We haven't seen "swordsmanship" from Roger. We have seen his weapon clashing with Whitebeard's weapon once. No swordspecific ability used. He used a named attack on Oden, yes, but that was rather a blast than a cut. Big Mom also used a named attack with her sword (spear of Elbaf) but the exact same named attack was used by a giant using an axe. So that named attack was not specific to swords.
I got adblock, so did not know, sorry
Yep, it´s the official one.
I do not think that´s the interpretation of Zoro´s statement, but we can disagree.
Stephen also translated it as such:
Mr. 1: Likewise.
By the way, don't think of me as a "swordsman"...
I have an unlimited number of weapons I can use to cut you to shreds...!!!
"SPIRAL HOLLOW"
- Page 172 -
Zoro: So you're not a swordsman,
You're a "MINER"!!!
Mr. 1: I'M AN ASSASSIN.
Yep, it´s the official one.
I do not think that´s the interpretation of Zoro´s statement, but we can disagree.
Stephen also translated it as such:
Mr. 1: Likewise.
By the way, don't think of me as a "swordsman"...
I have an unlimited number of weapons I can use to cut you to shreds...!!!
"SPIRAL HOLLOW"
- Page 172 -
Zoro: So you're not a swordsman,
You're a "MINER"!!!
Mr. 1: I'M AN ASSASSIN.
so wb weapon is a sword but the axe isnt
and somehow roger using his sword to attack wb isnt swordmanship. see there's a difference between swordmanhsip and sword specific ability. smh.
Post automatically merged:
Goal post has shift again
roger didnt show swordsmanhsip this chap because its a blast. not a sword specific attack
:yasu:
its not sword specific but he used a sword to do it
which is swordmanship.
the level of bullshit here stinks
That depends on what you see as swordsmanship. You are thinking of being trained in specific martial arts and techniques to further enhance your capabilities with a sword but that´s just that, technique.
People can have a difference in emphasizing different aspects of using a tool, strength, speed, technique and so forth.
Swordsmanship is simply using a sword to fight, it´s also the definition in pretty much every major dictionary.
Why do you think there are so many different weight classes in combat sports? Because a heavyweight can have the shittiest technique, footwork and everything else that is involved, simply crushes someone in Flyweight for example.
People can have a difference in emphasizing different aspects of using a tool, strength, speed, technique and so forth.
Swordsmanship is simply using a sword to fight, it´s also the definition in pretty much every major dictionary.
Why do you think there are so many different weight classes in combat sports? Because a heavyweight can have the shittiest technique, footwork and everything else that is involved, simply crushes someone in Flyweight for example.
we don't really know how strong Shanks is ... so no ... it's not out of realm of possible so if not knowing is a proof so Shanks have it
and at same time we know sick beard is aomung weakest of top tiers ... the fact that you don't understand that is sad
in order to make a logical claim you need to BASE it on some thing ...
unless it's a theory or head canon
that's why Shanks beating WB is wrong ... cause it's baseless
that's why Mihawk beating any of current top tiers is wrong ... cause it's baseless
the fact that I need to explain this is double sad
and at same time we know sick beard is aomung weakest of top tiers ... the fact that you don't understand that is sad
in order to make a logical claim you need to BASE it on some thing ...
unless it's a theory or head canon
that's why Shanks beating WB is wrong ... cause it's baseless
that's why Mihawk beating any of current top tiers is wrong ... cause it's baseless
the fact that I need to explain this is double sad
What's sad is that you do not know how a logical argument works. You are not honest enough to admit you got it wrong and so you do a poor job at Backtracking.
Your argument ; we don't know if Shanks beat Primebeard.
Manga : Shanks was a child when WB was in his prime, WB even old was still WSM.
Try again
Your argument ; we don't know if Shanks beat Primebeard.
Manga : Shanks was a child when WB was in his prime, WB even old was still WSM.
Try again
