Reread what I said above because you clearly did not
"Luf-fy did not defeat Kaido, he made him dizzy and made him fall into lava"
"Luf-fy did not defeat Katakuri, he made him dizzy and he stood up again"
"Luf-fy did not defeat Doflamingo, he made him dizzy and broke his glasses"
No they were
not dizzy but actually defeated...
Thats the difference. On the other hand the whole porpuse by Oda of the star attack was to take Kizaru out of plot without actually defeating him.
For the sake of the plot Kizaru took a
small break to get back to normal state, but he couldve easily continue fighting
if Luffy wasnt taken out of the plot with his time limit excuse and kept pursuing him.
There is a huge difference between that and actual defeats of Doffy, Katakuri, Kaido,... You gotta be insanely biased to not even admit that.