Break Week Primebeard was stronger than Roger

#5
He was weaker than or equal to Prime Roger, he could never beat him no matter how hard he tried. Prime Non Sick Roger was God Valley Roger 40 years ago- 47 years ago.

The One Piece magazine 9 states that Whitebeard used to clash with Roger and grew to his level 2 years after God Valley.

Xebec was Roger's true equal in fighting strength and as a pirate as well.
 
#6
WB reached his prime at 38.

WB was born 1450
WB (with Oden) and Roger fought 1496
WB was 46 at that time.

God Valley was 38y from present. so at 1486
10y before Roger and WB fought.
WB was 36 at that time.

WB during God Valley was still 2y away from becoming prime.
WB vs Roger was prime WB.


hopefully I got the timelines right
:cheers:

EDIT: WB was born 1450, not 1454
 
Last edited:

Fujishiro

Melon Farmer / Lemon Drinker
.
#11
He was weaker than or equal to Prime Roger, he could never beat him no matter how hard he tried. Prime Non Sick Roger was God Valley Roger 40 years ago- 47 years ago.

The One Piece magazine 9 states that Whitebeard used to clash with Roger and grew to his level 2 years after God Valley.
Every single thing that came out of your mouth was pure headcanon. As per usual.
2 years after god valley Roger wasnt sick lmao, and the vivre card states that during roger's era he was WSM, Roger became Pk a decade or so later.
The fact is WB was WSM even while roger was alive and in prime, therefore WB>Roger. Even if its just by a tiny bit, he was still considered the strongest.
Post automatically merged:

But another question is

Was Primebeard also WSS? :smart:

Or does his weapon not count for any chance?
WSM englobes everything so i fail to see your point.
By title WSM supercedes WSS
Post automatically merged:

we saw them fight .... and we saw then being equal .... how in the fuck name title should matter when in real life WB didn't overpowered Roger?

manga itself consider Roger as the highest level of power

WB get hype cause he was equal to Roger not the otherway around
Akainu and aokiji are also ''equal'' , we saw a friendly fight, they never fought to the death and im betting on WSM WB to win that.
When did the manga consider Roger the highest level of power lmfao? Its WB people keep mentioning everwhere when it comes to pure might.
 
Last edited:
#12
Every single thing that came out of your mouth was pure headcanon. As per usual.
2 years after god valley Roger wasnt sick lmao, and the vivre card states that during roger's era he was WSM, Roger became Pk a decade or so later.
The fact is WB was WSM even while roger was alive and in prime, therefore WB>Roger. Even if its just by a tiny bit, he was still considered the strongest.
Post automatically merged:


WSM englobes everything so i fail to see your point.
By title WSM supercedes WSM
Whitebeard could only stalemate Roger. Even the narrarator of the story call Whitebeard the equal of Roger. So no, Whitebeard was never stronger than Roger.
 

Fujishiro

Melon Farmer / Lemon Drinker
.
#13
PK title isn't tightly related to strength indeed.

Roger became PK after he was gifted 3 PG out of 4 and as regards the fourth, he sneakily stole it rather than conquering it after a open battle.

BTW Luffy's path is harsher than Roger's, he has actually to battle for almost every PG
Ehhhhh, he got handed one for free on Zou and then got brook to steal one from BM, i still agree with you in that the atmosphere rn is way harsher to become PK than when Roger did it.
Post automatically merged:

Whitebeard could only stalemate Roger. Even the narrarator of the story call Whitebeard the equal of Roger. So no, Whitebeard was never stronger than Roger.
What the hell do you mean could only stalemate him? Buggy isnt the narrator mate, and buggy said that WB was Rogers equal but that doesnt mean much, two people can be ''equal'' (Akainu and aokiji) but with one besting the other in a drawn out fight.
I am sorry but world strongest man> Roger who was a man when WB had this very title.
 
#14
Titles are good and all but we are talking about a story where the main guys are straw hats bearers, where COC seems to be the rarest power and the more unique one, where the PK title is the most important thing and the main goal of the MC. No way that WB was superior to Roger. They can be equal or Wb can be 0,1% weaker. Roger was a demon when fighting. This is a shonen, willpower > everything else, and goal of the MC > the rest.
 
#16
Ehhhhh, he got handed one for free on Zou and then got brook to steal one from BM, i still agree with you in that the atmosphere rn is way harsher to become PK than when Roger did it.
Post automatically merged:


What the hell do you mean could only stalemate him? Buggy isnt the narrator mate, and buggy said that WB was Rogers equal but that doesnt mean much, two people can be ''equal'' (Akainu and aokiji) but with one besting the other in a drawn out fight.
I am sorry but world strongest man> Roger who was a man when WB had this very title.
The Narrarator at the end of arc calls Whitebeard Roger's equal. One Piece Chapter 577 SO you are who is wrong.
 
#18
quite possible
why do people think wb didnt grow after he faced off with roger for the last time
he was younger than current shanks when they faced off
can shanks still grow stronger?
yes
then so can wb
at his absolute peak he could technically be stronger than roger.
 
Top