Questions & Mysteries Why Roger îs not a swordman

[CbShadow]

Roger is a swordsman. His fighting style revolves around swordsmanship.

 

[Kejon]

Yes it is.
How strong is brook ? He stole a copy and luckily ended up on zou for another. He could theoretically do the same for kaidos and luckily find the last and with nami and robin be on his way to raftel.

I really wouldn't classify Brook as fodder, but whatever. Brook could do all of this, because of Luffy and that's it. He had insane luck against BM, but do you seriously think that would work everytime?

 

[HA001]

I really wouldn't classify Brook as fodder, but whatever. Brook could do all of this, because of Luffy and that's it. He had insane luck against BM, but do you seriously think that would work everytime?

Why not if it worked once already.

 

[Kejon]

Why not if it worked once already.

Kaido isn't the one to play around with people. BM saw Brook as a toy, but Kaido? Brook would die.

 

[HA001]

Kaido isn't the one to play around with people. BM saw Brook as a toy, but Kaido? Brook would die.

Kaidos barely involved in wano. The shs have had free reign since they got there.

 

[Kejon]

Kaidos barely involved in wano. The shs have had free reign since they got there.

I'm sure his poneglyph is well-guarded. Orochi is definitely not the one in charge of protecting Kaido's poneglyph. If Brook really wants to steal Kaido's poneglypgh, he has to face him head on.

 

[HA001]

I'm sure his poneglyph is well-guarded. Orochi is definitely not the one in charge of protecting Kaido's poneglyph. If Brook really wants to steal Kaido's poneglypgh, he has to face him head on.

Why does he ? Kaido goes wandering off even out of wano regurlaly.

 

[Monkey D Theories]

yeah of course Roger is not a swordsman, he's the world's strongest hakiman! just like shanks!

/s

 

[Kejon]

Why does he ? Kaido goes wandering off even out of wano regurlaly.

That means his poneglyph must be so well protected, that he can do that. Brook wouldn't be able to steal Kaido's poneglyph.

 

[HA001]

That means his poneglyph must be so well protected, that he can do that. Brook wouldn't be able to steal Kaido's poneglyph.

Headcanon. Meme and kaido have been portayed together countless times. If he can steal memes he can do kaidos.

 

[Kejon]

Headcanon. Meme and kaido have been portayed together countless times. If he can steal memes he can do kaidos.

Kaido is different than Big Mom, he would murder Brook instantly.

 

[HA001]

Kaido is different than Big Mom, he would murder Brook instantly.

Not the point.

 

[Kejon]

Not the point.

What's your point then?

 

[HA001]

What's your point then?

That you can become pirate king regardless of strength.

 

[Kejon]

That you can become pirate king regardless of strength.

You can't become the PK while being fodder though. Roger countless times clashed against Garp, because he was chasing him. Someone like Brook or Buggy wouldn't be able to protect themselves like that. Luck is needed, but it isn't everything. You need to have strength too.

 

[MD Zolo]

You can't become the PK while being fodder though. Roger countless times clashed against Garp, because he was chasing him. Someone like Brook or Buggy wouldn't be able to protect themselves like that. Luck is needed, but it isn't everything. You need to have strength too.

Not that I agree with @HA001 on this, but Garp was chasing precisely because Roger was a strong pirate possessing sufficient danger to Marines. Garp wouldn't waste time on someone like Buggy.

 

[LolonoisZolo]

You can't become the PK while being fodder though. Roger countless times clashed against Garp, because he was chasing him. Someone like Brook or Buggy wouldn't be able to protect themselves like that. Luck is needed, but it isn't everything. You need to have strength too.

There's a difference between fodder and the str9ngest ever though...small one but still

 

[Kejon]

Not that I agree with @HA001 on this, but Garp was chasing precisely because Roger was a strong pirate possessing sufficient danger to Marines. Garp wouldn't waste time on someone like Buggy.

If Buggy was able to find the one piece for some reason, then they would chase him too for sure. They probably wouldn't send Garp, because anyone else would be sufficient enough to take out Buggy.
[automerge]1577214303[/automerge]

There's a difference between fodder and the str9ngest ever though...small one but still

Fodder can't become PK, but the strongest can.

 

[HA001]

If Buggy was able to find the one piece for some reason, then they would chase him too for sure. They probably wouldn't send Garp, because anyone else would be sufficient enough to take out Buggy.
[automerge]1577214303[/automerge]

Fodder can't become PK, but the strongest can.

Buggy has seen the one piece and they havent done shit.

 

[Finalbeta]

Roger is a swordsman. His fighting style revolves around swordsmanship.

As simple and true as it looks.