- Status
Even on the second reread, I still think this plan is bad.
If the cult start sacrificing their members to get more, it will be fresh reads again for us town. What is there stopping them from sacrificing the members that town is getting the most suspicious of?
We are just giving up our lynch ability. And even if somehow we get rid of all of the cult, it's not the end, there's still neutral players.
Why?
Are you claiming something?
If the cult start sacrificing their members to get more, it will be fresh reads again for us town. What is there stopping them from sacrificing the members that town is getting the most suspicious of?
We are just giving up our lynch ability. And even if somehow we get rid of all of the cult, it's not the end, there's still neutral players.
Why?
Are you claiming something?
Would you rather try and grab consistent reads on every player without having to worry about if they're scum? If your last day experience with them is worthless?
Again; We have no TI we can concretely trust. Yo Tan says Nat is good, but why do we believe him? What reason do we have? He is as confirmed as someone like Chrono. Or someone like me.
What is the plan, if we keep the current course? Question toughly and hope we get the right targets?
Again; We have no TI we can concretely trust. Yo Tan says Nat is good, but why do we believe him? What reason do we have? He is as confirmed as someone like Chrono. Or someone like me.
What is the plan, if we keep the current course? Question toughly and hope we get the right targets?
So we're down 2 scum and 1 of the scum, Cult Leader, will be found in the first day's postings.
So, we have the chance of narrowing down the most important Cult figure and that he'd kill 2 of his own? That is a massive boost / better scenario than nothing.
[automerge]1589342171[/automerge]
He can play the same way and still be scum.
So, we have the chance of narrowing down the most important Cult figure and that he'd kill 2 of his own? That is a massive boost / better scenario than nothing.
[automerge]1589342171[/automerge]
He can play the same way and still be scum.
@TheAncientCenturion you look afraid. Why?
Yes it's challenging to win and that's what mafia is all about.
Yes it's challenging to win and that's what mafia is all about.
1 Neutral in Flowers
2 Cult
1 Potential Convert
3 dead townies already
As of now, we're at 13 Townies. If we mislynch today and cult converts another person?
We're at 11 townies, cult is at 4. And we have 1 Neutral. Check to make sure my math is correct, but that's a horrible scenario to be in.
[automerge]1589342490[/automerge]
Because I think we fucked up by having our TI revealed so early on and with Observer gone. I have no reason to trust anyone of you guys. I don't think my reads have any strong validity, being carried over from one day to the next. And I think this is the case for everyone.
We're essentially playing by luck if we keep up with a classic format.
2 Cult
1 Potential Convert
3 dead townies already
As of now, we're at 13 Townies. If we mislynch today and cult converts another person?
We're at 11 townies, cult is at 4. And we have 1 Neutral. Check to make sure my math is correct, but that's a horrible scenario to be in.
[automerge]1589342490[/automerge]
Because I think we fucked up by having our TI revealed so early on and with Observer gone. I have no reason to trust anyone of you guys. I don't think my reads have any strong validity, being carried over from one day to the next. And I think this is the case for everyone.
We're essentially playing by luck if we keep up with a classic format.
- Status