[FNZ] Role Madness Valentine's Mafia Game: Be My Valentine

[Charlie]

Jess would have to kill to since she lied about Godha dying, so she can kill Shannon

If Jesicca killed Shannon, there's noone for doctor to kill

 

[DoflaMihawk]

If Jesicca killed Shannon, there's noone for doctor to kill

Doc kills everyone at t1

 

[Charlie]

Doc kills everyone at t1

So doc kills everyone T1.
T2 Kurosuhi kills Krauss or whatever.
Jesicca kills Shannon T4
Godha kills Kumasawa T5/6.
Godha kills doctor T7.
Godha kills Jesicca T8.

?

ngl, that's way too convoluted imo

 

[Charlie]

I really like this more :/

Kyrie kills 5 people, fakes own death.
T2 Kurosuhi kills Krauss or whatever.
Doctor kills Godha and Kumasawa or/and Shannon.
Kyrie kills everyone else.

 

[DoflaMihawk]

So doc kills everyone T1.

T2 Kurosuhi kills Krauss or whatever.

Jesicca kills Shannon T4

Godha kills Kumasawa T5/6.

Godha kills doctor T7.

Godha kills Jesicca T8.



?



ngl, that's way too convoluted imo

Trust me, this is tame compared to the actual series.

 

[Charlie]

i'll just drop Vote Lynch Alwaysmind admitting it's just for money .-. I'll focus on actually playing mafia more next cycle

 

[Charlie]

Trust me, this is tame compared to the actual series.

to be fair, while reading Murder on the Orient Express i thought that this one royal lady was the killer

Spoiler

and it turned out it's literally everyone except for her

 

[DoflaMihawk]

I really like this more :/



Kyrie kills 5 people, fakes own death.

T2 Kurosuhi kills Krauss or whatever.

Doctor kills Godha and Kumasawa or/and Shannon.

Kyrie kills everyone else.

Wouldn't Battler have to lie about Kyrie being dead then?

 

[Apollo]

In other words, you could in theory extrapolate that one statement from Shannon into three purple statements, one from Battler declaring the death of Rudolf and Kyrie, one from George, declaring the death of Eva and Hideyoshi, and one from Maria, declaring the death of Rosa.

@Charlie Kyrie is considered Battler's parent as well. I don't think she was the one to do the killing.

 

[Charlie]

Wouldn't Battler have to lie about Kyrie being dead then?

i am under assumption that he didn't really check and Shannon assumed he did

 

[Charlie]

@Charlie Kyrie is considered Battler's parent as well. I don't think she was the one to do the killing.

who do you think did?

 

[Apollo]

who do you think did?

The doctor is suspicious, but he isn't working alone. There are probably multiple killers, with some killers maybe killing others.

 

[Charlie]

The doctor is suspicious, but he isn't working alone. There are probably multiple killers, with some killers maybe killing others.

i mean, doctor killing someone is basically given

i'm asking about d1 though

 

[Apollo]

i mean, doctor killing someone is basically given

i'm asking about d1 though

You mean T1.
I found it suspicious that all heirs died except Krauss, I think he was a prime suspect with some aid from a servant. Then another culprit killed him and Natsuhi in their room and locked them in. Although things get complex in my assumption here, I don't think the killer of Krauss and Natsuhi has to be a servant.

 

[Charlie]

I found it suspicious that all heirs died except Krauss, I think he was a prime suspect with some aid from a servant. Then another culprit killed him and Natsuhi in their room and locked them in. Although things get complex in my assumption here, I don't think the killer of Krauss and Natsuhi has to be a servant.

who are 2 people who survived though?

 

[Apollo]

who are 2 people who survived though?

Read the red facts again. At least 5 were killed on T1, meaning only one possibily lived.

 

[Apollo]

The culprit of the first twilight (first set of murders) really did kill at least 5 people.

@Charlie Here. At best only one lived.

 

[DoflaMihawk]

Also Kyrie couldn't have killed both Nanjo and Jessica. The guesthouse was locked up when they found Nanjo, so Kyrie would've had to be inside and somehow run past everyone to catch up to Jessica











Godha doesn't have that restriction since his key was never confirmed as destroyed, so he can lock up from the outside after killing Nanjo

 

[Charlie]

Also Kyrie couldn't have killed both Nanjo and Jessica. The guesthouse was locked up when they found Nanjo, so Kyrie would've had to be inside and somehow run past everyone to catch up to Jessica











Godha doesn't have that restriction since his key was never confirmed as destroyed, so he can lock up from the outside after killing Nanjo

it was locked according to doctor

 

[Apollo]

Also Kyrie couldn't have killed both Nanjo and Jessica. The guesthouse was locked up when they found Nanjo, so Kyrie would've had to be inside and somehow run past everyone to catch up to Jessica











Godha doesn't have that restriction since his key was never confirmed as destroyed, so he can lock up from the outside after killing Nanjo

Neither was Kamasuwa's key confirmed, right?

Only reason I suspect Gohda is that he was more active, but it seems silly from my part.