Future Events After Kaidou, will Luffy be free from underdog narrative?

#1
We've seen a certain form of reward from various mangas and manhwas, which is: the pay-off from all the struggle to become strong. We've seen it in most shonen, even manhwas like Solo Leveling which pull of the biggest pay-off at the earlier part of the series.

It was after MC beat Igris in the best fight and struggle of the entire manhwa: That the MC get the ability to become a necromancer, something that allows the MC to literally buldoze through the rest of the series, thus be placed on pedestal of admiration from the rest of the world.

The pay-off also made the manhwa extremely boring since there is literally no more tension left and the fight results become predictable. Is it because of mismanagement of the reward as the author? Maybe the MC should get the pay-off later in the story instead of earlier, so that he doesnt become unbeatable too early? Or the existence of strength reward for the MC will make the follow-up boring, no matter what the author does?

But after seeing Luffy's power right now, is it finally time for Oda to set Luffy free from his underdog narrative? Will Luffy finally achieve some acknowledgement from other bigshots he meet? Will the fight of Luffy vs Shanks and Luffy vs Blackbeard, finally be the decisive fight between equals, who acknowledges each other as personification of greatness? The result of which dont depend on extreme powerups as the main cause, but instead the techniques, matchups, tactics or some ruthless twist that Luffy pulls when he adapts to his opponents?

...or will the Rubber Boi still get oneshotted by Shanks or Teach at their first meeting, only to match them in base a while later in the next rounds? Discuss.
 

nik87

Kitetsu Wanker
#6
Luffy will be the strongest in the verse if he can beat Kaido fair and square.
Which we all know he isnt capable off. He is having trouble to reduce Kaido's last 30% of stamina in 1vs1...
Refresh both of them back to 100% and Kaido will again trash him 3 times before he runs out of juice.
Luffy will never be free from the underdog narrative. He is a personification of it.

His greatest ability is making others help him and they helped him vs Kaido, just like they did vs Doffy, Cracker, Katakuri.
 
#7
Which we all know he isnt capable off. He is having trouble to reduce Kaido's last 30% of stamina in 1vs1...
Refresh both of them back to 100% and Kaido will again trash him 3 times before he runs out of juice.
Luffy will never be free from the underdog narrative. He is a personification of it.

His greatest ability is making others help him and they helped him vs Kaido, just like they did vs Doffy, Cracker, Katakuri.
Thats a fair point. Kaido suffered way more damage from other characters. However, the narrative might change if Kaido gives us a statement similar to Katakuri, "I no longer believe you are below my level"
 
#10
Its understandable for Oda to keep Luffy's boyish charms by having him lose in no-stake battles after this arc like against Chopper, Usopp, Buggy, Foxy or even the stronger ones, but if its a battle with stakes then i'd personally be distasted if Luffy suffered the oneshot underdog syndrome again unless if its against Prime BB or Imu lol.
 
#17
Nope, because Blackbeard is going to be stupidly stronger than anyone who has lived, and is currently living. Already has two broken Devil Fruits, with a possible third, and if Oda gives his High level Haki on top of it, then it's good game for anyone other than EoS Luffy, who will surpass him in that fight.
 
#18
Whether it's Kizaru or Akainu or Blackbeard or Shanks or Im or anyone else really, the game fundamentally changes after Kaido I feel like. Sure, Luffy will probably have further struggles with enemies (i.e. Akainu's broken AP or Kizaru's speed or Blackbeard's world ending DFs), but he'll no longer be the underdog in a fight imo.
 
#19
no cause that not how shonen writing works. to communicate a certain level of threat , luffy has to be the underdog in any potential major fight till the story ends.
shanks is not in this convo
bb most definitely is
 
Top