Anyone else notice.
It's always admiral fandom that calls people retards excessively?
Not saying yonko fans don't do this but they insult people's reading comprehension and what not.
Really proves my point about toxicity.
I don't think this is actually about toxicity and is genuinely an issue of a large difference of interpretation.
Most people when they first read through the series are very much not close readers and probably didn't pay attention/remember a lot of details. They just get the gist of the story and that's that.
So when they catch up and its time for them to start discussing the series with other people, they have lots of holes in their memory about the story and go off vibes, especially true when power-scaling. For example: the amount of people that think Enel is stronger than a Pacafista.
When confronted with this gap in understanding, stubborn people will insist their first reading was the correct one and that everyone else is wrong, while introspective people will reread the story and either reaffirm or reconsider their perspective. The issue is that One Piece is such a long story that rereading it is asking a lot.
So you have to keep in mind that 99% of the time you are discussing One Piece online, its with someone who's understanding and memory of the series is from the first time they read it, and it most likely sucks.
For the admirals It really doesn't help that they don't, or at least didn't have that many concrete feats prior to the current arc. So very few people when they first catch up to the series weekly have the impression that the Admirals are as strong as the Emperors. Upon closer readings a case can be made for the Admirals, but for the average joe catching up to One Piece they don't really care. So most people arguing for the side of the Admirals tend to repeat themselves in nearly every argument they have, which I imagine is where the "toxicity" comes from.