Left right was made in the French Revolution

It ONLY made sense there, trying to split all political options into two zones is dumb
Post automatically merged:

Don't tell them that the Ancient Greek invented democracy.
*Lebanon

Practically everything about Greek democracy started there, Greece was just lucky it was protected from European tribes while Lebanon had to deal with Iraq and Egypt's empire bullshit
 
@Mathias is there anyway to deal with that without being irrespectful ?
You're literally trying to think with the far-right. The far-righties aren't talking with you in good faith. And you're being baited as always.

democratics societies existed before capitalism? no, this is also a concept that emerged in the capitalist context

@Logiko I'm very marxist in this sense, I consider all these notion in historical and materialist terms
Ancient-Athens is capitalistic ? I mean what's your definition of capitalism ? Do you think feudal times were capitalistic ?
 
You're literally trying to think with the far-right. The far-righties aren't talking with you in good faith. And you're being baited as always.



Ancient-Athens is capitalistic ? I mean what's your definition of capitalism ? Do you think feudal times were capitalistic ?
1) there is a huge gap between what they understood about democracy and what we understand
2) so are you telling me there was democracy in feudalism??
 
left and right wing concepts just make sense in the capitalist context
thats why I mentioned that
democratics societies existed before capitalism? no, this is also a concept that emerged in the capitalist context

@Logiko I'm very marxist in this sense, I consider all these notion in historical and materialist terms
Yes and no. Left and right concept are indeed nomination of the "modern age" and the rise of capitalism, but the reality of those concept is as old as human language itself.


A Little exemple :

Upper paleolithic : The food is getting scarse in the current settlement of this hunting gathering group. A woman is sick and people are getting very nervous and stressed. The hunting group finally came back with a big piece of meat. They (the hunters) agreed to share the meat and give a bigger portion to the weak woman. But the rest of the group (that remained to work on the camp) does not agree and start yelling.

As you can see here, with a simple conflict, we have the left/right (progressive/reactionnary) dichotomy at work. The group who hunted the beast decided to share food with equity, but the group who stayed back and is hungry as fuck wanted the same size, thus ignoring the needs of the weak one in the group.


Hassina was pretty progressive

she focused heavily on DEI and whatnot

her politics/policies were mostly leftist too and I really liked many things she did

however she had other motives hence her downfall
You described DEI, which is a liberal thing, but not leftism. What do you mean by "leftism" ?


You're literally trying to think with the far-right. The far-righties aren't talking with you in good faith. And you're being baited as always.
Yeah... but for some reason, I have this feeling that there is a way for them to understand.

That's why I came back, I can't give up that feeling. I need to know that there is something that can be done to politicize them.

It's my idealistic side..
 
https://www.cnbc.com/2025/09/03/sen...-stake-in-intel-a-step-towards-socialism.html
Another libertarian fundamentally misunderstanding their own views…if this genius thinks the government purchasing a stake in a publicly traded company is socialism, he’s even dumber than the AI that Herrera has gladly given himself over to :few:
Funny.. Intel is on the list of BDS


man look it up I m busy
Seems to me like she was pro business and pro capitalist.
At best center left and liberal like Macron at the beginning, which - like Macron - is just the far right disguised as rationnality.

When you shoot on protesters, it's not leftism. lol
 

Reborn

Throughout Heaven & Earth,I alone am d Honored One
The notion that methods such as suppressing opposition or curbing rights makes one right winger is wrong as well.


These are just tools which is adopted by any authoritarian regardless of ideology. These aren't hallmark of any ideology but hallmark of all authoritarians.


What separates left wing and right wing dictators are the justification they give to use these methods and their goal.
 
Left right was made in the French Revolution
Yes but even ancient Rome had social and political demands from the people that could be defined with left and right eyes too.


1) there is a huge gap between what they understood about democracy and what we understand
2) so are you telling me there was democracy in feudalism??
You tried making two points without developing the first one and your second point is a question.

India is democratic despite having caste system. Which is core to feudalism.

The US and Athens ruled with slavery.

But to make it short, there has always been friction between people who wanted to live freely and in a more fair way.

And I'm not playing the game where we answer each other's question with questions lmao.

Yeah... but for some reason, I have this feeling that there is a way for them to understand.

That's why I came back, I can't give up that feeling. I need to know that there is something that can be done to politicize them.

It's my idealistic side..
Plato's dialogues with Socrates were all made up. You can't just randomly pick someone on the opposite side and convert them somehow.
 
Top