General & Others Next Strawhat Crew Members and the Grand Fleet

[Uncle Van]

If it's Usopp, he would've seen the genie approaching...

Head canon. bad comparison, Usopp is not a look out.

Yes that's a look out thing

@thedarkdragon11 literally posted a panel of Carrot failing at her destiny job, with you saying Usopp would have saw the genie coming aka he's a better lookout...

Oda also said that 2 SHs are up are all times to watch the front and back of the ship as lookouts, and we see Carrot getting caught from the back.

You're accidentally giving better anti-Carrot arguments than others lol

 

[Lhulu]

Wrong. Lookout is about seing ships not auras. Usopp can't go as high and fast as Carrot and doesn't have her experience. Stop with this bullshit argument.

Yeah, Carrot needs to use binoculars but somehow she's better than Ussop who could see through buildings.

 

[thedarkdragon11]

If it's Usopp, he would've seen the genie approaching...

Head canon. bad comparison, Usopp is not a look out.

Yes that's a look out thing

Carrot isn't a lookout as well... But between Usopp and Carrot, you know who can do a better job for a lookout and that is someone who impressed Viola who can see through almost an entire island country...

ROFL at headcanon...

 

[Kurodiamondo]

WCI theme is musical while wano is kabuki play. Wouldn't feel so weird if we get a great performer from this arc

All star/ookanban
Flying six/tobi roppo
Headliner/shinuchi
The stars (zoro and sanji)/hanagata
Hannya mask, ham actor, act, etc

Those are terms and something that used in performing arts 🎭

And we got so much great acting this arc. Kyoshiro, kanjuro, kamazou, komurasaki, kiku, drake, SHs disguise as wano citizen.

Last chapter hiyori act as komurasaki fooling her prey like a certain pirate who has mythical fox ability 👀

Playing shamisen in the middle of fire festival to mourn the dead. Maybe she plays princess of the moon song, the song oden asked to play for his funeral. Father-daughter relationship so strong

 

[Logiko]

I responded to you calling "Usopp noticing the Genie faster than Carrot" as headcanon - that's completely false and he will notice it earlier than Carrot did.

Headcanon. Bad faith argument. I'll keep repeating if I need too. The argument of the genie is situational not specific to the look-out job. Anyone, even Usopp, would be surprised by the speed of daifuku's genie and you know it. Stop with the BS just meant to deminish Carrot's role as a look out. You are ridiculizing yourself.

Carrot has had the experience of being a lookout on ships for how long? Didn't Oda say that all the members have been alternating as lookouts all this while?

Carrot is experimented as a sentry from way back in Zou. This experience can be transfered to the ship easily and you know it too.

And how is this a bullshit argument? Just because you occupy a position at the crew doesn't mean you are the best at it - Zoro is the combatant but is he stronger than Luffy now?

Zoro more of a first mate than a combatant. The argument consisting in the comparison with other strawhat is meaningless. each stgrawhat have their role. Carrot's one is a look out. This is UNDENIABLE as she has been drawn to the post more than 40 times. Stop with the BS.

@thedarkdragon11 literally posted a panel of Carrot failing at her destiny job, with you saying Usopp would have saw the genie coming aka he's a better lookout...

Being surprised by the speed of Daifuku is not "failing" to the crew. Stop with the bad faith argument meant to diminish Carrot's role as a look out. It's starting to be ridicule. Usopp would be as surprised as Carrot in this situation.

Oda also said that 2 SHs are up are all times to watch the front and back of the ship as lookouts, and we see Carrot getting caught from the back.

Wrong, from the front.

You're accidentally giving better anti-Carrot arguments than others lol

Nah

Yeah, Carrot needs to use binoculars but somehow she's better than Ussop who could see through buildings.

A look out needs to see ships, not auras. bad argument. Her binocular are very usefull in fact

Carrot isn't a lookout as well... But between Usopp and Carrot, you know who can do a better job for a lookout and that is someone who impressed Viola who can see through almost an entire island country...

ROFL at headcanon...

Carrot has been drawn as a look out, acted as a look out, interacted as a look out.. But she is not a look out.

Are you a clown ?

 

[Ravagerblade]

Keep this argument as much as you want, it's still YamaO lol

And what does that even prove? Nothing.
You are clinging to any little thing. That's not something someone with confidence does.

 

[ConquistadoR]

Headcanon. Bad faith argument. I'll keep repeating if I need too. The argument of the genie is situational not specific to the look-out job. Anyone, even Usopp, would be surprised by the speed of daifuku's genie and you know it. Stop with the BS just meant to deminish Carrot's role as a look out. You are ridiculizing yourself.

What? Listen to yourself.

Luffy, Zoro, Sanji, Usopp and Jinbe would react much better at that situation than Carrot did. That is an undeniable manga fact based on the magic system that's in place in One Piece. Denying that or calling it headcanon is just either coping or outright intellectual dishonesty.

Carrot is experimented as a sentry from way back in Zou. This experience can be transfered to the ship easily and you know it too.

And?

You yourself said that noticing Auras or people is different from seeing ships. Usopp and pretty much the entire Straw Hat crew have been doing that ever since the Pre TS. Actual experience at being a lookout.

 

[Ravagerblade]

Headcanon. Bad faith argument. I'll keep repeating if I need too. The argument of the genie is situational not specific to the look-out job. Anyone, even Usopp, would be surprised by the speed of daifuku's genie and you know it. Stop with the BS just meant to deminish Carrot's role as a look out. You are ridiculizing yourself.



Carrot is experimented as a sentry from way back in Zou. This experience can be transfered to the ship easily and you know it too.



Zoro more of a first mate than a combatant. The argument consisting in the comparison with other strawhat is meaningless. each stgrawhat have their role. Carrot's one is a look out. This is UNDENIABLE as she has been drawn to the post more than 40 times. Stop with the BS.



Being surprised by the speed of Daifuku is not "failing" to the crew. Stop with the bad faith argument meant to diminish Carrot's role as a look out. It's starting to be ridicule. Usopp would be as surprised as Carrot in this situation.




Wrong, from the front.



Nah




A look out needs to see ships, not auras. bad argument. Her binocular are very usefull in fact



Carrot has been drawn as a look out, acted as a look out, interacted as a look out.. But she is not a look out.

Are you a clown ?

You talk about bad faith arguments but please look in the mirror.
That bit about needing to see ships not auras is a bfa, if any presence is felt that is a very big telling... but I guess we can't expect an honest answer from you.

 

[Logiko]

And what does that even prove? Nothing.
You are clinging to any little thing. That's not something someone with confidence does.

A surname is not "a little thing" it's - in the context of One Piece - a important narrative item. The surnames are mentionned multiple time in the story has being relevant. I'm not suddenly paying attention to that little thing. I'm observing a tendancy.

 

[Ravagerblade]

A surname is not "a little thing" it's - in the context of One Piece - a important narrative item. The surnames are mentionned multiple time in the story has being relevant. I'm not suddenly paying attention to that little thing. I'm observing a tendancy.

Yamato doesn't have a known surname. You are strawmaning. And Yamato still has all her narrative backing her up. The weight she pulls is light years in comparison to your beloved Carrot.

 

[Logiko]

What? Listen to yourself.

Luffy, Zoro, Sanji, Usopp and Jinbe would react much better at that situation than Carrot did. That is an undeniable manga fact based on the magic system that's in place in One Piece. Denying that or calling it headcanon is just either coping or outright intellectual dishonesty.

Headcanon and probably wrong for Usopp. Usopp might have observation haki it doesn't meant his reaction time is that good. Your intellectual dishonesty is using a panel drawn to make a surprise against the job of Carrot as a look out. THIS is intellectual dishonesty. Don't mix up the lines Billy.

 

[Ravagerblade]

Headcanon and probably wrong for Usopp. Usopp might have observation haki it doesn't meant his reaction time is that good. Your intellectual dishonesty is using a panel drawn to make a surprise against the job of Carrot as a look out. THIS is intellectual dishonesty. Don't mix up the lines Billy.

Usopp supposedly doesn't have a good reaction time? Strawmaning again. Dude just shut the fuck up at this point. You are an embarrassment.

 

[Logiko]

Yamato doesn't have a known surname. You are strawmaning. And Yamato still has all her narrative backing her up. The weight she pulls is light years in comparison to your beloved Carrot.

Yamato's surname is YamaO. Your are in denial. The narration is not backing up Yamato rather the opposite. You should pay more attention to the storytelling.

Post automatically merged: Nov 20, 2021

Usopp supposedly doesn't have a good reaction time? Strawmaning again. Dude just shut the fuck up at this point. You are an embarrassment.

No, just saying the obvious. You are ridicule. Also don't use rethoric word you don't understand.

 

[Ravagerblade]

Yamato's surname is YamaO. Your are in denial. The narration is not backing up Yamato rather the opposite. You should pay more attention to the storytelling.

Post automatically merged: Nov 20, 2021

No, just saying the obvious. You are ridicule.

Yeah Ok Troll. Pot meet kettle. Maybe spell out your words correctly before accusing other people of not using words properly.

 

[Logiko]

Yeah Ok Troll. Pot meet kettle.

That's all you have ?

 

[Ravagerblade]

That's all you have ?

Is that all I got? What do I need to post a paragraph for you? Get over yourself.

 

[Logiko]

Is that all I got? What do I need to post a paragraph for you? Get over yourself.

 

[Ravagerblade]

:holdthisl:

 

[Logiko]

:holdthisl:

lol you have issues

 

[Ravagerblade]

lol you have issues

That's a non issue and has nothing to do with the thread, But if you want to accuse people of things, then don't get offended when you get the same in return. But I am expecting something like that to go over your head, seeing as you can't see just how bad your arguments have been.
Continue with your ignorance.