Controversial Will Kidd return?

[Hyakujuu Kaido]

If the sea around Elbaph has the same gigantic proportions as the land then Law might be closer than Kidd.
I had to do it, I'm sorry.

Jimbei had the fish scope out the seas and no one was to be found. These jokes are getting outdated please

 

[zzShinichi]

Kinda hilarious to think that Kid is floating around Elbalf somewhere

 

[Jika]

Still no actual take on why he would come back

I've written plenty of posts on this forum about why he would come back...

https://worstgen.alwaysdata.net/for...l-return-and-will-fight-luffy-at-elbaf.58033/

 

[Warine]

shanks is not fighting a gorosei. these enemies are going to lose to new gen members. shanks doesn't have his place in there
luffy has to fight imu he could fight both though , he did defeat 2 cp9 agents in enies lobby
coby? why would he do that over kid
zoro vs vnusjuro is set
sanji will probably fight one too but if that happens so will kid. oda is not gonna give zoro and sanji way stronger matchups than kid and law it was like that in dressrosa and wano and its going to be like that each time that they are fighting on the same side in bug arcs because these 2 guys are written like that. that is never gonna change
[automerge]1733870577[/automerge]

people like that just repeat whatever popular opinion they hear without thinking for a second. It's kinda insane to me that people equates trying to save your captain's life betraying his dream. One guy proudly said "even ussop is braver" probably forgetting that in wano he wanted nami to not tell ulti that luffy will become the pirate king, what is this?

You see, the solution to your problem is kid not coming back because this guy just got no build up with a gorosei, and yes shanks got a billion time more chance than kid to fight one since his father is literally in the line up
[automerge]1733898562[/automerge]

I've written plenty of posts on this forum about why he would come back...

https://worstgen.alwaysdata.net/for...l-return-and-will-fight-luffy-at-elbaf.58033/

Acoc, to sky split with who? This is just fan fiction with no ground at all

 

[Hyakujuu Kaido]

You see, the solution to your problem is kid not coming back because this guy just got no build up with a gorosei, and yes shanks got a billion time more chance than kid to fight one since his father is literally in the line up
[automerge]1733898562[/automerge]

shanks likely gonna die before that to blackbeard. how odd would it be during the final war for the dawn of the new world, amongst the biggest the likes luffy, zoro, sanji, law that the 5th man ends up being Shanks when one of one piece's biggest themes has been about the growth of the new generation, cmon man. i think you guys simply do not want him to have any type of w and relevancy. the final war will be luffy at the head of the new gen bringing about the dawn of the new world and kid will be there as of of the major contributors right behind luffy (just like in wano) you guys are gonna have to accept that one day, not someone who will most likely be out of the equation before that even happens

 

[Ven437]

Which one of them is in elbaf rn

Not Kidd that boy is sleeping with the fishes right now

 

[Jika]

You see, the solution to your problem is kid not coming back because this guy just got no build up with a gorosei, and yes shanks got a billion time more chance than kid to fight one since his father is literally in the line up
[automerge]1733898562[/automerge]

Acoc, to sky split with who? This is just fan fiction with no ground at all

Let's bet on it? If it's just a fanfiction, should be easy W for you, right?

 

[nik87]

I hope not. Kidd taking down Shanks at this point would be downright awful and I have a feeling its gonna happen. He's not the type of character I want beating Shanks.

I can guarantee you one thing right now - Kidd is not a guy who is capable of taking Shanks out, at any point in the story.

 

[Warine]

Let's bet on it? If it's just a fanfiction, should be easy W for you, right?

Okay, but no cope out, I lose if he is even mildly relevant

 

[Jika]

Okay, but no cope out, I lose if he is even mildly relevant

Sure, what do you want if you win?

 

[Warine]

Sure, what do you want if you win?

Nothing

 

[Hyakujuu Kaido]

Not Kidd that boy is sleeping with the fishes right now

The same fish that told jimbei that they dont see nothing ? really?

 

[Blax Blah]

I can guarantee you one thing right now - Kidd is not a guy who is capable of taking Shanks out, at any point in the story.

I think either way when the one piece is found Kidd's strength will be way stronger than Shanks', the former generation of emperors may end up being as strong as current yonko commanders are to the emperors, compared to the worstgeneration,
[automerge]1733944863[/automerge]

Not Kidd that boy is sleeping with the fishes right now

Having a nice nap before he goes to train,

 

[JoNdule]

The only character that will save this boring arc is Kidd

 

[nik87]

I think either way when the one piece is found Kidd's strength will be way stronger than Shanks', the former generation of emperors may end up being as strong as current yonko commanders are to the emperors, compared to the worstgeneration,

I don't believe in power creep so it is hard for me too see that.
Also, it is kinda impossible to make Kidd stronger than Shanks.
Complete stat overhaul would be required...

 

[moreha9685]

The same fish that told jimbei that they dont see nothing ? really?

Imagine that's how Kid was brought back into the story Rescued by Jinbe's searching fish

 

[Blax Blah]

I don't believe in power creep so it is hard for me too see that.
Also, it is kinda impossible to make Kidd stronger than Shanks.
Complete stat overhaul would be required...

For the powercreep maybe, we will see with what happens, but Kidd can train his haki more,

 

[Hyakujuu Kaido]

Imagine that's how Kid was brought back into the story Rescued by Jinbe's searching fish

Oda is not an idiot, and if kid can survive under water for 3 days straight then this is the best feat in the manga. as well as the biggest asspull
[automerge]1733947502[/automerge]

I think either way when the one piece is found Kidd's strength will be way stronger than Shanks', the former generation of emperors may end up being as strong as current yonko commanders are to the emperors, compared to the worstgeneration,
[automerge]1733944863[/automerge]

Having a nice nap before he goes to train,

The mc's gen ends up being the strongest most of the time, people know that. they agree with that, but dont want kid to be part of that despite him arguably having one of the best potential in the series

 

[L57]

Kidd s story ended
He s irrelevant

 

[Jika]

Nothing

Lol alright