Game 01: Generic Mafia [Game Thread]

[Bogard]

Lmao @Reborn you can't even think outside of the box and pretend to be a detective lol.

When you first ask me a question in this game, when did I reply? Something like 4hours later. You even posted ojn my wall asking me to participate and I told you I was at work

There is also timezone to consider. I'm in Germany(just like Playa) and currently 8:30 am. There was night in between with people usually having 5 - 7 hours sleep. I'm readying myself to work again as we speak, arriving at 9:00. Finishing job at 5:00pm.

In other words, I don't have much time in the first place, but I try to be as active as I can. Yesterday was also one piece chapter, so dedicated some of that time for chapter reviews, hype or other stuffs especially since last time I checked this mafia game, it was quite inactive. After that I was busy with other stuffs

And lol at me not replying to Rej. I replied to him right after he asked me to reply to your second question, saying that it's too early for me to claim who is mafia, needing more material for that

I'd look into this game again when I'm at work. I usually have some free time allowing me to lurk in the forum

 

[Naomi]

@Izumi how many hrs left for voting?

 

[TheAncientCenturion]

@Izumi how many hrs left for voting?

@playa4321 needs to unvote @Kiwipom too. And I think Kiwi went to bed..

 

[Gambit]

Naomi why did scamper off our debate like buggy? No more fluids to spill?

Post automatically merged: Sep 20, 2019

@playa4321 needs to unvote @Kiwipom too. And I think Kiwi went to bed..

You may wanna unvote there, too.

Post automatically merged: Sep 20, 2019

And what can u say about Naomi?

 

[Naomi]

@playa4321 needs to unvote @Kiwipom too. And I think Kiwi went to bed..

well i don't want kiwi lynched off. We need three votes, plus gambit if he really town can roll in salt.


But depending how many hrs left, i will put it back on him, or go for playa who did not unvote till now.

Post automatically merged: Sep 20, 2019

I change my vote to Gambit

I'll just leave that there, since gambit was not concerned and ignored that and then went to lynch kiwi after playa put lynch on them

 

[Reborn]

Lmao @Reborn you can't even think outside of the box and pretend to be a detective lol.

that hurts you know

Anyway, you should be glad that I didn't vote on you as of now giving you the benefit of doubt regarding your hectic schedule involving work and being admin of this forum.

But let me be blunt here. You can't blame me for not so clear responses you left yesterday and I am still finding you suspicious. May be not enough to vote on you but you are in my suspicious list.


Also can anyone tell me what's stand all of you taking. Only one and a half hour left before day 1 ends.

If in case we get tie vote then @Izumi will you do random lynching or no lynching?

 

[Finalbeta]

The Gambit / Kiwipom situation is pretty tricky. Right now I believe Gambit is the one who could end up scummy, but on his behalf I find he hasn't just spent his dayphase trying to 'shadow' other players but somehow also tried solving the game from an analytic standpoint like for example Rej was capable of doing. This is townie-like behaviour.

I have a sensation scum could underlay amongst inactives as well, this set-up broadly advantages who sits on the back/sidelines and make other players be suspected in their place.

I recall Celestia throwing - something almost tantrum-like - at TAC, then disappearing from the game. She should have kept explaining herself instead of basically ending her day like that since she never showed up again. Helping out newbies is a fine behaviour however it doesn't match with the rest of her actions, so I'm starting getting very suspicious of her, despite Haku and Vonal also ever hardly showed up.

Vote Lynch Celestia

 

[Gambit]

that hurts you know

Anyway, you should be glad that I didn't vote on you as of now giving you the benefit of doubt regarding your hectic schedule involving work and being admin of this forum.

But let me be blunt here. You can't blame me for not so clear responses you left yesterday and I am still finding you suspicious. May be not enough to vote on you but you are in my suspicious list.


Also can anyone tell me what's stand all of you taking. Only one and a half hour left before day 1 ends.

If in case we get tie vote then @Izumi will you do random lynching or no lynching?

Pretty sure it's via RNG..

Post automatically merged: Sep 20, 2019

The Gambit / Kiwipom situation is pretty tricky. Right now I believe Gambit is the one who could end up scummy, but on his behalf I find he hasn't just spent his dayphase trying to 'shadow' other players but somehow also tried solving the game from an analytic standpoint like for example Rej was capable of doing. This is townie-like behaviour.

I have a sensation scum could underlay amongst inactives as well, this set-up broadly advantages who sits on the back/sidelines and make other players be suspected in their place.

I recall Celestia throwing - something almost tantrum-like - at TAC, then disappearing from the game. She should have kept explaining herself instead of basically ending her day like that since she never showed up again. Helping out newbies is a fine behaviour however it doesn't match with the rest of her actions, so I'm starting getting very suspicious of her, despite Haku and Vonal also ever hardly showed up.

Vote Lynch Celestia

Ok.. What do u think of Naomi? What do u think of Bombard vs Reborn?

 

[Reborn]

Here it is

Kiwipom has one vote from Playa

Bogard has one vote from rej

Celestia has one vote from final

Gambit has two votes from kiwi and TAC. I think kiwi went to bed as she is from north America and it's night time there. So kiwi can't lynch gambit off.

Pretty sure it's via RNG..

Post automatically merged: Sep 20, 2019

Ok.. What do u think of Naomi? What do u think of Bombard vs Reborn?

What's RNG?

 

[Naomi]

Here it is

Kiwipom has one vote from Playa

Bogard has one vote from rej

Celestia has one vote from final

Gambit has two votes from kiwi and TAC. I think kiwi went to bed as she is from north America and it's night time there. So kiwi can't lynch gambit off.


What's RNG?

randomly generated (game phrase) but basically randomly picked who will die, by the host.

 

[Reborn]

Okay I think I made a mistake here. @playa4321 whom you voted? Can you clarify

 

[Finalbeta]

Ok.. What do u think of Naomi? What do u think of Bombard vs Reborn?

Well Bogard clearly stated he still has to make his case and will do when at work. He has been very inactive but at the same time explained his reasons instead of just lurking the thread so I'm waiting for his post.

About Reborn and Naomi I don't find many anomalies in their behavior honestly, they are playing very similarly than in King's game. Moreover if we consider how difficult that is for a newbie (Reborn) I find the odds for him to flip scum are low for now meta-wise.

 

[Naomi]

They might be subbed out or modkilled so let's leave them out for now
Let's focus on who is active
I see players making excuses about inactivity or being too passive this don't look so towny

 

[Reborn]

@TheAncientCenturion @Gambit @playa4321 @Naomi @Rej @Finalbeta what's your final stand.

Be careful in your decisions as we don't want to lynch a townie at any cost which could reduce our number by 3 before day 2 begins

Kiwi has one vote on gambit and she is offline.

 

[Gambit]

Ok. I will save my towniness right here and vote for celestia... I think FB's reason is valid one... I still have things to do

Vote Celestia

 

[Naomi]

@TheAncientCenturion @Gambit @playa4321 @Naomi @Rej @Finalbeta what's your final stand.

Be careful in your decisions as we don't want to lynch a townie at any cost which could reduce our number by 3 before day 2 begins

Kiwi has one vote on gambit and she is offline.

hold on sec, I know tradition mafia serial killer does not win with mafia. So does vanilla sk win with mafia?

Post automatically merged: Sep 20, 2019

@Izumi I can't find rules for vanilla, is sk vanilla allied with mafia win?

 

[Reborn]

hold on sec, I know tradition mafia serial killer does not win with mafia. So does vanilla sk win with mafia?

What's the difference? Don't complicate it for me..

My yesterday research indicated that sk has least chance to win because he needs to eliminate both townie and mafia. I don't know the exact distinction because there are too many variants mafia which adds to confusion @Izumi can clarify more

 

[Naomi]

What's the difference? Don't complicate it for me..

My yesterday research indicated that sk has least chance to win because he needs to eliminate both townie and mafia. I don't know the exact distinction because there are too many variants mafia which adds to confusion @Izumi can clarify more

In some games sk can win with mafia, I'm question if this vanilla game is set up is like that. So can get better understanding.

for example, if it's like that with mafia/sk win.


then one option is mafia town cop got lucky and found them, so this let's mafia know who is town and who to lynch off. avoiding the sk if this is the case.

Post automatically merged: Sep 20, 2019

But if it's not like that, then the mafia cop would need to lynch them off, thus getting town cred.

can go either way depending on the setup.

 

[Reborn]

In some games sk can win with mafia, I'm question if this vanilla game is set up is like that. So can get better understanding.

for example, if it's like that with mafia/sk win.


then one option is mafia town cop got lucky and found them, so this let's mafia know who is town and who to lynch off. avoiding the sk if this is the case.

Post automatically merged: Sep 20, 2019

But if it's not like that, then the mafia cop would need to lynch them off, thus getting town cred.

can go either way depending on the setup.

Hmm we will talk about this in next day phase

But as of now we need to take care of voting. Can you confirm this?

We have two votes on Celestia by final and gambit

We have one vote on Bogard by rej

Two votes on gambit by kiwi and TAC

And, one vote on kiwi by Playa

 

[Naomi]

Hmm we will talk about this in next day phase

But as of now we need to take care of voting. Can you confirm this?

We have two votes on Celestia by final and gambit

We have one vote on Bogard by rej

Two votes on gambit by kiwi and TAC

And, one vote on kiwi by Playa

Yes, we need to get three votes, though i'm not fan of lynching inactives (because time zone, but not to say some could just be lurking scum)

Even if @playa4321 claimed to do it just for a reaction, it’s still suspicious. @Vonal, any ideas why he targeted you of all people?

This post here for example, show they paid attention to last game. As i remember stating some people put false reaction post to form lynch train. and the fact playa still has vote on her till now when day phase is about to end.

Usually this type of angle person says reaction,but scum can use this to bait town. Works both ways. and so far playa fine sitting back with his vote on her, while day phase about to end.


That speaks more scum tactic to me.