General & Others Next Strawhat Crew Members and the Grand Fleet

[Un-amed]

Think we’re all missing something worth noting - even if Carrot joins the crew with Yamato, the focus will unquestionably be on the latter regardless. Several other main characters have basically become set dressing as it is, there’s nothing for the rabbit to do going forward unless the full moon is out and nobody obstructs her view like many people could do in a variety of ways…whereas Yamato’s still keeping a Yonko at bay by herself, moon or not. There’s space on the ship for both, but only Kaido’s offspring has any narrative impact

First rule of writing a story, don't put your fans opinion or the narrative impact over the curse of the story.

That's always bad.
Law inclusion changed the entire Dressrosa.

Oda knows the hype over Yamato, he could easily subvert the character because of what you call Narrative Impact.
It'll be more impactful actually if she doesn't join.

 

[Sigran101]

I don't know who you're talking as my friends. I'm just here to support Carrot4Nakama and you're insulting every Carrot fans. Not every Yamato fans are simps. Cinera is the perfect example of some one who likes Yamato. Defending the character to the very end without insulting another. If you feel offended by what other Carrot fans say, it's not my fault and not the fault of the character. By saying that Carrot fans are all furries and addicted to opium, you're doing the same thing that toxic Carrot fans(which is a minority in the Carrot fanbase). Worstgen is known to be a place with a lot of toxicity. I talked to Carrot fans on Twitter and they said they don't want to join because they think this forum is too toxic. I already made a break after chapter 1006 because it was toxic af for Carrot fans. For the brainless, it was a supposition IN THE CASE you really think what you said about Carrot fans.

I hope you understood what I mean.

And I hope you could understand the difference of singular and plural. I said “Carrot FAN” not “Carrot FANS” and I said to the specific person. Are you really that, I quote, BRAINLESS that you don’t know the difference? Is it really hard for you to comprehend?

I think there's just a misunderstanding here. Someone said Yamato fans are just brainless simps, and Joseunghun was responding to that. I think the idea was that you could just as easily make the same argument about Carrot fans. I think you just missed that first post they were responding to.

 

[Jew D. Boy]

First rule of writing a story, don't put your fans opinion or the narrative impact over the curse of the story.

That's always bad.
Law inclusion changed the entire Dressrosa.

So in your eyes, the anime is canon and narrative impact isn’t as important as the “curse” (???) of the story…my man, this is some truly wacky bullshit.

 

[JoSeungHun7335]

I think there's just a misunderstanding here. Someone said Yamato fans are just brainless simps, and Joseunghun was responding to that. I think the idea was that you could make the same argument about Carrot fans. I think you just missed that first post they were responding to.

Finally, someone who can really understand what I meant.

 

[Roo]

First rule of writing a story, don't put your fans opinion or the narrative impact over the curse of the story.

That's always bad.
Law inclusion changed the entire Dressrosa.

are you implying Law's inclusion was bad?

Wow, Carrot fans really hate anybody who threatens her candidacy, even the fringe ones lol

 

[Un-amed]

So in your eyes, the anime is canon and narrative impact isn’t as important as the “curse” (???) of the story…my man, this is some truly wacky bullshit.

Naruto was full of Narrative Impact, and was shit.

Post automatically merged: Jul 5, 2021

are you implying Law's inclusion was bad?

Wow, Carrot fans really hate anybody who threatens her candidacy, even the fringe ones lol

No

 

[Red Night]

I think there's just a misunderstanding here. Someone said Yamato fans are just brainless simps, and Joseunghun was responding to that. I think the idea was that you could just as easily make the same argument about Carrot fans. I think you just missed that first post they were responding to.

And I hope you could understand the difference of singular and plural. I said “Carrot FAN” not “Carrot FANS” and I said to the specific person. Are you really that, I quote, BRAINLESS that you don’t know the difference? Is it really hard for you to comprehend?

 

[Uncle Van]

Funny how this Carrot vs Yamato war is nowhere near as toxic as the Dressrosa days.

Monet, Caesar, Rebeeca, Viola, Bart, Cavendish, Kyros, Kinemon, Momo and Law....that's 10 different trains that was active at once and fighting each other, using every argument and assumption in the book lol. They all crashed and then Carrot and Pudding came along.

 

[Jew D. Boy]

Naruto was full of Narrative Impact, and was shit.

Post automatically merged: Jul 5, 2021

No

Love to read stories with a bunch of plot points that don’t matter and characters who have no purpose…please stop quoting me, you’re as disconnected from reality as the other one.

 

[JoSeungHun7335]

when “A” toxic, irrational Carrot “FAN”. Is it really hard for you to comprehend? So Carrot fans can say shits on Yamato but Yamato fans can’t on Carrot? That explains the copium addicts for sure.

 

[Monet]

Funny how this Carrot vs Yamato war is nowhere near as toxic as the Dressrosa days.

Monet, Caesar, Rebeeca, Viola, Bart, Cavendish, Kyros, Kinemon, Momo and Law....that's 10 different trains that was active at once and fighting each other, using every argument and assumption in the book lol. They all crashed and then Carrot and Pudding came along.

lol the old days
i was Cavendish team (+monet )
but the best thing is that oda didn't disappoint me , Cavendish joined SH fleet and he was number 1.
while carrot , yamato teams one of them will be loser or even both

 

[Sigran101]

Again, this was a response to a potshot from a troll.

 

[Sir Yasheen]

I will truly never understand why having his own crew is a problem when Jinbei literally just joined this arc. And Law is truly delusional if he thinks he is Luffy's rival even if he was Yonko level because Luffy has at least 3 YC level subordinates, 4 if Yamato joins, and Zoro is arguably above YC level. It would have been really cool if Law had a legitimate crew, but he doesn't. It's him and fodder, and him being Luffy's rival for the position of pirate king is a joke.

When it comes to crews Jinbe was introduced without his crew and we didn’t see them in fishman island when Jinbe was asked to join the Straw Hats.

Moving along we also know Jinbe never wanted to be a leader of the sun pirates. And when we went to WCI we finally met his crew and his replacement.

Laws crew is much more integral to his character. We saw how much they all love each other in Zou and honestly how much they need law and vice versa. Law was introduced along with his trio of Bepo Shachi and penguin.

Law having a crew is not the same as Jinbe. As Jinbe just inherited his crew where as Law formed it himself.

And to the franky point, the franky family weren’t pirates. They’re bounty hunters and when franky was given a bounty he wouldn’t be able to stay in water 5 safely so he had to leave.

 

[JoSeungHun7335]

Again, this was a response to a potshot from a troll.

no need to explain to him. Carrot fans being their usual selves isn’t really surprising at all

 

[Uncle Van]

To clear things up, @JoSeungHun7335 was talking about Dizzy who said Yamato fans are simps. Jo said carrot fans in a way to flip Dizzy's logic back at him. He wasn't shitting on all Carrot fans.

lol the old days
i was Cavendish team (+monet )
but the best thing is that oda didn't disappoint me , Cavendish joined SH fleet and he was number 1.
while carrot , yamato teams one of them will be loser or even both

Lol didn't think of that. Cavendish and Barto fans are the only ones who won somewhat.

 

[Red Night]

when “A” toxic, irrational Carrot “FAN”. Is it really hard for you to comprehend? So Carrot fans can say shits on Yamato but Yamato fans can’t on Carrot? That explains the copium addicts for sure.

Did I say Yamato shit on Yamato? The real thing is that SOME Carrot fans here are saying shits on Yamato and you think that is the opinion of every Carrot fans. If it's not the case explain me why did you used "fans" with a "S"

Post automatically merged: Jul 5, 2021

To clear things up, @JoSeungHun7335 was talking about Dizzy who said Yamato fans are simps. Jo said carrot fans in a way to flip Dizzy's logic back at him. He wasn't shitting on all Carrot fans.

no need to explain to him. Carrot fans being their usual selves isn’t really surprising at all

... yeah he clearly proved it was not the case.

 

[Sigran101]

When it comes to crews Jinbe was introduced without his crew and we didn’t see them in fishman island when Jinbe was asked to join the Straw Hats.

Moving along we also know Jinbe never wanted to be a leader of the sun pirates. And when we went to WCI we finally met his crew and his replacement.

Laws crew is much more integral to his character. We saw how much they all love each other in Zou and honestly how much they need law and vice versa. Law was introduced along with his trio of Bepo Shachi and penguin.

Law having a crew is not the same as Jinbe. As Jinbe just inherited his crew where as Law formed it himself.

And to the franky point, the franky family weren’t pirates. They’re bounty hunters and when franky was given a bounty he wouldn’t be able to stay in water 5 safely so he had to leave.

This seems like semantics. Just because Law's crew happened to be with him when he first showed up doesn't mean they're more important. I think you are seriously underestimating how significant the sun pirates are to Jinbei. He inherited the crew of the messiah of his race and his personal hero. That crew went through hell together and experienced arguably the most significant event in Fishman history since before the modern era together. They even experienced the death of Fisher Tiger together.

 

[JoSeungHun7335]

Did I say Yamato shit on Yamato? The real thing is that SOME Carrot fans here are saying shits on Yamato and you think that is the opinion of every Carrot fans. If it's not the case explain me why did you used "fans" with a "S"

LOL I’m laughing so hard right now because you clearly don’t understand what I meant: which Van & Sigran101 already explained what I meant. Why so triggered?

 

[Red Night]

LOL I’m laughing so hard right now because you clearly don’t understand what I meant: which Van & Sigran101 already explained what I meant. Why so triggered?

I thought I understand what they were saying until you said: " Carrot fans being their usual selves isn’t really surprising at all".

 

[Sigran101]

no need to explain to him. Carrot fans being their usual selves isn’t really surprising at all

It's worth a try because @RedNight seems pretty reasonable.