Question is if the silences were the Scorned or the Reaper..
I think the default setup in ToL from what I saw was 1 neutral killing + 2 other indies + 2 Cult/ Maf + rest town (where King, Prince and Sheriff/ Paladin are guaranteed)
So Midnight claims he's Alchemist, which is Neutral support. So there is probably 2 more indies, where 1 is SK.
I suppose Reaper would fall under that category.
There is some suspicion that JDB is Za Fuuru, which is a Neutral social. So it is quite possible that it is a
Reaper + Alch + Fool.
Question remains, who is the reaper, and who is the last cult..?
So from PoE, TAC can be neutral, though it's hard to think he was SK, but lets for ease say he was town. So he is the King rn.
Jew cannot be the cult, at least he wasn't to begin with as he got bled and fixed by Doc Destroyer.
Ratchet put us in the mystic chat, so its not him.
I've yet to be converted, and I got the first CL killed.
Udell is also most probably not cult, which means he COULD be SK, IF JDB is the fool. Unless he ofc is Town, but I don't think he claimed anything?
If anything he's the likeliest candidate for SK rn.
Rhea seems very likely to be town, though is a possibility she might be converted.
Then the last remaining one is Blother, but as you said he's not playing rn? So idk
to summarize, I think the pool is down to JDB, Udell, Rhea and Blother.