I personally didn't see an issue with his thought process but can see why scum would have an issue with lhf being given town leans on very little . I think saying giving town lean reflects badly on ekko is shading and not necessarily merited
"The hole in his thought process was that it carried an assumption that could not be safely made at this point in time. That was what reflected poorly - not necessarily him giving a town lean outright, which is what you've attempted to change my argument to. I'm still yet to see why it has to be shading though - it's a rather selective conclusion to make from my post."