General & Others Next Straw Hat Crew Members and the Grand Fleet
- Thread starter Uncle Van
- Start date
- Tags #c4ng2g carrot fans are still losers carrot haters are real losers seethe at the rabbit carrot is doing nothing because she doesn't matter carrot will never join the straw hats carrot's story never even began cry about carrot everyone else in the verse neg diffs the bunny imagine thinking stussy won't join its over furry bros keep the bunny on zou nobody else needs her let it go furry bros momo is breeding yamato no character is less relevant than carrot oden larper fans can't read stussy > carrot & yamato stussy supremacy who will be the next nakama of the week? yamato always had a better chance than carrot yamato story is over
1. No flashback, we disagreed with you that it doesn't matter.
2. She was never the center of an arc.
3. Luffy never defeated her personal villain.
4. Most importantly, she was missing for 250 chapters in the arc where she was supposedly going to join. This was a dead giveaway to the rest of us
You can claim none of this matters, but we were right in the end.
2. She was never the center of an arc.
3. Luffy never defeated her personal villain.
4. Most importantly, she was missing for 250 chapters in the arc where she was supposedly going to join. This was a dead giveaway to the rest of us
You can claim none of this matters, but we were right in the end.
Oh indeed, I remember those argurment, that I actually debunked.
First, I never said that a flashback doesn't matter I said that it was not necessary and I proved it. But for that you need to read what I said if not you can't understand my point.
Which is not a requirement to join the crew, just a requierement to become a strawhat.
Same.
But those two I actually take into account, so those are not argument that I debated. Those are just part of what make a strawhat a strawhat. I proved that there are not all there is.
This was indeed the only good argument and good reasonning.
This would require an entirely new storyline but its possible.
First, I never said that a flashback doesn't matter I said that it was not necessary and I proved it. But for that you need to read what I said if not you can't understand my point.
Which is not a requirement to join the crew, just a requierement to become a strawhat.
Same.
But those two I actually take into account, so those are not argument that I debated. Those are just part of what make a strawhat a strawhat. I proved that there are not all there is.
This was indeed the only good argument and good reasonning.
This would require an entirely new storyline but its possible.
Yes, because Oda can easily do that if he doesn’t want to deal with a character anymore; find a reason to send them off without suddenly erasing them from the story. Rushed pacing can also cause decisions like these to be made, and Wano ended right after One Piece Film: Red released.
I’ve stated this before in the past, I don’t like Yamato’s personality because it isn’t her personality to begin with. IIRC she went as far as to claim Momonosuke was her son when they first met. A dead man‘s son, mind you. The memory of his father’s death was still fresh in his mind when she did that.
I had a plan for Yamato’s character that could’ve worked to fix her. Have her join the Straw Hats, and overtime she would develop her own character after seeing the world with her own eyes. She’d drop the Oden persona after deciding to live life the way she wants to, and explore the places Oden didn’t write about in his logbook.
Something like that, anyway.
This won’t work very well if Yamato ends up joining near EoS, which could happen unless Oda goes back to Wano right after Egghead or Elbaf. We don’t know how many islands are left for the Straw Hats to go to but I’m sure there aren’t a whole lot that we haven’t already seen.
There’s no point in introducing a Straw Hat if there’s only one or two arcs left, which is why I think Vivi would work well. We’re already familiar with her, and we have been for years.
I don’t see any reason for an Admiral to join a pirate crew. If you put him next to the other Straw Hats, he’d be an odd fit. It’d be like trying to put a circle into a triangle box. I take this into account when I think about potential candidates.
I’ve stated this before in the past, I don’t like Yamato’s personality because it isn’t her personality to begin with. IIRC she went as far as to claim Momonosuke was her son when they first met. A dead man‘s son, mind you. The memory of his father’s death was still fresh in his mind when she did that.
I had a plan for Yamato’s character that could’ve worked to fix her. Have her join the Straw Hats, and overtime she would develop her own character after seeing the world with her own eyes. She’d drop the Oden persona after deciding to live life the way she wants to, and explore the places Oden didn’t write about in his logbook.
Something like that, anyway.
This won’t work very well if Yamato ends up joining near EoS, which could happen unless Oda goes back to Wano right after Egghead or Elbaf. We don’t know how many islands are left for the Straw Hats to go to but I’m sure there aren’t a whole lot that we haven’t already seen.
There’s no point in introducing a Straw Hat if there’s only one or two arcs left, which is why I think Vivi would work well. We’re already familiar with her, and we have been for years.
I don’t see any reason for an Admiral to join a pirate crew. If you put him next to the other Straw Hats, he’d be an odd fit. It’d be like trying to put a circle into a triangle box. I take this into account when I think about potential candidates.
They were all good reasoning. You debunked nothing. We were proven right in the end.
As for Yamato, her story is wide open since she is only staying in Wano out of a sense of responsibility, which is against Momo's wishes and against her own dream. All that needs to happen is for Momo to find out that she lied about her reason for staying, or for Wano to become strong enough to protect itself.
As for Yamato, her story is wide open since she is only staying in Wano out of a sense of responsibility, which is against Momo's wishes and against her own dream. All that needs to happen is for Momo to find out that she lied about her reason for staying, or for Wano to become strong enough to protect itself.
Example ?
Wano was not rushed.
That's her quirk therefore a personnality. The fact that you had a plan for her don't change that lol
Why ?
Yes I did, you are just in denial lol
No, her story is finished, you should know this very well. The thread prepared for her were closed. The choices she had to make were made and the journey she had to take to discover herself was made. To recreate that Oda could start from where he left, but he would need to recreate entire storylines.
That wouldn't change Yamato's character. For a new story to happen, something must happen to Yamato character on a basic level. You know, Need, desire, beliefs, weaknesses etc.
It was never a dream. Its a responsibility.
Wano was not rushed.
That's her quirk therefore a personnality. The fact that you had a plan for her don't change that lol
Why ?
Yes I did, you are just in denial lol
No, her story is finished, you should know this very well. The thread prepared for her were closed. The choices she had to make were made and the journey she had to take to discover herself was made. To recreate that Oda could start from where he left, but he would need to recreate entire storylines.
That wouldn't change Yamato's character. For a new story to happen, something must happen to Yamato character on a basic level. You know, Need, desire, beliefs, weaknesses etc.
It was never a dream. Its a responsibility.
Carrot's story is finished, you should know this very well. The threads prepared for her were closed. The choices she had to make were made and the journey she had to take to discover herself was made. To recreate that Oda could start from where he left, but he would need to recreate entire storylines
You clearly don't understand Yamato's character arc. Since she didn't join, you assumed you're arguments were all correct, but they specifically adressed your theory that Yamato just wants to explore Wano and she admitted it was a lie because she knew Momo wouldn't let her stay if it was just to protect him.