Speculations Why are people so against Kidd return?

#61
Lnly way Kidd might return is if this Moss guy saved Kidd as a thanks for taking out Big Mom and wants to talk Loki and Kidd teaming up

Or he asks another alliance to defeat Loki and Shamrock lol.
 
#63
I am against his Return cause i think oda will make him another Luffy cocksucker or a cheerleader, which will ruin his character

Like let be real Kidd god hoed twice now by shanks, one losing his arm now this. People not gonna engage in ludonarrative dissonance this hard when he comes back again and says he gonna be PK

Its not a issue with Law because Law already bowed out on of the PK race anyway, he is just there to eat robin crums and maybe die for the imortal surgery
 
#64
There are so many characters oda needs to deal with. Compared to thise , what is significance of Kidd ? What will contribute to story if he returns? Just stealing panel
Imu has 5 top tier commanders under him, the gorosei. All having conquerors and mythic zoan awakening.

In order for Luffy or Teach to be on that level, they need to have 5 top tiers on their side as well.

Luffy has Zoro and Sanji, both who will likely reach top tier. In the Wano fight, Kid and Law beat BM while Yamato fought Kaido 1v1 before Luffy.

This could possibly set up Yamato, Kid, and Law to complete “Luffy’s Gorosei”. Yamato wants to join the SHs, and while Kid and Law are their own men, they could easily fall into an alliance where they are functionally straw hats(basically what happened in Wano, dressrosa, and PH).

Kid does have his thing with Shanks tho, which means he could alternatively fall into Teach’s hands. Rocks had 3 top tiers on his crew, not counting Kaido who didn’t have his fruit and was an apprentice. Apart from Kuzan nobody really compares to the Rocks commanders. Shiryu is very unimpressive. Kid is at least a confirmed conqueror with a broken fruit.

My guess is he allies with Teach and then eventually switches to Luffy’s side at the end.
Post automatically merged:

But in any case, Imu proved that you need at least 5 top tier commanders to be king of the world(not even counting Shamrock, the marines, and others).

Teach and Luffy are both candidates for King of the World.

between the two, one of them will inevitably end up getting Kid as an ally.
 
#66
Imu has 5 top tier commanders under him, the gorosei. All having conquerors and mythic zoan awakening.

In order for Luffy or Teach to be on that level, they need to have 5 top tiers on their side as well.

Luffy has Zoro and Sanji, both who will likely reach top tier. In the Wano fight, Kid and Law beat BM while Yamato fought Kaido 1v1 before Luffy.

This could possibly set up Yamato, Kid, and Law to complete “Luffy’s Gorosei”. Yamato wants to join the SHs, and while Kid and Law are their own men, they could easily fall into an alliance where they are functionally straw hats(basically what happened in Wano, dressrosa, and PH).

Kid does have his thing with Shanks tho, which means he could alternatively fall into Teach’s hands. Rocks had 3 top tiers on his crew, not counting Kaido who didn’t have his fruit and was an apprentice. Apart from Kuzan nobody really compares to the Rocks commanders. Shiryu is very unimpressive. Kid is at least a confirmed conqueror with a broken fruit.

My guess is he allies with Teach and then eventually switches to Luffy’s side at the end.
Post automatically merged:

But in any case, Imu proved that you need at least 5 top tier commanders to be king of the world(not even counting Shamrock, the marines, and others).

Teach and Luffy are both candidates for King of the World.

between the two, one of them will inevitably end up getting Kid as an ally.
If HKs fall in elbaph then dragon and sabo can fight gorosei also. Shanks most likely garling opponent.
 
#67
I don't really know what Kidd will do now, I think he probably wanted to fight Shanks because Shamrock attacked his country as a kid ( hehe =] ) but Shamrock's behaviour against Loki, being triggered by his words so much and attacking him while he is tied up, doesn't seem to be the behaviour of someone strong, and I think Kidd is at least stronger than yc+, because Yamato is yc+ and can only stall Kaido for a bit, but Kidd, that I think is around as strong as Law, if there are two Kidds, they defeat Big Mom, who is around as strong as Kaido, so Kidd probably actually wants to defeat Shamrock, but Shamrock's strength may not be such a big deal that Kidd needs to train much, but then he probably won't come back without getting stronger, but then what, he comes back just to mid diff Shamrock?
Post automatically merged:

After Kidd finds out about Shamrock in my opinion he would probably feel bad about attacking Shanks and his fleets and want to apologise to him and make amends,
 
#68
I don't really know what Kidd will do now, I think he probably wanted to fight Shanks because Shamrock attacked his country as a kid ( hehe =] ) but Shamrock's behaviour against Loki, being triggered by his words so much and attacking him while he is tied up, doesn't seem to be the behaviour of someone strong, and I think Kidd is at least stronger than yc+, because Yamato is yc+ and can only stall Kaido for a bit, but Kidd, that I think is around as strong as Law, if there are two Kidds, they defeat Big Mom, who is around as strong as Kaido, so Kidd probably actually wants to defeat Shamrock, but Shamrock's strength may not be such a big deal that Kidd needs to train much, but then he probably won't come back without getting stronger, but then what, he comes back just to mid diff Shamrock?
Post automatically merged:

After Kidd finds out about Shamrock in my opinion he would probably feel bad about attacking Shanks and his fleets and want to apologise to him and make amends,
Even if it was Shamrock that did all that Shanks destroyed his ship and possibly killed some of his crew. Bringing him back to try again doesn't really make sense.
 
#69
If HKs fall in elbaph then dragon and sabo can fight gorosei also. Shanks most likely garling opponent.
Revolutionaries vs Marines make the most sense.

Akainu has a direct conflict with both Sabo and Dragon.

As for Garling vs Shanks, I think we could see that happen before the final war with Garling playing a role in Shanks’s death.
 
#73
Revolutionaries vs Marines make the most sense.

Akainu has a direct conflict with both Sabo and Dragon.

As for Garling vs Shanks, I think we could see that happen before the final war with Garling playing a role in Shanks’s death.
Akainu vs Dragon
Garling vs Shanks
Topman vs Sabo
Venus vs Zoro
Mars vs Sanji
Worm vs Law or Kidd
 
#75
Coupled with the revelation that Dragon is an ex-marine, imo they ought to have a confrontation.
Post automatically merged:

Akainu vs Dragon
Garling vs Shanks
Topman vs Sabo
Venus vs Zoro
Mars vs Sanji
Worm vs Law or Kidd
Sabo is too important to fight warcury. He’s a main character in the saga. There’s a decent chance he’ll play a major role in Teach or Imu’s downfall.
 
Last edited:
#76
If he is alive, he will be Blackbeard's subordinate. He's lame and can't even use haki as well as his peers Law/Zoro/Luffy. He won't be a true rival to Luffy like Whitebeard was to Roger.
 
Top