General & Others Next Strawhat Crew Members and the Grand Fleet

[Logiko]

Where is her backstory then?

You are in her backstory.

 

[Ravagerblade]

You are in her backstory.

Wrong. That is not backstory, Stop making shit up, it's illogical. You continue to spout illegitimate nonsense.

 

[Flagandhat]

I don't ignore Wano, I'm just saying that it doesn't negates what was written in Whole Cake, Carrot is still the same character, still loves the sea, still a look out etc.



I'm not really defending Carrot, I'm defending the theory that she will join. But in general I like Carrot because she reminds me of the early Luffy.



People are not chill at all with Carrot, just look at this thread.



The monolog of Perospero is enough



Be recruited no, but joining the crew yes.

Carrot didn't do "nothing", she had a key role in saving Marco. Keep ignoring that and I will keep bringing it up.

You must stop thinking in term of arc, but in storyline and Saga. What happened on whole cake is ENOUGH for carrot to join.


Carrot's personal conflict has yet to be resolved. It wasn't resolve with Perospero.

Post automatically merged: Jul 24, 2022

A simple introspection from Carrot about her journey.



I have an article explaning that storytelling principle Here.

If I am honest. Sometimes I find so obvious that yamato will join that I also think "wait, maybe it is only a joke from Oda". But when you see the importance that Yamato is in the story line... It is easy to think that yamato deserve going with luffy ... In other words yamato has a more deep relationship in the world of one piece than carrot... This is the main reason ...

Every mugiwaras Have something of relationship in one piece story ... But carrot not ...

How do you believe that carrot will improve her importance in the story if she don´t know no one from the outside ?

Back on Orojackson one of the biggest obstacle Carrot faced was Wano itself, because WCI even back then was not not enough for her.

Everyone was saying that yes, the set-up was there.
: She's gotta inherit Pedro's will
: Revenge match with Perospero
: The dawn
: The sulong moment

But I ask you @CarrotForNakama in the 4yrs since that arc ended, what happened with the first 3 bullet points.

Why didn't she inherit his will?
Why did the revenge match get offscreened?
Pedro's comment on the dawn had nothing to do with her? Why?
Sulong isn't a unique power why is Carrot being treated differently?

The story for Carrot you wanted and the one Oda gave you are two completely different things. It's time to get over this.

The problem with carrot is that she share a lot of things with another character that make clear that she is not unique like the mugiwaras

Every minks has sulong NOT ONLY HER ( Maybe chopper some day will create a sulong for him using science)
She is not the only human rabbit we saw. Also that rabbit from whole cake in the forest. I am pretty bad with the names.
Her story is pretty similar with vivi story line.
All the minks uses electro, not only her, and nami use similar powers...
She only can jump so high but we have a sanji on the sunny....
She wasnt the unique mink in whole cake
And Luffy said "a island of choppers" so for luffy, chopper is a carrot so another carrot doesnt make sense.

 

[Mr. Reloaded]

Wrong. That is not backstory, Stop making shit up, it's illogical. You continue to spout illegitimate nonsense.

He's

You and I are just too dumb to see it.

 

[Peroroncino]

That's a lot of fighting over 2 characters that won't be joining the SHs

 

[Ravagerblade]

He's

You and I are just too dumb to see it.

You and I both know that emote is to show how idiotic and far reaching their logic is, not to mention it makes fun of the intelligence of another.
Which to be fair, I don't think he has any sign of actual intelligence.

 

[Mr. Reloaded]

That's a lot of fighting over 2 characters that won't be joining the SHs

Would you be willing to join @LubeDaddy in the bet against me in that case?

 

[Peroroncino]

Would you be willing to join @LubeDaddy in the bet against me in that case?

what do i get if i win?

 

[Mr. Reloaded]

what do i get if i win?

I wear an embarrassing profile pic of you guy's choosing.

 

[Peroroncino]

I wear an embarrassing profile pic of you guy's choosing.

i'll pass, can't have 2 chads against you at the same time

 

[Logiko]

Wrong. That is not backstory, Stop making shit up, it's illogical. You continue to spout illegitimate nonsense.

No, it's perfectly logical. You must ask yourself : what is a backstory.

Well a backstory is when the character gain a purpose and face a life changing tragedy. That's is what happening in the present for Carrot.

So again, you are in her backstory.

In other words yamato has a more deep relationship in the world of one piece than carrot...

With Wano, not with the world of One Piece.

Every mugiwaras Have something of relationship in one piece story ... But carrot not ...

The arc is not fiinished yet.

How do you believe that carrot will improve her importance in the story if she don´t know no one from the outside ?

You'll see.

 

[Peroroncino]

i already had to kick penis off the chad squad because of his insane takes

 

[Flagandhat]

Wrong. That is not backstory, Stop making shit up, it's illogical. You continue to spout illegitimate nonsense.

I read four times what is subversive affirmation but I dont get It. What the hell is that ? This is the only thing that is illogical for me...

 

[Ravagerblade]

No, it's perfectly logical. You must ask yourself : what is a backstory.

Well a backstory is when the character gain a purpose and face a life changing tragedy. That's is what happening in the present for Carrot.

So again, you are in her backstory.



With Wano, not with the world of One Piece.



The arc is not fiinished yet.



You'll see.

Backstory cannot be in the present, it's in the fucking word you dolt.

 

[Mr. Reloaded]

i already had to kick penis off the chad squad because of his insane takes

Should have been lurking. You would have known adding that man was a mistake

 

[Ravagerblade]

I read four times what is subversive affirmation but I dont get It. What the hell is that ? This is the only thing that is illogical for me...

It's best if you just look it up, if you go to C4N hell give you a false definition.

 

[Flagandhat]

No, it's perfectly logical. You must ask yourself : what is a backstory.

Well a backstory is when the character gain a purpose and face a life changing tragedy. That's is what happening in the present for Carrot.

So again, you are in her backstory.



With Wano, not with the world of One Piece.



The arc is not fiinished yet.



You'll see.

Yamato is relationed with wano ... But also yamato is relationed with one piece world in a deeper way than carrot.

For example. If Yamato - Oden. Go outside wano. If Yamato says "I am the son of kaido". People will have reasons to intereact with yamato. Carrot not... Carrot only could say "I am the son of my rabbit parents...". And I am not saying that in a bad way.

I believe that Yamato relationship with Ace and Kaido are better that carrot relationship with pedro in the world of one piece

Seriously. When would carrot have a better role in one piece ?

It's best if you just look it up, if you go to C4N hell give you a false definition.

Yeah ... I searched it on internet and I read a lot of things that have another definition... Why C4N try to give us a very false defintion ? To lie us or to lie himself in his world of subersive affirmation headcanons ?

 

[Logiko]

I read four times what is subversive affirmation but I dont get It. What the hell is that ? This is the only thing that is illogical for me...

My article is not clear enough ??

Backstory cannot be in the present, it's in the fucking word you dolt.

That's why it'snot a backstory you need to seek, it's what are IN the backstory. The backstory only takes place because there are elements IN IT that need to happen. If those elements are here without the backstory, you don't need a backstory.

For example. If Yamato - Oden. Go outside wano. If Yamato says "I am the son of kaido". People will have reasons to intereact with yamato. Carrot not... Carrot only could say "I am the son of my rabbit parents...". And I am not saying that in a bad way.

Everything isn't about connection to the world of One Piece.

Seriously. When would carrot have a better role in one piece ?

Not a better role, a different one.

 

[Random_Kurozumi]

Tama won't join

http://imgur.com/a/rzEslRn

source: Volume 27

 

[Mr. Reloaded]

That's why it'snot a backstory you need to seek, it's what are IN the backstory. The backstory only takes place because there are elements IN IT that need to happen. If those elements are here without the backstory, you don't need a backstory.