Spoiler One Piece Chapter 1110 Spoilers Discussion

[zenox]

All of them earned their captian spots after rox downfall when they were essentially rookies
You'd be insane to call captains of huge crews as commanders

they were quite literally commanders, its not like commanders cant become captains

and its hilarious how u skipped aokiji

 

[HellBlazer04]

Why no?

Beckman has better portrayal than King/Marco/Kata

And EOS Shiryu is one of Zoro's final opponents

Shiryu the sneak merchant won't be challenge to Zoro in a head on fight.
Beckman has nothing in this story that supports him being top tier

 

[ConquistadoR]

Yes

So Venus - a Undead Horse Centaur - can be a swordsman but Shanks the CoC user is an exception?

 

[Cruxroux]

Yeah I’m well aware? But cmon they’re clearly high tiers without it. Not stronger than those worth over a billion berries, but I’d take either of them over cracker and smoothie.

Luffy would have lost against Cracker if not for nami.
And luffy is probably the strongest among three.
Smoothie is controversial nothing of her haki prowess and df is known to us.

 

[DKI]

@Gauntlet
Like zoro would have definitely won without any interference or anything he just would’ve taken longer. With him needing the one thing to really push him
Without it he still would’ve probably won but it’d be a significantly harder fight

Basically Zoro is Michael Jordan of One Piece.
GOAT confirmed.

Sanji: Zoro you are a deadweight!
Zoro:

 

[HellBlazer04]

they were quite literally commanders, its not like commanders cant become captains

and its hilarious how u skipped aokiji

Already addressed the Kuzan point. Not gonna say it again

 

[Cruxroux]

Wrong.

That's a punch genius.

 

[HellBlazer04]

He already fought a YC1.
You think oda gonna give him yc1 as his next opponent as well?

Yes obviously because his next opponent is most likely Shiryu

 

[sanjikun]

The rank of commander is worthless amongst the Top Tiers. But that doesn't mean someone can't be Top Tier if they're a commander. Aokiji is the clear counterexample.

It's like Vice-Admiral rank. It means nothing amongst the heavy-weights. But there are some super strong Vice Admirals.

 

[Artem]

Acoc

 

[Etzel Andergast]

How Shyriu will be as menacing than Venus? No way Oda wont give more updates to him

 

[TheKnightOfTheSea]

they were quite literally commanders, its not like commanders cant become captains

and its hilarious how u skipped aokiji

he's just changing goalposts lol, don't bother

 

[Sir Yasheen]

Luffy would have lost against Cracker if not for nami.
And luffy is probably the strongest among three.
Smoothie is controversial nothing of her haki prowess and df is known to us.

Law and Kid and Luffy genuinely were pretty close in power post timeskip imo. Law and Kid as dead equals and Luffy as just barely stronger (genuinely I think law would win 1v1 since Luffy sucks against smart fighters)

 

[Tejas]

That's a punch genius.

No. It's G5 shenanigans. So is this which took out Pizzaru

 

[Ssg super suit coby]

@Moegara and @Ssg super suit coby wants to claim that Nika didnt beated Lucci while Lucci himself admits to it and that he doesn't stand a chance against Nika

Another Bullshitter I see. Never once stated he didn't beat him. Stated he didn't knock him out flat unconscious. Why? Because the fight ended before Luffy could do so since he reverted into an old man

 

[Shiroyru]

So Venus - a Undead Horse Centaur - can be a swordsman but Shanks the CoC user is an exception?

Venus fights like a swordsman. Shanks fights like a pirate

 

[HellBlazer04]

he's just changing goalposts lol, don't bother

How am I changing goalpost?
All of those characters have other more important titles that portray them as top tiers. Is that not clear enough they are not commanders.
Zoro will get to that same category at Eos

 

[Franosuke]

Venus fights like a swordsman. Shanks fights like a pirate

And Zoro fights like an acrobat

 

[sanjikun]

Luffy would have lost against Cracker if not for nami.

This is a certified garbage take.

 

[dalbajobas]

can't wait for all the bullshit Oda will pull for everyone to survive without a scratch

Oh boy, I bet that ancient Robot is gonna be one of the biggest bullshits ever