General & Others Next Strawhat Crew Members and the Grand Fleet

[Zihark95]

The list was just to show how poor of character Carrot is overall and as an ally, not as a prospect for the Strawhats.
A ton of characters are more elaborate than her


Even if she's used as a plot device do you want to argue that her character has greater characterisation than Carrot. It's pretty obvious




Arc or not, she's not receiving the right focus and barely at that. She wasn't treated in any special type of way throughout Wano, she was never built up as a Strawhats aside spending some time on the ship travelling with them.. Even if Oda is going somewhere with her right now, it's not in Strawhat direction.. Else she would need to be involved directly in the main plot.

She might still be involved with stuff happening at onigashima. She will obviously be revelant again otherwise her character would have been useless. I do not think oda would build up her character sice wci only for her to be useless. And when she revelent again what will stop her to be a mugiwara

 

[Staticshadic]

I don’t actually think Carrot’s that bad lol. A little bland but she’s far from the worst. Tama isn’t that bad either, I just die a little inside every time I see her name these days. Not her fault, in isolation of this war I like Tama. I would agree she’s better characterized than Carrot.

I’d much rather a Carrot chapter than another Tama chapter though lol.

Carrot is not that bad in comparison someone like momo joining the crew.

 

[Dr_Professor83]

Carrot is not that bad in comparison someone like momo joining the crew.

I’ve never rooted against a character, that I thought was an actual candidate, joining the crew until Momo & Tama. Again, it’s nothing against either by themselves. I just don’t want the SHs to be babysitting kids that need protecting.

 

[Rootbeer]

She might still be involved with stuff happening at onigashima. She will obviously be revelant again otherwise her character would have been useless. I do not think oda would build up her character sice wci only for her to be useless. And when she revelent again what will stop her to be a mugiwara

He didn't build much on her really, very fleeting. She will be, the point is up till now she hasn't help in any way other than herself. She's not even listening to what Pedro told her, to keep moving forward and honoring his will. She's doing the exact contrary, going after Perospero is not moving forward, its moving backward..

 

[Dr_Professor83]

That's a good point, i agree with that. I would also say that i'm sort of interested in what decision Carrot will take. Anyway better than Tama who needs to be protected all the time and serves no other purposes than reverse the tides of the war or even it at least.

I am curious as hell as to what Oda’s plans are for Carrot. Like forget about her jointing the crew, I need to see what he plans for her just as a side character that’s been around so long that he’s dedicated subplots to.

Post automatically merged: Jun 28, 2021

I thought she was going to ultimately beat Perospero but it turns out that I greatly overestimated Sulong Carrot. I’m flabbergasted after Oda had her mercilessly defeated off screen in a tag team.

I suppose she can still help Neku, but does Neku really need help with Perospero? And is that even a satisfying pay off after all this?

 

[Staticshadic]

I’ve never rooted against a character (that I thought was an actual candidate) joining the crew until Momo & Tama. Again, it’s nothing against either by themselves. I just don’t want the SHs to be babysitting kids that need protecting.

Same here I do not want straw hats to be in situation where they constantly babysitting someone else kid. They do not offer much anything beside a moral and encouraging support. Tama devil fruit only works only against gifters and animals. Outside of that she would be kind useless against other enemies they face. Momo despite his character seems to understand that he has live through this situation. Is more likely his purpose will be served towards end game of the series just like shirihoshi is. So it best for him stay wano. What straw hats need to do in my opinion continue progress that they made so far. For few other characters especially Nami, Ussop, and Chopper they still need grow in terms strength as characters. Right now, Luffy’s crew becoming more and more of Yonko level crew. We recently add jimbei, Nami has zeus, ussop has observation haki, and chopper is able extend his time limit for monster transformation. Having kid alongside with them would be such wasted slot. The enemies there going face are going tougher than previous one. Where going against 3 admirals, the world government and they are 3 more yonkos that are left. They going to be even more danger that lies ahead. The Warlord system has already been abolished whatever vegapunk has cook up against warlords it could also harmful to straw hats as well. The world there entering once they get out of wano might be little different from what they are used to. It would not be safe for 8 years kid who has no skills go along with them. Knowing akainu sense justice he doesn’t care if you are child if your enemy of the government he would not hesitated to kill you unless some form of respect for you. On top that this recent chapter Zoro getting Super antidote saying it might have serious side effect it might take little longer until recovers. Why not take someone who could at least put a fight in order help them continue progress they made.

 

[Rootbeer]

I am curious as hell as to what Oda’s plans are for Carrot. Like forget about her jointing the crew, I need to see what he plans for her just as a side character that’s been around so long that he’s dedicated subplots to.

Post automatically merged: Jun 28, 2021

I thought she was going to ultimately beat Perospero but it turns out that I greatly overestimated Sulong Carrot. I’m flabbergasted after Oda had her mercilessly defeated off screen in a tag team.

I suppose she can still help Neku, but does Neku really need help with Perospero? And is that even a satisfying pay off after all this?

If the goal was Carrot to have an inner struggle, it would be pointless to get it resolved without difficulty the next time she shows up..
I also doubt Perospero's intent was to help her..

 

[Ponelglyph]

more or less, I can say that Carrot=Paulie Water 7

 

[thedarkdragon11]

At most, Carrot would end up being an "honorary" member like Vivi...

Carrot witnessing Pedro's explosive sacrifice is similar to Vivi witnessing Pell's... That, aside from her being one of the weaklings...

 

[Koro]

#Gender - Alphabet - character - Role

• M - IJ : Jimbei - Helmsman Father
• F -- WX : Woden (?) - Woman fighter/combatant who takes on Strong woman. (This is for M3 kind & shame the best cook in the world; kalifa -> nami, Black Maria -> Robin, YC2 & higher -> wOden)
• *double M+M = GH - OP : Gyukimaru/Onimaru - Pet of Shimotsuki / Sage-Monkey

#Carrot
- similar to vivi

• meet in 1 arc - Zou vs Whiskey peak
• travel in 2 arc - WCI-Wano vs Drum-Alabasta

- dont know if she will stay at Wano as Vivi stayed at Alabasta
- dont know if she will representate the unique trait (double) as Vivi representate Nevertari & an odd theory

#Onimaru
- he was the Shimotsuki pet & will accept allegiance with shimotsuki
- can change into something, as a Stick/Staff i mean, & just for example, example.

 

[Finalbeta]

123 voters for Carrot

 

[JoSeungHun7335]

Same here I do not want straw hats to be in situation where they constantly babysitting someone else kid. They do not offer much anything beside a moral and encouraging support. Tama devil fruit only works only against gifters and animals. Outside of that she would be kind useless against other enemies they face. Momo despite his character seems to understand that he has live through this situation. Is more likely his purpose will be served towards end game of the series just like shirihoshi is. So it best for him stay wano. What straw hats need to do in my opinion continue progress that they made so far. For few other characters especially Nami, Ussop, and Chopper they still need grow in terms strength as characters. Right now, Luffy’s crew becoming more and more of Yonko level crew. We recently add jimbei, Nami has zeus, ussop has observation haki, and chopper is able extend his time limit for monster transformation. Having kid alongside would them such wasted slot. The enemies there going face are going tougher than previous one. Where going against 3 admirals, the world government and they are 3 more yonkos that are left. They going to be even more danger that lies ahead. The Warlord system has already been abolished whatever vegapunk has cook up against warlords it could also harmful to straw hats as well. The world there entering once they get out of wano might be little different from what they are used to. It would not be safe for 8 years kid who has no skills go along with them. Knowing akainu sense justice he doesn’t care if you are child if your enemy of the government he would not hesitated to kill you unless some form of respect for you. On top that this recent chapter Zoro getting Super antidote saying it might have serious side effect it might take little longer until recovers. Why not take someone who could at least put a fight in order help them continue progress they made.

This is pretty much true. Even Vivi, as an honorary SH, who is quite capable of fighting, would still be such a burden to the rest of the crew if SHs will fight WG & BBP in the end. So having kids in SHs, with no special abilities to offer (like navigation, archaeology, etc.) will definitely be burdensome to other SHs, unless if there’s a plot armor (and we actually don’t want to see much more plot armor).

 

[Red Night]

If Carrot somehow by some miraculous chance joined the Strawhats, it would be the worst job Oda has ever done on a predominant character bar none. She has never been important, from insignificant in Zou to unimportant in WCI to non existent in Wano. She's always been an out of place useless eyesore..

Lets see a list of allies by Sagas who are objectively better characters than Carrot..

East Blue Saga
- Coby
- Rika
- Shushu
- Boodle
- Gaimon
- Kaya
- Zeff
- Gin
- Nojiko
- Gen-san
- Johnny
- Yosaku

Alabasta Saga
- Crocus
- Laboon
- Vivi
- Carue
- Igaram
- Pell
- Dorry
- Broggy
- Kureha
- Dalton
- Cobra
- Mr. 2 Bon Kurei
- Ace

Skypiea Saga
- Cricket
- Gan fall
- Conis
- Wyper
- Aisa

Water 7 Saga
- Kokoro
- Paulie
- Iceberg
- Zambai

Thriller Bark
- Lola
- Kuma

Shabondy Archypelago + return to + Fishman Island
- Camie
- Pappagu
- Hachi
- Shakki
- Rayleigh
- Perona
- Boa Hancock
- Duval
- Shirahoshi
- Neptune
- Fukaboshi

Dressrosa Saga
- Law
- Tashigi
- Smoker
- Kinemon
- Momonosuke
- Brownbeard
- Bartolomeo
- Cavendish
- Sabo
- Sai
- Don Chinjao
- Rebecca
- Kyros
- Viola
- Baby 5
- Leo
- Bellamy
- Koala

Whole Cake Island Saga
- Pekoms
- Pedro
- Wanda
- Nekomamushi
- Inuarashi
- Pudding
- Reiju
- Chiffon
- Capone
- Reiju
- Pound
- Gastino

Wano
- Yasuie
- Tama
- Tenguyama Hitetsu
- Ashura
- Denjiro
- Hiyori
- Shinobu
- Kiku
- Onimaru
- Kawamatsu
- Yamato
- Marco
- Hyogoro
- Toko
- Tsuru
- Drake

I can't believe that you really think what you said. This list is just troll.

 

[Zihark95]

more or less, I can say that Carrot=Paulie Water 7

Paulie was just a red herring for franky plus he never travel with the crew

 

[Gyro The God]

123 voters for Carrot

123 furries freaks

 

[Red Night]

123 Furries freaks

123 PERSONS ON THE PATH OF THRUTH!!

 

[Un-amed]

123 PERSONS ON THE PATH OF THRUTH!!

I voted for her, and I still believe she'll join, BUT the slow peace of her plot is sooo XD
I'm 99%sure he's doing this because of something of her future and her participation in the rest of the raid (Like being with the Mugi's), but the peace is still soo slow xD

 

[Finalbeta]

123 furries freaks

I think some must of voted her because they feel she won't resign the crew until Pedro is avenged properly.

 

[Gyro The God]

I think some must of voted her because they feel she won't resign the crew until Pedro is avenged properly.

This my friend is one of the reasons why I can’t stand carrot
This whole avenging pedro plotline is so dumb

acting like pedro is the hero
And perospero is the villain

Pedro invaded whole cake island
Tried to murder big mom
And then when he knew he had no chance against perospero HE BLEW HIMSELF

??????????????

WTF
How is perospero the bad guy here ?
Why is she hating perospero exactly? He defended his country and his family
Which is the normal thing to do

Was he supposed to sit there and do nothing while Pedro and the rest wreck the island?

Pedro needs avenging why ?
because carrot (oda) is retarded

 

[Red Night]

This my friend is one of the reasons why I can’t stand carrot
This whole avenging pedro plotline is so dumb

acting like pedro is the hero
And perospero is the villain

Pedro invaded whole cake island
Tried to murder big mom
And then when he knew he had no chance against perospero HE BLEW HIMSELF

??????????????

WTF
How is perospero the bad guy here ?
Why is she hating perospero exactly? He defended his country and his family
Which is the normal thing to do

Was he supposed to sit there and do nothing while Pedro and the rest wreck the island?

Pedro needs avenging why ?
because carrot (oda) is retarded

If she was not in the "i'll will avenge Pedro" shit would you consider her as a good character?