
More?
The "stairs climb" that lasted multiple chapters for the sole reason of dragging the story enough so we would get Luffy's chapter at the 1000 milestone.
Why?
Because on several other threads I've said my mind on things I don't like on Oda's writing, decisions he make that serves no purpose, etc.
I'm not gonna repeat myself each time someone asks me to do it.
You think I'm your high school teacher or something?
Want an example?
The scabbards fight against Kaido is completely useless.
It builds up to Zoro scarring Kaido only to be reduced to a middle of chapter thing that immediately gets overshadowed by Luffy mastering CoC coating 1 page later.
More?
The "stairs climb" that lasted multiple chapters for the sole reason of dragging the story enough so we would get Luffy's chapter at the 1000 milestone.
By your logic you can say that marineford is useless 😂
Post automatically merged:
Why separating the streahats is bad?
it eas a sneaking mission
It is not a war , so they dont have to take full squad
Post automatically merged:
I wonder how it is a one piece blogger and only two knowa that oda ia a genius 😂
Last edited:
The answer to that question would require actual knowledge on what constitutes a "good writer". Most people usually don't have that and are just gonna make judgements based on stuff they liked/disliked. Which they don't understand is entirely separate.
However one thing that should be pointed out is that I keep seeing the mention of "flaws" as if that were relevant to the discussion. EVERYTHING has flaws. A story/writer doesn't have to be flawless to be considered good. It'd be insane to expect every story or author to be perfect because nothing is. Having flaws doesn't mean a story isn't good. Having flaws doesn't mean an author isn't good at his craft. In the same way that a castle having a few cracks in it doesn't mean it's not a well built castle.
Good writers are good writers not because their flaws don't exist but because their good points outweighs all of that. Theres plenty of issues to take with Togashi, Araki, Kentaro Miura etc. Doesn't mean they're not all excellent at what they do.
To think that Oda of all people isn't up there with the best is nothing short of crazy talk.
However one thing that should be pointed out is that I keep seeing the mention of "flaws" as if that were relevant to the discussion. EVERYTHING has flaws. A story/writer doesn't have to be flawless to be considered good. It'd be insane to expect every story or author to be perfect because nothing is. Having flaws doesn't mean a story isn't good. Having flaws doesn't mean an author isn't good at his craft. In the same way that a castle having a few cracks in it doesn't mean it's not a well built castle.
Good writers are good writers not because their flaws don't exist but because their good points outweighs all of that. Theres plenty of issues to take with Togashi, Araki, Kentaro Miura etc. Doesn't mean they're not all excellent at what they do.
To think that Oda of all people isn't up there with the best is nothing short of crazy talk.
Oda, like every writer, has his strengths and weaknesses. His strengths are being able to create a vibrant setting with well established rules, as well as creating instantly likeable characters even on the fly.
His weaknesses, imo, is his sometimes messy arc finishes due to his pension on creating so many characters, and sometimes neglecting to develop them after their initial appearance, instead just regurgitating their same schtick.
overall, I think his pros outweigh his cons.
His weaknesses, imo, is his sometimes messy arc finishes due to his pension on creating so many characters, and sometimes neglecting to develop them after their initial appearance, instead just regurgitating their same schtick.
overall, I think his pros outweigh his cons.
