Chapter Discussion No one deserves to get laughed at after they die

#50
This is the one edit that gets me every time!
:gokulaugh:
Post automatically merged:

Mfers in this thread unironically believe that the Straw Hats 20 years into the story are ever in real danger of dying horrific deaths, and should die. Pretending that the series doesn't spoil Luffy winning the day at the end of it within Chapter 1.

Mfers its a fun adventure about the future pirate king, and we're a few arcs away from him just being the current Pirate King. You are kidding yourself if you still buy "OH DAMN SATURNS GONNA KILL LUFFY!11!!" at this point. Having a laughing power up fits this series tone more than a stone faced Luffy clad in full Haki. He doesn't *like* being deadfaced serious, and now he can fight in his truest form. A happy go lucky goofball who likes fighting for those he cares about.

Kaido liked being a power scaler, Big Moms whole kit is centered around ordering her homies around, Akainu likes to erupt like a volcano, and the cool Aokiji freezes people. Why can't the smiling and laughing Luffy smile and laugh at the peak of his power?

Roger laughs while he fights, why can't Luffy? He's not a fucking hero he's a goddamn motherfucking pirate who has literal murderers on his crew.
That’s precisely the problem though. Knowing that Luffy will win at the end doesn’t mean that we shouldn’t expect him to be serious when the situation calls for it.

In fact, that’s the way the story has always been. The Nika nonsense is actually the opposite of that. You can see it in every single major fight prior to Wano. When it comes to the final round of all of them, Luffy hardly ever smiles let alone laughs:
Crocodile
Enel
Lucci
Moriah
Hordy
Caesar
Doflamingo
Katakuri

When I last counted, Luffy smiles or laughs more in the Gear 5 fight with Kaido than in the last rounds of every one of those previous fights combined.

Luffy’s joy/goofiness is one of his defining traits…but so too is his anger/vengefulness. Both go hand in hand, and acting like only one of those defines Luffy has never made any sense.
 
Last edited:
#53
Vegapunk ain't dead bro

this is One Piece
And since Luffy became Nika he is aware he is the main character of a manga so he already knows that. There is a "meta" factor in Gear 5. Mistery solved. :willsmith:

By the way this Nika thing its inspired by Looney Tunes and The Mask but its also a weed/drugs metaphor,isnt it? Luffy is like stoned right now lol
 
Last edited:
#54
It feels like this post and the reaction for gear 5 in this chapter is a side effect of agenda brain rote, it's been said that awakenings has a chance effects someones personality and it has been said luffy acts differently in gear 5 pacificly laughing, he transforms he smiles and laughs it doesn't takes away the danger from situation if it's just a side effect of a transformation.
 
#56
Like I said a million times.

Vegapunk isn't dying.

Kuma isnt either.

Oda will go through the motions of making it look like VP will die but then be healed by Chopper and some miracle science on egghead
 
#58
It feels like this post and the reaction for gear 5 in this chapter is a side effect of agenda brain rote, it's been said that awakenings has a chance effects someones personality and it has been said luffy acts differently in gear 5 pacificly laughing, he transforms he smiles and laughs it doesn't takes away the danger from situation if it's just a side effect of a transformation.
You don’t need to be a part of the agenda nonsense to view this as being poor taste.

Also, saying “this is the effect of a transformation” doesn’t stop that effect from being terrible.
 
#60
I think the only possible way Oda can salvage this G5 shit is if it turns out Joyboy/Nika isn't actually all he's cracked up to be and is more of a chaos god, and the sort of maniacal possession Luffy is under is indicative of this. Doubt it though.

The dick sucking of Nika from other characters like the giants is atrocious and the most cringe element of the series atm.

Think Oda is just losing his touch, a humorous author once capable of writing likeable characters has completely forgotten how to do either effectively, and his only recourse is to constantly remind the reader what they should be thinking in the most forced way possible.

"Please Love Oden!!!"

"G5 IS REALLY FUNNY, PLEASE LAUGH"
 
Top