Questions & Mysteries Should Straw Hats Vs Kaido happen?

[Celestial D. Dragon]

The scabbards are above the weaker straw hats tho so this isn’t a good argument.

That doesn't matter. The scabbards abilities are all pretty straight forward. The Straw Hats all have tricky abilities which would allow them to be a nuisance to Kaido. It would be a very different type of fight.

Kaido ain't an idiot and hilariously weak like oars, one shot everyone bar Luffy and Zoro.

Oars demolished the Straw Hats and would have killed them had Luffy not shown up. What do you mean "Hilariously weak?"

 

[M944]

Nope Luffy don't need those weaklings now
They will just slow him down

Their role was established they will clear the fodders until Luffy defeat Kaido and come back like they did at EL

People seems to forget Kaido's side have 20000 mens and Alliance only 7000

 

[sneko]

Oars demolished the Straw Hats and would have killed them had Luffy not shown up. What do you mean "Hilariously weak?"

Yes, you're right about that but Kaido is miles stronger, one hit from him and they're ko, oars couldn't ko any of the stawhats despite multiples hits they received from him and he had moria assisting him in the fight here and there. The sh are not like law with his annoying fruit ability, and they're not faster than kaido to escape from his attack, luffy with fs couldn't doged his attack comfortably.

 

[stairs-kun]

Zoro

 

[Salah WG]

Nine Shadows will Defeat Kaido
Nothing changed about that

 

[zzShinichi]

Honestly, maybe.
But it depends on how long will it take Luffy to recover, and at this rate he will be gonig back in the next few chapters.
Btw the 9 shadows = 9 Straw Hats are knida ruined now that Yamato is here

 

[nik87]

Unlike vs Oars where they could contribute, they literally cant do anything against Kaido...
Zoro can carry Luffy alone but carrying 8 people more is not doable even for Zoro...
Not a good idea to burden Zoro with more liabilities, Luffy is plenty.

 

[Finalbeta]

Kaido ain't an idiot and hilariously weak like oars, one shot everyone bar Luffy and Zoro.

Indeed. Many users don't realize the gap between Zoro/Luffy and the other SHs is much more profound than the one between Zoro/Luffy and the other SHs in Thriller Bark.

 

[PuckTheGreat]

It's clear as day why the majority of the thread seems to completely against this idea. It is the fear of what could be
All I'll say is that if the above scenario happens the probability of the stronger SHs being able to hurt Kaido is very high so y'all better prepare urselves lol

On the topic of the thread though, I think there is a very high probability of it happening and my reasons for this are:
- For one most of the SHs are still fresh, only one that seems to have exhausted herself quite a bit is Robin, but after a bit of rest she should be fine and she's support for the most part so she doesn't necessarily have to exhaust herself that much against Kaido, tho it'd be interesting to see her Demon face off against him :p
- Wano Anime has had a lot of spoilers and in it there's a scene where the SHs all face off against Kaido (and Linlin iirc)
- Franky is still yet to reveal his so called "anti-kaido" weapon so that has to come into effect at some point in the arc and I can't think of a better scenario for it than the SHs v Kaido

All that said, I still expect Luffy to 1 v 1 Kaido in the end so this could very well be a Oars Jr type situation where the SHs fight Kaido and then Luffy arrives to take over from them ^^

 

[Jailer]

No

 

[nik87]

On the second thought, why not... Let everyone face Kaido so we see who can do what.

 

[PuckTheGreat]

People who think it's impossible seem to forget the Straw Hats vs Oars/Moriah, where the gap in strength was arguably comparable to what the current Straw Hats vs Kaido would be now. They also seem to forget that even the scabbards were able to tango with Kaido for a fixed amount of time as well, and not to mention how just Nami, Brook, Carrot, and Jinbei were able to fend off Big Mom.

There is also the prospect of Yamato joining the crew who is currently holding off Kaido by herself. So I see no real reason why the rest of the Straw Hats wouldn't be able to join Yamato in holding off Kaido until Luffy arrives. Especially considering they all see to have been given a multitude of powerups that make them mush more harder to deal with than their preskip Thriller Bark counterparts.

Personally I am on the fence of this happening, as I just don't see how they can all make it up there before Luffy, who isn't that far off from being recovered, and the Calamities have yet to fall. But to think it's impossible, or the Straw Hats are just to weak to hold off Kaido is asinine.

Personally I think the Calamities are gonna get washed in a similar fashion to the Tobi Roppo so I don't expect drawn out fights. Moreover, most of the SHs are pretty close to the live floor, so once the calamities battles finish Marco could fly them all up ^^

 

[Zowo]

zoro cant protect them all so no it would not happen

 

[Finalbeta]

On the second thought, why not... Let everyone face Kaido so we see who can do what.

A further manifestation of Zoro's might indirectly.

 

[NAMELESS]

I doubt it!Ussop and Nami almost got taken out by Ulti and Page1!
Weaker Straw Hats would get 1 hit koed very fast!
Only Jinbe and Sanji might stand a chance vs Kaido(aside from luffy,zoro,yamato)!

 

[ShinmenTakezo]

Personally i don´t see it since there is no build-up whatsoever. Besides Zoro, none of the Strawhats even remotely have anything to do with Kaidou, have expressed a desire to battle him or whatever.

But who does have a relationship with pretty much every Strawhat? Big Mom.

Hence i think they will actually fight her.

 

[Shasha23]

Even if all the Strawhats joined in they will all be useless anyway, only Luffy and Zoro can damage Kaido what will the rest of those losers do except get in the way

 

[The White Crane]

Even if all the Strawhats joined in they will all be useless anyway, only Luffy and Zoro can damage Kaido what will the rest of those losers do except get in the way

Cook can cheerlead Zoro and Luffy, tho.

 

[Screws Loose242]

I think the straw should have a go at Kaido each straw hat should have trick in ther arsenal to hurt kaido & as a team the attack power is more , now I'm not saying they would win but it can be like thriller bark they go against kaido stalling him, but then kaido still shits on them while there laying on the ground fatigue luffy steps in etc

 

[vikas]

I voted for worst gen members thinking it was us



Either way, I think that Luffy will defeat Kaido in a "1vs1".

I did too...then retracted when I realized it's not.