I don't really understand how this disputes Ratchet's comment. What he said makes sense. Normally, in a game, the flavor and the alignments attached to it are pretty clear-cut, there's very little disagreement amongst the loremaster about it. But here, there's been several about who can be town or scum, etc. It indicates that the flavor isn't like the norm and there can be some tomfoolery involved. How does only 3-5 players disagreeing about the roles not enough for Ratchet to make that comment? Because generally, those 3-5 players are agreeing with each other.