Spoiler One Piece Chapter 1039 Spoilers Discussion

[Pantheos]

Just wanna clarify that What if she stand up in next chapter?

Dont see how. But should that happen, i take my L with all consequences. I can pay an even higher price if my bet wasnt risky enough for you back then.

 

[Kurozumi Wiwi]

Shes beaten but i dont think its total defeat

Look at the last page, bitch about to fly back down the the center of the earth

 

[Chrono]

"I take my W".

Obviously. Place a bet, lost and act it out.

Chickens out? That's you chickening out of your own fucking bet.

Whatever dude.

If its confirmed next chap….that means she was defeated this chap. You dont say Queen was defeated in 1035 or Albert in 1036. The annoucement chaps are just the aftermaths…

 

[Pot Goblin]

Yes, I'm refering to the strawhats having rematches with the awakened Tobi Roppo and Calamities.
It is my belief that these rematches would add a lot to the story actually. After the defeat of the strawhats we could actually get some emotional investment in the story, and I think that longer fights would payoff the long wait we've had of the strawhats not all getting their individual match ups.
We could also get to actually see Nami and Ussop fight if that happens too.
Luffy has fought Kaido in different settings, I don't see why other main characters can't do that too.

It worked with Luffy because he lost the fight with Kaido and as a result grew stronger from the experience. The rematch is the fruits of his labor in Udon + Onigashima. Why it doesn't work with the Tobi Roppo/All Stars is that they already won these fights and already received the fruits of their labor through their fights. The only Straw Hats that didn't grow in any way were Brook and Usopp and that's in the middle of being fixed right now as they're both actively doing things with vulnerable allies.

I'm going to use Sanji vs Queen as an example of what I mean by adding to the story.

If the raid failed at this point and Sanji fought Queen again, how can this rematch improve on the narrative progression that happened in the first fight? Sanji already went through the inner turmoil and recovered from it. How can a rematch add to this without rehashing already resolved plot points or relying on the feelings of the raid failing as a crutch? As if that's the case literally every fight will be like this and be incredibly boring.

And the big thing that I just can't get my head around is how is this raid going to fail in such a way that allows both sides to completely recover without consequences heavy enough to prevent these rematches from happening?

 

[Jackteo]

If she is defeated. You deserve your W

The point is that it is impossible to know if she was defeated just by reading chapter 1039. He needs-at least- chapter 1040 to prove his point. So he already lost.

Not that it is that important. Big Mom is not down and she will defeat them, so who cares

 

[Indigo]

Brago is gonna love this chapter

 

[Roo]

ya need to learn how to take an L

 

[Halyup]

Dont see how. But should that happen, i take my L with all consequences. I can pay an even higher price if my bet wasnt risky enough for you back then.

The chances of her standing up nxt chapter is pretty low but i wont rule her out , doin an akainu comeback in later chapters

 

[Sir Yasheen]

I just hope that the next time we see big mom she ends up falling down to the Big Mama Chanter that was about to climb the waterfall knocking it back down. (Big dream is she and Flampe end up drowning and dying)

 

[Formerly Seth]

If its confirmed next chap….that means she was defeated this chap. You dont say Queen was defeated in 1035 or Albert in 1036. The annoucement chaps are just the aftermaths…

I don't think she's defeated. Ur lad shown example of white eyes being completely meaningless. I don't think she is out for good yet.

If she is it's w/e. Panthyhoe was sure she will be done in this chapter. I disagree.

If she stands up next chapter who was right then? Me or pantheos?

 

[Roo]

I just hope that the next time we see big mom she ends up falling down to the Big Mama Chanter that was about to climb the waterfall knocking it back down. (Big dream is she and Flampe end up drowning and dying)

Jesus Christ she’s just a kid

 

[Formerly Seth]

I just hope that the next time we see big mom she ends up falling down to the Big Mama Chanter that was about to climb the waterfall knocking it back down. (Big dream is she and Flampe end up drowning and dying)

BM falling off of Onigashima to hit Queen Mama Chanter and drown with her kids would be the best ending to that joke of a character.

 

[Reborn]

Dont see how. But should that happen, i take my L with all consequences. I can pay an even higher price if my bet wasnt risky enough for you back then.

Well no need for higher price.


If she doesn't stand up in next chapter or shown Unconscious/Koed then logically she lost in this chapter and thus you should get your W.


But if she does stay conscious or standup in next chapter then you are taking the L.

 

[Roo]

I don't think she's defeated. Ur lad shown example of white eyes being completely meaningless. I don't think she is out for good yet.

If she is it's w/e. Panthyhoe was sure she will be done in this chapter. I disagree.

If she stands up next chapter who was right then? Me or pantheos?

I’m pretty sure pantheos said if it’s not official 1040 he loses

 

[Stargazer]

Dont see how. But should that happen, i take my L with all consequences. I can pay an even higher price if my bet wasnt risky enough for you back then.

What if she's stands up and then dies on her feet lol like whitebeard

 

[Kurozumi Wiwi]

What if she's stands up and then dies on her feet lol like whitebeard

Don't insult Whitebeard

 

[Obsidian]

This chapter was really good imo only complains i have is we didn't see more from BM in terms of haki and awakening

The art was great in this chap, Law the MVP & Kidd looked somehow useful.
My problems is that Oda decided to do that at the expense of BM.
I've mixed feelings about this chapter.
+I lost a bet, i'm biased!

 

[Formerly Seth]

Well no need for higher price.


If she doesn't stand up in next chapter or shown Unconscious/Koed then logically she lost in this chapter and thus you should get your W.


But if she does stay conscious or standup in next chapter then you are taking the L.

I’m pretty sure pantheos said if it’s not official 1040 he loses

So Pantheos playing 5D chess and actually spread his bet across multiple chapters?

If we are completely cut off from Big Mom and Kid/Law next chapter and lets say we see if she out or not in 10 chapters he can call himself a winner for at least 10 chapters worth of wait?

 

[Sir Yasheen]

Jesus Christ she’s just a kid

She’s 15 same age as chopper when he became a pirate. If she was 8 or 10 sure, but she’d be a high schooler and is just a bitch

 

[Nate D. White hawk]

The bitch will be at the sea floor unless her pirste ship come clutch
[automerge]1643924301[/automerge]

How is he gonna bake , mf is in coma

Just have a pretty lady pass by, better yet have yamato pass by, you'll be surprised how fast he would get up