Who will be the next Strawhat


  • Total voters
    895
Status
Not open for further replies.

Uncle Van

Bullets don't hurt. But Taxes do.
I think you misunderstood me when I said I didn't care what certain individuals think. I'm not looking for a ceasefire. I don't want them to stop calling Carrot "grass-eater", I don't want them to say Carrot's going to join the crew. I don't care if they say Akainu's going to join the crew. In my opinion, their opinions hold literally zero value, and that's not an exaggeration. Just because they have dangerously low emotional intelligence and love to make a lot of noise, does not mean that I need to pay them any mind.

Remember, not everyone who supports Yamao is like this. You'd find that her supporters who make the best arguments, are the most rational and aren't just all-round pathetic individuals won't even mention the fact that I call her Yamao. It's such a trivial thing. Consider "Yamao" to be a litmus test. If they have no reaction then it's likely fine to consider talking to them in this thread. If they start crying, personally attack you, or full on start shitting in the thread (as is common around here), then you'd best leave that one alone. It's not worth it.

Imagine getting this traumatised by a nickname that the main character himself calls her? You'd think I was saying the n word or something. God help them next time Luffy and Yamao meet and he calls her that again. Might wanna put them on suicide watch.
I hope you realize that you're admitting to baiting people on purpose? You're already known to be anti-Yamato and talk down to people who disagree with you, along with calling her "Yamao" to downplay the character. You yourself has said Luffy doesn't even bother to remember her name and used the nickname to say Yamato isnt joining.

It's a very bad look for you to try and make it seem like people can't stand the nickname and flip out because of it. It because it's you saying it, as you've used it as an anti-Yamato argument before. If a random guy shows up and thinks Luffy not remembering her name is a minus, people will likely give normal counter arguments. If you say it, people will act like jackasses because of your past comments.
 
And just like that Nekomamushi sent Perospero flying in Carrot's direction? That means Carrot has been laying there the whole time doing nothing.. Hopefully Nekomamushi realises that Perospero isn't responsible for Pedro's death and understand that Perospero spared Wanda and Carrot's life.. Its going to be so bad if Carrot finishes Perospero like Nami did with Ulti after Big Mom dealt most of the damage..

So when's the irrelevant rabbit coming back, chapter 1023, 1024, 1025, 1026?


I hope you realize that you're admitting to baiting people on purpose? You're already known to be anti-Yamato and talk down to people who disagree with you, along with calling her "Yamao" to downplay the character. You yourself has said Luffy doesn't even bother to remember her name and used the nickname to say Yamato isnt joining.

It's a very bad look for you to try and make it seem like people can't stand the nickname and flip out because of it. It because it's you saying it, as you've used it as an anti-Yamato argument before. If a random guy shows up and thinks Luffy not remembering her name is a minus, people will likely give normal counter arguments. If you say it, people will act like jackasses because of your past comments.
You don't need an indirect confession to know that the guy is a fake ass..
 
I think you misunderstood me when I said I didn't care what certain individuals think. I'm not looking for a ceasefire. I don't want them to stop calling Carrot "grass-eater", I don't want them to say Carrot's going to join the crew. I don't care if they say Akainu's going to join the crew. In my opinion, their opinions hold literally zero value, and that's not an exaggeration. Just because they have dangerously low emotional intelligence and love to make a lot of noise, does not mean that I need to pay them any mind.

Remember, not everyone who supports Yamao is like this. You'd find that her supporters who make the best arguments, are the most rational and aren't just all-round pathetic individuals won't even mention the fact that I call her Yamao. It's such a trivial thing. Consider "Yamao" to be a litmus test. If they have no reaction then it's likely fine to consider talking to them in this thread. If they start crying, personally attack you, or full on start shitting in the thread (as is common around here), then you'd best leave that one alone. It's not worth it.

Imagine getting this traumatised by a nickname that the main character himself calls her? You'd think I was saying the n word or something. God help them next time Luffy and Yamao meet and he calls her that again. Might wanna put them on suicide watch.
well we never wanted a truce anyway. It’s your fellow mate, Shift, who proposed it. I personally never get insulted with “Yamao” thing, it’s just that I find it funny that for don’t know how many times Carrot fans gave insults then play the victim card. Like you can’t go lower than that.

It’s like a defense mechanism to cope with the fact that Oda doesn’t consider Carrot relevant again. At least with “Yamao” Oda wants to imply that Luffy considers Yamato important that he remembers Yamato although he changed her name as he will, even giving Yamato an important job to protect Momo & Shinobu. And it must be painful to see that Luffy never called “Carrot” once, hence you started the name-calling.

at least you call her “Yamao” is a reminder that even within few minutes they know each other, Luffy considers Yamato is relevant & trustworthy enough for Luffy to remember her and call her “Yamao” multiple times. While on the other hand, again, as long as I can remember Luffy never once mentions Carrot’s name although she tagged along for so long. I bet Luffy never considers Carrot to be important nor trustworthy enough for Luffy to call her name.
 
Can't say I didn't try. Back into the fray we go.

While on the other hand, again, as long as I can remember Luffy never once mentions Carrot’s name although she tagged along for so long. I bet Luffy never considers Carrot to be important nor trustworthy enough for Luffy to call her name.


 
Here’s the thing about the “both sides are guilty” approach. It’s bullshit. Now, I’m not going to go pointing fingers as there are good arguers for any character, but come on.

The name thing. It’s one thing to roast a character once in a while. The straw hats roast each other. Look at Sanji and Zoro. But it’s another thing entirely to completely go out of your way to rename a character every chance you get, and on top of that to admit you do it to bait people. Like, you have to do that every time you say the name. You have to correct yourself every time you type the name “Yamao” because you know it should be “Yamato.” That’s obsessive levels of hate beyond saying “Grass Eater” once in a while but still calling her Carrot 99% of the time.

As for the furry argument, it’s not without merit. Freaking Naito, Oda’s editor, has professed his love for Carrot, stated he wished he could marry her, and Toei is having a blast with her beast pirate outfit. Remember, this is a 15-year-old girl. There is a general unease about how the people in charge will portray an underage girl if she sticks around.

Now, the last thing I want to point out which is the biggest annoyance of all, we have a bunch of armchair psychologists in here who I guarantee have never taken a psychology class they stayed awake for commenting on Yamato’s “Oden worship” as a mental illness. The Oden cosplay is just a fixation that Yamato needs to get over. That shit is toxic AF and it’s clearly hate geared at a character rather than the character’s reception. Don’t even try to say roasting one character is the same level of bad as calling another mentally stunted.

I’m fine with Carrot getting on the crew if Oda does the proper narrative buildup. That’s it. But we’re here with only Yamato getting that narrative buildup. If not for Carrot’s adamant fans who incessantly bring up her WCI feats every day, we’d only be talking about her in this thread like twice a year.
 
Here’s the thing about the “both sides are guilty” approach. It’s bullshit. Now, I’m not going to go pointing fingers as there are good arguers for any character, but come on.

The name thing. It’s one thing to roast a character once in a while. The straw hats roast each other. Look at Sanji and Zoro. But it’s another thing entirely to completely go out of your way to rename a character every chance you get, and on top of that to admit you do it to bait people. Like, you have to do that every time you say the name. You have to correct yourself every time you type the name “Yamao” because you know it should be “Yamato.” That’s obsessive levels of hate beyond saying “Grass Eater” once in a while but still calling her Carrot 99% of the time.

As for the furry argument, it’s not without merit. Freaking Naito, Oda’s editor, has professed his love for Carrot, stated he wished he could marry her, and Toei is having a blast with her beast pirate outfit. Remember, this is a 15-year-old girl. There is a general unease about how the people in charge will portray an underage girl if she sticks around.

Now, the last thing I want to point out which is the biggest annoyance of all, we have a bunch of armchair psychologists in here who I guarantee have never taken a psychology class they stayed awake for commenting on Yamato’s “Oden worship” as a mental illness. The Oden cosplay is just a fixation that Yamato needs to get over. That shit is toxic AF and it’s clearly hate geared at a character rather than the character’s reception. Don’t even try to say roasting one character is the same level of bad as calling another mentally stunted.

I’m fine with Carrot getting on the crew if Oda does the proper narrative buildup. That’s it. But we’re here with only Yamato getting that narrative buildup. If not for Carrot’s adamant fans who incessantly bring up her WCI feats every day, we’d only be talking about her in this thread like twice a year.
the funniest thing about the name-calling is that they use the victim card LMAO. Dizzy insulted Yamato multiple times, calling her a “bitch” because of her DF, then calling Yamato fans as “simps” and “trans activists”. And when I clapped back at him/her, their fellow Carrot fans play the victim card & pretended to be surprised or pretended not to see dizzy’s insults, saying that my life is “sad because hating on a fictional character” and never say that to their fellow Carrot fan. Desperate times, desperate measures.
 

Zoro and Sanji will always be Luffy's wings.
Yamao being able to singlehandedly stall a serious hybrid Kaido makes her stronger than Sanji, ruining the M3 dynamic. We've had strong characters join the crew before, but every time they did Oda always kept them weaker than the M3 when the final fights came. Jinbe and Franky were the most questionable but both times Oda had Zoro and Sanji fight much stronger opponents at the end of arc match ups.

With her strength, Yamao would be better suited as a strong ally. Someone like Marco.

Carrot's power level safely slots in with the crew. Just as Jinbe is between the monster trio and the mid trio, she's between the mid and weakling trio. Overall the crew will remain just as balanced as it was during the Luffy-Brook period.

Luffy/Zoro/Sanji
Jinbe
Franky/Robin/Brook
Carrot
Chopper/Nami/Usopp
Isn't that a futile argument? The Monster Trio dynamic has never changed, even when stronger people did join. They always fall behind the monster trio after joining. It happened to Robin, it happened to Franky, it happened to Jinbe. It will also happen to Yamato once she joins.

Carrot is actually the one who's out of place to join right after a Warlord. Because going by your logic, Carrot should've be introduced and joined back before the time skip along with the rest of the mid trio.

It's funny how you chose this pattern that doesn't hold any water, yet you refuse the pattern that actually does. And that's the straw hat crew get stronger members in more dangerous seas further down the series.

We got most of the weak trio in East Blue with Nami and Ussop.

We got mid trio in Grand Line with Robin, Franky and Brook.

We got Jinbe in the New World

We are in the Yonko Saga and the Wano Arc. Getting Carrot to join after Wano after we just got Jinbe in WCI would actually be pretty anti-climactic and out of place.

Yamato and her strength is the perfect addition after the victory against a yonko.
 
We've been telling you(plural) that, and using that argument since the beginning of the debate...
Luffy already consider her as a nakama, but she isn't because she never asked to officially join xD
well I’m not ashamed to admit my mistakes though. At least as much as I don’t like Carrot, I don’t have to name-call & insult her fans most of times, then play the “low emotional intelligence”, “personally attack” victim card like a psychopathic deranged bully.
 



Post automatically merged:


Say it!! You don’t get extra credit when saying shitty things for not saying MORE horrible words, so go ahead and let it fly!! :gokulaugh:
Even though i turned down Shift's offer for ceasefire initially, i still wanted to wait a couple of days before coming back into this thread firing shots. Who knew ya'll we're even more impatient than even me and started calling him out less than a day before the chapter drops!
:saden: :cantseeme:

Now I get to enjoy reading all of the roasts.

:ihaha:
 
With caribou deed for luffy this chapter, i think luffy wouldn't mind if he tag along to leave wano

Tama will ask luffy to take her to the sea because that she has proven that she is a good kunoichi. Although it's only a promise between ace and her, but so far she has not asked that question to luffy yet, and we still dont know what luffy's answer if that happen

Carrot may tag along once again in case BM and peros wont be done for good this arc

Yamato will leave wano to do an "important mission" (if my prediction right)

I think the recruitment for new nakama will be delayed once again because it will be so blur to distinguish which is new nakama, which is companion
Looks like I forgot to add marco. I think he should be there when SHs meet weevil and maybe marco will guide us to the last poneglyph. He may come along too

One more. Kozuki is destined to come with the joyboy, like the moonlight be the guide to make it through this endless night. Hiyori come along as well. She was a tomboy kid. She probably missed going out to the sea
Post automatically merged:

Anyway, good chapt to bring pedro back to the story. My agenda always running smooth :myman:
 
Last edited:
Looks like I forgot to add marco. I think he should be there when SHs meet weevil and maybe marco will guide us to the last poneglyph. He may come along too

One more. Kozuki is destined to come with the joyboy, like the moonlight be the guide to make it through this endless night. Hiyori come along as well. She was a tomboy kid. She probably missed going out to the sea
Post automatically merged:

Anyway, good chapt to bring pedro back to the story. My agenda always running smooth :myman:
What your agenda is???
 

Jew D. Boy

I Can Go Lower
Even though i turned down Shift's offer for ceasefire initially, i still wanted to wait a couple of days before coming back into this thread firing shots. Who knew ya'll we're even more impatient than even me and started calling him out less than a day before the chapter drops!
:saden: :cantseeme:

Now I get to enjoy reading all of the roasts.

:ihaha:
Now that he’s admitted what we all knew for a long time, I don’t see any reason to hold back :kayneshrug:
Post automatically merged:

the funniest thing about the name-calling is that they use the victim card LMAO. Dizzy insulted Yamato multiple times, calling her a “bitch” because of her DF, then calling Yamato fans as “simps” and “trans activists”. And when I clapped back at him/her, their fellow Carrot fans play the victim card & pretended to be surprised or pretended not to see dizzy’s insults, saying that my life is “sad because hating on a fictional character” and never say that to their fellow Carrot fan. Desperate times, desperate measures.
If he thinks he isn’t gonna be called a bitch multiple times every single day once she joins the crew, he’s every bit as dumb as he thinks the rest of us are :gokulaugh:
Post automatically merged:

Can't say I didn't try. Back into the fray we go.




You tried, but you were never the one who needed to act right…the kid doesn’t understand that Yamato fans don’t hate all Carrot supporters, just the ones who act like mincing little babies, a description that only fits one person here :kayneshrug:
 
Last edited:
I recently saw an interesting take on the devil fruit number theory.

All the SH DF users have 2 numbers associated with their fruit, with 2-9 being the 2 missing. This lead ppl to assume the final member will be a df users associated with those numbers, Oda even being evasive wen answering this theory in the past.

Now the wrench in all this is that we already have a character that has those numbers for their fruit, Kuma. Now no one actually feels hes SH material, but hes his death seems more evident as the story unfolds, which would free up his fruit.

At this point 1 of 2 things can happen. The final SH is the one who eats his fruit. Off the top of my head thatd point to Vivi since she seems to be close to where Kuma currently is, and actually has some precedent to be a SH. The other possibility is that one of the DFless SHs gets the fruit. Franky immediately comes to mind as Oda has played with the idea of him getting a DF in Dressrosa. That said the SH doesnt necessarily have to eat the fruit themselves. The could easily give the fruit to their weapon/armor which would also count.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top