- Status
Depends. As seen with the other game, it only takes one player to mess it up last minute. Moreover, even if mislynches costs, no lynch costs too. Mislynch could provide info and help with night phase and reads. It’s up to town to decide to be a sitting duck or to take action.
but don’t take this as an encouragement to lynch someone just for the sake of it. We have 48 hours to figure something out, I think something is ought to come up. There is always going to be a person more suspicious than others
but don’t take this as an encouragement to lynch someone just for the sake of it. We have 48 hours to figure something out, I think something is ought to come up. There is always going to be a person more suspicious than others
D
Yes, it does. If your reads are forced then it means that they're fake and disingenuous. It means that you're only coming up with them to fake contribution.
Yes, I saw. What I'm asking you is why are those reasons forced and not genuine? What makes you think it's a forced suspicion and not a genuine one?
Yes, I saw. What I'm asking you is why are those reasons forced and not genuine? What makes you think it's a forced suspicion and not a genuine one?
N
Regarding Bogard vs TAC - not taking sides, but blowing up over someone answering a question right off the bat ended up backfiring spectacularly, and voting to lynch when it wasn’t completely necessary left a bad taste in everyone’s mouth. Bogard seems to be attacking pretty aggressively, can’t tell if it’s a cover up or not...but his certainty in taking that particular action makes me a bit suspicious. TAC could be scum, but helping someone understand the game is nowhere near a clear indication of that.
Then I’m more than a little confused, why does that make Bogard suspicious?? Some people are putting WAAAY too much importance on the earliest remarks made here; I can’t speak for everyone, but I think asking and answering questions aren’t inherently suspicious...
(Real life note - I’m pretty stoned right now, so my reads may be off, but I still think it’s nonsense for anyone to vote to lynch right now for any reason)
(Real life note - I’m pretty stoned right now, so my reads may be off, but I still think it’s nonsense for anyone to vote to lynch right now for any reason)
GLADLY!
This post specifically @Reborn. Let me quote the specific part.
The way he makes this sound, it's as if he's trying to say I contradicted myself by saying I didn't read the OP. Which is a lie. Never did I say that.
If we're generous to Bogard, it's him misphrasing what he meant. I'm not feeling particularly generous, given his push on me.
This post specifically @Reborn. Let me quote the specific part.
The way he makes this sound, it's as if he's trying to say I contradicted myself by saying I didn't read the OP. Which is a lie. Never did I say that.
If we're generous to Bogard, it's him misphrasing what he meant. I'm not feeling particularly generous, given his push on me.
It's honestly really frustrating.
Bogard thinks I'm suspicious because I asked NeutralWatcher about his comment. I read the OP and I didn't see 48 hour phases mentioned, so I wanted to see what that's about.
Bogard says I'm playing dumb (my first real comment of the game, second in total) and that I shouldn't defer to less experienced Mafia players... When I was quoting and responding as I read thru the first 3 pages, of which I was not present for.
Bogard thinks I'm suspicious because I asked NeutralWatcher about his comment. I read the OP and I didn't see 48 hour phases mentioned, so I wanted to see what that's about.
Bogard says I'm playing dumb (my first real comment of the game, second in total) and that I shouldn't defer to less experienced Mafia players... When I was quoting and responding as I read thru the first 3 pages, of which I was not present for.
- Status