General & Others Next Strawhat Crew Members and the Grand Fleet

[ankama]

Pedro in Zou arc already surrounded Luffy in Whale Forest without being detected at all. Even with Luffy's CoO that easily sensed Caribou in Thousand Sunny, he was never aware that Pedro was above him in the treetop the whole time.
That is more impressive than Carrot randomly jumping around.

There was not only Pedro, but a lot of other Minks. It is not necessary to single him out, all perfectly concealed their presence.

 

[Sadistic Senpai]

I thought Sanji was the World Strongest Swordsman XD?

There is no need
Sanji is strongest martial arts user... martial arts includes all kinds of fighting style (swordsmanship is ONLY ONE TINY art)

 

[Warchief Sanji D Goat]

There is no need
Sanji is strongest martial arts user... martial arts includes all kinds of fighting style (swordsmanship is ONLY ONE TINY art)

:smithnie:

 

[Jew D. Boy]

King4nakama. No one even knows what he is

This is something I could get behind, he’s the last completely unknown quantity among the big baddies of the arc (Flying Six can’t be as powerful as him and the Numbers are clearly oni/demons) to the point that we don’t even know WHAT he is, let alone who.

 

[Paperchampion23]

What the fuck are you Smoking?
Calgara in his FIRST APPEARANCE did what Vice Admiral Garp did when he throw a HUUUUGE ASS Cannon ball at the Strawhat crew

Which all of them had to use fucking Cope De Burst to get out of there...

The same fucking move!

Calgara is far superior than your rabbit girl...

1. Shes not "my" rabbit girl, really could care less of she joins. In just advocating what I see, and she clearly, plainly has the highest chance out of any new character the past few arcs. Its painful to watch people argue otherwise.

2. I baited the calgara comment. All of you with your power dick measuring contests are getting tiring. Why does a new strawhat have to destroy warships to be a new crew member? We JUST got Jinbe, why does the possible next character have to be OP as fuck? This is not a carrot conversation, this a general one.


Seriously, arguments against Carrot have always been ridiculously silly, and to be quite fucking honest, are the EXACT same conversations people had about Jinbe:

- He has no role on the ship (before Helmsman was specified by Oda)
- Hes boring
- Hes fat
- He cant grow as a character


You all belittle a character who quite literally has not done anything wrong or is frankly not that annoying but you all blow it WAY out of proportion. I honestly hope she joins, just so it derails half of the forum that has an aneurysm every time her name is mentioned.

 

[ankama]

By the way, Luffy also needs cabin boys. Whitebeard and Roger had the cabin boy. Momo and O-Tama are suitable for this role. Although it is unlikely that anyone will let Momo go sailing after all the events in Wano. Too small, and the country needs a ruler.

 

[Sadistic Senpai]

LOL i actually stopped watching the anime around PH/DR, pace was toooo slow, but if you say so, im gonna check that one out

They did that scene justice
But really? you should check out AT LEAST Wano arc... I think it's the BEST animation-wise arc for One Piece this far....
I don't recall an arc in One Piece with better animation than Wano honestly...

In all other arcs... you get shitty animation in lots of scenes in the arc.. but some good highlight... except in Wano... where animation STANDARDS are much higher than average... and in highlight moments... there is godly animation

In my opinion you're missing out
AT LEAST in Wano animation

 

[TEACH D TEACH]

They did that scene justice
But really? you should check out AT LEAST Wano arc... I think it's the BEST animation-wise arc for One Piece this far....
I don't recall an arc in One Piece with better animation than Wano honestly...

In all other arcs... you get shitty animation in lots of scenes in the arc.. but some good highlight... except in Wano... where animation STANDARDS are much higher than average... and in highlight moments... there is godly animation

In my opinion you're missing out
AT LEAST in Wano animation

Ive seen Luffy vs Doffy/Cracker/Katakuri on youtube, but i couldnt be bothered going through all the episodes. Ive heard that Wano is good, i was planning on picking up from there when i find time. Good to hear anime is getting better as well

 

[Albino 👑]

 

[Sadistic Senpai]

O-tama Plot with Ace NEEDS to be addressed once again
She doesn't even know yet that Luffy is Ace's brother... Oda HAS TO revist the subject at one point

 

[Albino 👑]

Also not a big fan of momo joining but if he did...

• Luffy could help him become more of a leader
• Zoro and brook a swordsman
• Brook and sanji a pervert
• Robin could teach him to read the poneglyph
• Chopper being a better zoan
• Franky being a chad
• Etc.

 

[Paperchampion23]

O-tama Plot with Ace NEEDS to be addressed once again
She doesn't even know yet that Luffy is Ace's brother... Oda HAS TO revist the subject at one point

I really believe the tama plot will come full circle. Part of me believes she's orochi's (or someone's) illegitimate daughter and has a horrible past. Something with Tama, Tengu, etc is happening eventually.

 

[Monkey D Theories]

Carrot offers nothing meaningful to the crew. As a lookout, she is inferior to Usopp in almost every way. Usopp, due to his haki which he either has mastered or will master in wano, gives him a far bigger range than carrot. Also as a sniper, he can actually take care of a threat if he spots one.

 

[Kai. Do]

I dont like the vibe im getting from this at all. Hopefully he gets the Vivi treatment and doesnt sail out with them

I hate this shitty kid, praying to god he never joins.

 

[Kai. Do]

Carrot offers nothing meaningful to the crew. As a lookout, she is inferior to Usopp in almost every way. Usopp, due to his haki which he either has mastered or will master in wano, gives him a far bigger range than carrot. Also as a sniper, he can actually take care of a threat if he spots one.

Yeah i don't want carrot to join either.

 

[thedarkdragon11]

Carrot offers nothing meaningful to the crew. As a lookout, she is inferior to Usopp in almost every way. Usopp, due to his haki which he either has mastered or will master in wano, gives him a far bigger range than carrot. Also as a sniper, he can actually take care of a threat if he spots one.

I don't see something relevant with Carrot enough to benefit the crew... I feel she will just give them more burden... She can't even save herself from Katakuri and can potentially stall Sanji (as seen when Daifuku's genie attacked them), plus she will be just another addition to those who are vulnerable to Logia users...

 

[Monkey D Theories]

I don't see something relevant with Carrot enough to benefit the crew... I feel she will just give them more burden... She can't even save herself from Katakuri and can potentially stall Sanji (as seen when Daifuku's genie attacked them), plus she will be just another addition to those who are vulnerable to Logia users...

If chopper awakens CoA, I think he would probably be way stronger than her. I mean it took an elephant gun by Luffy to take out monster chopper, and chopper could still have a more powerful form as we haven't seen him eat 3 rumble balls post-skip

 

[thedarkdragon11]

If chopper awakens CoA, I think he would probably be way stronger than her. I mean it took an elephant gun by Luffy to take out monster chopper, and chopper could still have a more powerful form as we haven't seen him eat 3 rumble balls post-skip

True... That aside from Chopper's unused Jump Point... Oh, have we seen him take 2 RBs after TS?

 

[ShinmenTakezo]

Carrot was entertaining.

 

[Tejas]

Carrot was less entertaining than Pekoms.

Fixed.