Search results

Talking in circles. Mihawk > Shanks in swordsmanship. I've said it only 3 billion times already. The problem is, we don't know if the swordsmanship is exclusive (Shanks barely has done anything in the series thus far) or if it meant anything to Shanks in terms of the WSS. Nobody knew Roger was...

Again, cherry picking, there are 3 other words I used there. Strongest pirate implies exactly what it is, the strongest pirate. Whitebeard was the strongest man, and thus likely the strongest pirate. Kaido is now likely the strongest pirate. No confusion on it being a fighting style.

Uhuh, says the person who can't spell

Oh my god dude, MIHAWK IS BETTER THAN RAYLEIGH AT SWORDSMANSHIP. Did I really have to fucking spell that out? Learn to read! Thats NOT my argument! Read my last post please, I'm outa here.

I'll say it one more time cause I'm done discussing it. Mihawk as the WSS title. This implies he is the greatest and strongest swordsman in the world. This does not imply he is the strongest pirate or man or creature or combatant in the world. Swordsmanship is a skillset. Nothing implies Shanks...

I mean people are casually throwing around Mihawk's title as the fucking pure law of the land, yet characters like Whitebeard, Shanks, Kaido, BM have been shown to literally split the sky from pure haki clashes alone. That's like using the bible to say "god exists" when in fact there is actual...

Read Chapter 233 please: https://ww8.readonepiece.com/chapter/one-piece-digital-colored-comics-chapter-233/ Buggy literally says it point blank. Unless, we are going to go the whole "can't take the words of a character seriously" like people are saying for Kaido right now. 1606845607 Fanmade...

Literally my point. I agree. But we dont know enough about Shanks and how he fights. Rayleigh does not only use a sword and he fights just like Shanks. Hence my point to just wait and see what happens

Literally Buggy in 230s. Sengoku in the 550s, you can look this up yourself. This is where the WSM information comes from. Thats literally it.

Not even remotely the same logic. WB 's title was only given to him for his status on facing Roger equally and being the man closest to one piece. Thats it. So no, Dave wouldn't be the WSM. Again, apples to oranges 1606844653 Did you read the asterisk or just fail to read that entirely?

In swordsmanship* That's the only fact, there you go. Case closed. End the thread. Nothing implies overall combat prowess. If Zoro could outclass Law with pure swordsmanship, but then Law simply uses one of his broken devil fruit abilities to catch zoro off guard, I wouldn't think Law was the...

What? Have they ever fought? The fuck kind of logic is that? Whitebeards title comes from his ability to stand on par with Roger. Its not a competitive title because nobody else stood on par with Roger. Kaido's title IS competitive. "1v1, always bet on Kaido". And my god, I've said it 50...

No, and thats the point, seems like it started with Mihawk. It also just doesn't imply Mihawk > Shanks because Shanks' goals are entirely undefined and has never been implied to lose against Mihawk

Apparently you can't even read my comment, but cool. To imply he's stronger than Shanks, that would imply Shanks lost to Mihawk, which has never been stated in the manga. Implying i can't read lol

Read my above point. Nothing implies the opposite either

Kind of my point about it not being black and white but you do you. By using the same blind fanboy logic you use for Mihawk > Shanks i can say that Shanks losing his arm and not fighting Mihawk again caused the spread of rumors to make Mihawk the WSS. We can say whatever the fuck we want...

Listen, we all know PK is just a Journey milestone or a fight against Blackbeard at Laugh Tale or whatever but YOU know there is more to it than that right? Surpassing Roger is more than just becoming PK, that would only have Luffy EQUATE to Roger. Odens flashback made it entirely clear that...

Except you very well know that is also commensurate with strength since Whitebeard was the WSM and was considered to be Roger's only equal.

You are not understanding what I am saying. People are using the logic that Mihawk > Shanks because Shanks has only been shown to use his sword/is a swordsman. Then by that logic, Mihawk > Roger for the exact same fucking reason. Which means when Zoro > Mihawk, apparently he's the top in the...

Insult me all you want, but once again, not black and white. It was never implied Shanks lost to Mihawk ever or even tried to become the WSS. Its even a fan guess that Shanks is trying to become Pirate King, which has never been implied either by the story (he is the one Yonko with no clear...