General & Others TOP 5 underrated and overrated characters

I

Inspector_Mu

#64
A fleet admiral is just another admiral with more authority. You don't magically get a boost in power with a promotion. Strength alone doesn't warrant the FA position for an admiral. If the higher-ups in the WG didn't oppose Sengoku's decision to make Aokiji the FA then he'd have been the one to replace Sengoku instead of Akainu despite him being a tad-bit weaker than Akainu in comparison. Even if Garp is willing to become the FA, I don't think he'd be preferred over Sengoku for the FA position. The fleet admiral along with the three admirals exists to counterbalance the 4 emperors.
Being FA means you are the strongest
Sengoku was strongest marine equalled by Garp until Logi admirals took over at MF, Akainu became the new strongest marine
Kong was strongest marine until Garp and Sengoku surpassed him

You dont command Navy admirals is you are weaker than them , when you grow weaker . You step aside
 
#65
Being FA means you are the strongest
Sengoku was strongest marine equalled by Garp until Logi admirals took over at MF, Akainu became the new strongest marine
Kong was strongest marine until Garp and Sengoku surpassed him

You dont command Navy admirals is you are weaker than them , when you grow weaker . You step aside
You don't need to even have good intelligence or grasping talents on a good level to be a FA. refer to what Mother Carmel said when she told the CP0 that 5 years old Linlin has the potential to be an admiral or fleet admiral ( the same Linlin that was too dumb that she killed a bear she tried to save ). the "or" part would be completely useless if it didn't mean to distinguish the difference in power. as child Linlin got nothing to surpass an admiral in terms of warfare tactics, so it definitely means strength.

The current set of admirals are weaker than the FA.
 

Gol D. Roger

ȶɦɛ քɨʀǟȶɛ ӄɨռɢ
#69
Being FA 7means you are the strongest
Sengoku was strongest marine equalled by Garp until Logi admirals took over at MF, Akainu became the new strongest marine
Kong was strongest marine until Garp and Sengoku surpassed him

You dont command Navy admirals is you are weaker than them , when you grow weaker . You step aside
So the color trio was weaker than Sengoku before TS considering an almost 80 year old Sengoku was leading the Navy at the time of MF war?!:giogio:

And it totally makes sense that Kong took over a position much more powerful than FA because he was surpassed by Sengoku. Yeah, Sure.:cheers:
 
I

Inspector_Mu

#72
So the color trio was weaker than Sengoku before TS considering an almost 80 year old Sengoku was leading the Navy at the time of MF war?!:giogio:

And it totally makes sense that Kong took over a position much more powerful than FA because he was surpassed by Sengoku. Yeah, Sure.:cheers:
MF was when old gen passed the torch finally
Sengoku was still active , in fact Sengoku was stronger than old Garp at MF , based on their feats.

FA is not about Being smart or tactical.

Just like I don't see Sengoku and Garp being above Kong until Edd War.

Same way you become admiral for being strong, sane way you become FA for being stronger
 
#77
You don't need to even have good intelligence or grasping talents on a good level to be a FA. refer to what Mother Carmel said when she told the CP0 that 5 years old Linlin has the potential to be an admiral or fleet admiral ( the same Linlin that was too dumb that she killed a bear she tried to save ). the "or" part would be completely useless if it didn't mean to distinguish the difference in power. as child Linlin got nothing to surpass an admiral in terms of warfare tactics, so it definitely means strength.

The current set of admirals are weaker than the FA.
The same Linlin who was five years old.
 

Gol D. Roger

ȶɦɛ քɨʀǟȶɛ ӄɨռɢ
#78
MF was when old gen passed the torch finally
Sengoku was still active , in fact Sengoku was stronger than old Garp at MF , based on their feats.

FA is not about Being smart or tactical.

Just like I don't see Sengoku and Garp being above Kong until Edd War.

Same way you become admiral for being strong, sane way you become FA for being stronger
Let's rewind things a bit...

You dont command Navy admirals is you are weaker than them , when you grow weaker . You step aside
I am pretty sure Sengoku was weaker than C3 at MF and I am also pretty sure the C3 surpasssed him or rather he has gotten weaker than them way before the MF war. He still had command over the C3 despite being weaker than them. He'd still remain the FA if the war of them best didn't happen. It was never said nor implied anywhere in any shape or form that FA candidate must be the strongest of the admirals. In fact, The first person to be nominated as Sengoku's successor was the one who was implied to be the weakest of the C3. Sengoku nominated Aokiji as his successor without thinking twice about which of the 3 is the strongest. Kong left FA position because he was promoted not because Sengoku surpassed him. Even today the same old-ass Kong has command over Akainu and his underlings despite him being weaker than most of them.
 
#79
Overrated

Akainu
Crocodile
Zoro
Sanji
Garp

Underrated

Ace
Cavendish
Marco
Mihawk
Magellan
Sanji isn't overrated. He been on balance on what he can do, Bogard. Also why you think Mihawk is underrated? Some think here he can beat off Yonkos and Admirals easily? He nothing, but overrated than underrated.

Garp overrated? Didn't we had him beating Rocks with Roger? Don't think he is overrated if Oda giving him great feat like that and capabilities in his prime.
 

Bogard

You can't win
#80
Sanji isn't overrated. He been on balance on what he can do, Bogard. Also why you think Mihawk is underrated? Some think here he can beat off Yonkos and Admirals easily? He nothing, but overrated than underrated.

Garp overrated? Didn't we had him beating Rocks with Roger? Don't think he is overrated if Oda giving him great feat like that and capabilities in his prime.
Both Zoro and Sanji are Overrated in my Book by people who Overrated their abilities compared to yonko commander tier lvl characters when in reality the best they did is beat some mid tiers

I believe Mihawk is more Underrated than Overrated because Mihawk is a top tier, yet some people try to Underrated him by placing him as yonko commander tier. Top tiers are capable of giving each other extrême diff fight, when yonko commanders are for the most part low diff opponents, except few exceptionsI

So i value whoever win in a top tier battle less significant than underrating a top tier character to a lvl he doesn't belong to

I find Garp Overrated because most of hype not only come from government propaganda, but also against people who were far from their prime. He is placed on a pedestal he doesn't belong imo(Primebeard/Roger tier) when it's been implied multiple times in the manga that they were ahead of him in their prime
 
Top