[FNZ] Salem of Lies Round 09: Throne of Lies

Status
Not open for further replies.

TheAncientCenturion

I will never forgive Oda
‎‎‎
natallija also claims to have investigated nuetral last night
and she thinks he's seeker.
So let me get this straight....

Yo Tan verifies Nat.
Nat claims she invested NeutralWatcher.
NeutralWatcher claims he invested Queen.

So, NeutralWatcher is almost the key to understanding Queen's affiliation, whether or not Nat can be trusted and then whether or not Yo Tan can be trusted.
 
@Yo Tan Wa what you think of cinera and flower situation?
I first suspected both Flower n Tac cult members working together.
Then Flower acting Scorn D2 to keep us into thinking she was Fool acting Scorn so to not get lynched.

Bt with so many claims everything messed up. Didn't sus Cinera as much last Night phase, bt since he was inactive today, thought he might be converted last Night, hence quoted hkm to get his opinion. Don't think Cinera used Flower, if he was Fool he would have achived getting Lynched anyway.
Bt Sera n Cinera nw, it could also be Cult relying on sacrificial strategies, Hence Sera could have claimed Butler role.

Problm with all this is Queen gameplay also was unusual rhat would bave cleared Tac as cult. None of the things so far are going in our favoue.
Our Investigative Users are susing each others when they shpuld be sussing major sus, and so many role have been claimed.
 
Tac why are you highlighting it?
Initially I did. But when going back to make my strategy, I went to the wiki to quote the killing powers. I saw the cooldown and decided that Nat's statement is a lot less suspicious because of that. Her early insistence on Unseen / not trusting NeutralWatcher early on is off. Because, IMO, it was good to trust NeutralWatcher before this kerfuffle expanded alongside his own self doubt
Not convinced.

Also i only see you saying Cool down period, is this TMI?
I'll accept that my strategy is unorthodox. But let's look at the deck we've been handed Yotan. We can't trust our two TI claims. I just skimmed the last 8 pages and it seems NeutralWatcher's even less of a solid source now? There's some issue with messed up results, he claims? As of last night, Nat was a big source of suspicion.

So, in my remedy to this, we manage to play in a way that let's not rely on TI. But on consistent reads.
No i mean why you didn't cross check, question Queen who claimed your role?
o, NeutralWatcher is almost the key to understanding Queen's affiliation, whether or not Nat can be trusted and then whether or not Yo Tan can be trusted.
Are you suggesting lynching NW?

Also, Tac you didn't reply to my previous post? Kiwi don't agree her Gameplay changed, what towncleared her for you in D3.
 

Finalbeta

Zoro Worshipper
So there's indeed a chance a role has framed Flower? But can this apply with Queen as well?

In that case my primary suspect would be Cinera since him and Sera claimed the same role however the former observed the weirdest behaviour in the game so far
 
This is just weird.

NW flipfloppin

Nata isn't credible to me

Sera claims cinera is lying

Queen and tac claimed physician but queen wanted DA to get lynched first while tac wanted no Lynch at all

Now let's assume there is can't be duplication then definitely
Between queen and tac - one is LYING

Between - sera and cinera one is lying.

And,our invest reads aren't credible

Now, if I consider timing of sera claim then if he was cult then he could have simply taken back seat with already big mess going on.

But instead he proactive claimed cinera is lying. This doesn't sound like scummy.

Infact, I actually believe sera because if cinera doesn't flip Butlersl then he would be branded as sus yet instead of hiding under such messy situation, he claimed cinera is lying. This doesn't seem to be scummy game play


So, Vote lynch cinera
Your logic is all over the place, this is why I think you’re dodgy.
It got me Mis-Lynched.
Hehehe, clever answer.
No, they did not surely convert two players. They might have targeted conversion immune players, they might have been redirected, they might have been Role Blocked. There are many ways the night interactions could have played out so far, and there's not much reason to assume that Cult was able to successfully convert both nights.
.
That’s a lot of might haves, my friend. As I said, there are a lot of players, so it’s not that hard to pick two BY LUCK EVEN and convert them. It’s a scenario we should go by instead of being optimistic.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top