[FNZ] Role Madness [Season 2] Round 1 - The Dancing Valentine
- Thread starter Noctis
- Start date
- Tags #yamato4nakama bonbon give me cotton candy for a dance laraptsd scumflowa scumilia scumlighthoe scumrhea scumsopp sussopp
- Status
I think that [My Bloody Valentine] could be a townie ability by which one of the three folks presented is a scum.
In that case I would think it's Poison.
Reborn is extensively off meta. I doubt he would change so much.
Alibaba and krog are giving off very bad vibes, I happen to think one of them is scum. Would be genuinely surprised if none was. But in that case I would think of you (no offence bud).
The 4th scum would be still a mystery however if not Light.
The game could have more than 4 scums, I see it unlikely.
In that case I would think it's Poison.
Reborn is extensively off meta. I doubt he would change so much.
Alibaba and krog are giving off very bad vibes, I happen to think one of them is scum. Would be genuinely surprised if none was. But in that case I would think of you (no offence bud).
The 4th scum would be still a mystery however if not Light.
The game could have more than 4 scums, I see it unlikely.
Last game Vergo had revealed himself as Townie and he was townie, that game was plenty of hijacks and an SRM. This is RM so I believe it is very likely that Flower is that revealed character.
Also I have never seen an ability like [My Bloody Valentine] as scum related, usually fake write ups didn't feature this type of content (not that it's off sight that they would, but I'm saying to my knowledge).
Much more importantly, since I'm hell bent on Poison, I think my theory about it being what I described could be eventually proven correct.
We should definitely lynch Poison today.
Also I have never seen an ability like [My Bloody Valentine] as scum related, usually fake write ups didn't feature this type of content (not that it's off sight that they would, but I'm saying to my knowledge).
Much more importantly, since I'm hell bent on Poison, I think my theory about it being what I described could be eventually proven correct.
We should definitely lynch Poison today.
Vote Lynch Emilia @Noctis
I get that she’s a new player and all, but I don’t like how she were still going after Flower when she was revealed to be town beforehand. Also, we apparently have to lynch her or two other specific folks, and while Poison could be lying in the weeds, I have a stronger town read on her and Mango than Emilia at the moment.
I get that she’s a new player and all, but I don’t like how she were still going after Flower when she was revealed to be town beforehand. Also, we apparently have to lynch her or two other specific folks, and while Poison could be lying in the weeds, I have a stronger town read on her and Mango than Emilia at the moment.
I’m not asking you to reveal anything, I can guess how and why you reached that conclusion. Still, a write up is publicly available and more substantial than anything we’re allowed to provide...can you speculate why you’re mentioned as one of the required lynch targets?
^I meant that a fake write up can still be instructive, but I don’t see any reason to believe it’s fake...I only wonder why it’s specifically Emilia, Poison, and Mango.
Post automatically merged:
^I meant that a fake write up can still be instructive, but I don’t see any reason to believe it’s fake...I only wonder why it’s specifically Emilia, Poison, and Mango.
Two people having the same sus is not what I would call conclusive, even if based on (easily manipulated) night actions...I guess we can’t actually reveal if we won or lost in the dancing thing, but it’s interesting that you brought it up. If that’s the case, I still don’t see much of a reason to go with either of the other two; Mango’s been active and giving killer reads, and Poison’s inactivity doesn’t necessarily indicate scuminess, I’ve railed against that assumption in this game and several past ones. Call it recency bias if you want, but I think my vote’s with you until further notice.
I really don't understand that kill. I came out of that last day phase thinking that while Usopp's reaction to being voted off appeared genuine enough, the resolution of the lynch left it feeling like nothing but a whole lot of pathos. I had an entire post written about it wherein my vote ended up on Usopp for this Day Phase. To burn a superkill this early on that... I can only assume scum are either readily paranoid, new and inexperienced or have a pleathora of superkills to burn through. Either way, it offers some interesting food for thought regarding the nature of the scum team in this game.
On a similar note, I'm immediately suspicious of each and every individual who readily accepted this partnership thing, and even more so of those who partook in it. Given that it is a mechanic that has clearly been developed, one would assume it is related to solving the game in some form, and not just simply a whole extra mechanic tacked on purely for flavour purposes. Given that, why one would subject themselves to it without any critical thought whatsoever indicates to me that they are either informed (and thus likely scum) or simply don't care (and thus aren't going to be very useful town players anyway). In a previous Oreki game, a similar mechanic featured the option to play in a Mafia-style "Death Note RPG" mini game. I advised caution there too, and pointed out that people so happily involving themselves within it exhibited the aforementioned traits. Of course I was ignored, and would you have guessed, a scum ringleader was directly involved, and the whole mechanic itself came from scum. My point is to say that there is a non-negligible chance that partaking in this mechanic is harmful to the Town, and should be avoided where possible.
On a similar note, I'm immediately suspicious of each and every individual who readily accepted this partnership thing, and even more so of those who partook in it. Given that it is a mechanic that has clearly been developed, one would assume it is related to solving the game in some form, and not just simply a whole extra mechanic tacked on purely for flavour purposes. Given that, why one would subject themselves to it without any critical thought whatsoever indicates to me that they are either informed (and thus likely scum) or simply don't care (and thus aren't going to be very useful town players anyway). In a previous Oreki game, a similar mechanic featured the option to play in a Mafia-style "Death Note RPG" mini game. I advised caution there too, and pointed out that people so happily involving themselves within it exhibited the aforementioned traits. Of course I was ignored, and would you have guessed, a scum ringleader was directly involved, and the whole mechanic itself came from scum. My point is to say that there is a non-negligible chance that partaking in this mechanic is harmful to the Town, and should be avoided where possible.
- Status