Kaku has swords. Kizaru doesn't, nothing similar about it.
By your logic every cp9 member had swords and were swordsman because they could use rankyaku, oh wait no, only the dude who carries swords was considered a swordsman. Wonder why that is.
Oh yea having a sword is a prerequisite for being a swordsman, who would of thunk it? Even Daz wasn't considered a swordsman despite his whole body being a blade and him using it like a blade.
Until Kizaru comes out and outright says he's a swordsman, there is no reason to categorize him as one, as he doesn't even meet the absolute basic requirement of having a blade let alone a sword.
Damn, Luffy must be going around carrying guns and bazookas then. Since he named moves created by his df after guns.
By your logic every cp9 member had swords and were swordsman because they could use rankyaku, oh wait no, only the dude who carries swords was considered a swordsman. Wonder why that is.
Oh yea having a sword is a prerequisite for being a swordsman, who would of thunk it? Even Daz wasn't considered a swordsman despite his whole body being a blade and him using it like a blade.
Until Kizaru comes out and outright says he's a swordsman, there is no reason to categorize him as one, as he doesn't even meet the absolute basic requirement of having a blade let alone a sword.
Damn, Luffy must be going around carrying guns and bazookas then. Since he named moves created by his df after guns.
Kizaru does have his sword. It just happens to be made of light.
Yes every cp9 member is a swordsman. Kaku just happens to bethe best out of all of them. He even stated it himself that his swordsmanship is the best out of the cp9. A person who is not a swordsman would not be trained in swordsmanship. Since all cp9 learnt swordsmanship, they are all swordsmen. Cp9 members dont needto carry physicall swords since their bodies are they weapons as alluded to in the conversation between Kaku and Zoro.
All swords are blades but not all blades are swords. A knife and a sword, bisento are all bladed weapons but only by using a sword do you become a swordsman. Daz bones' body being made of blades doesnt mean he is automatically a swordsman.
Correct me if am mistaken, but I have never see Fuji, Rayleigh, Shiki, Brooke, Kinemon, Law, Ryuma etc callthemselves swordsmen yetthey still are. You requiring Kizaruto call himself a swordsman to believe it makes no sense when through out the series only 5 people as far as I can recall have called themselves swordsmens: Mihawk, Zoro, Kuina and Vista.
I dont mean to be rude but you last point insults your own intelligence. The fact that you had to use Luffy's named attack as a means to justify you opinion shows you dont have good point to debate with. Anyway, I will entertain your argument and show you the difference. Kizaru and Luffy are completely different. Luffy only names his attacks after guns etc, he doesnt actually make a gun with his power then use that gun to fight with it. Kizaru on the other had, named an attack based on a sword then created asword with his power and fought using that sword like how a swordman would. You would have a leg to stand on if all Kizaru did was name an attack after a sword but not use his power to create a sword then fight with a sword.
Last edited: