General & Others If Jinbe and Yamato won't be Monsters or Wings to Luffy, then what would they be to him?

[Herrera95]

Yeah I remember jimbei blocking a combined attack from 2 yonkos and preventing momo, Tama and chopper from dying along with hundreds of samurais

So you probably forget Jinbei blocking an Admiral(now Fleet Admiral) attack to save Luffy and preventing Strawhats of WCI from dying to Big Mom

 

[notAfanboy]

Someone make a thread: Jinbei has more feats than Zoro. 100 pages discussion in 1 day guaranteed.

 

[Ask D question]

So you probably forget Jinbei blocking an Admiral(now Fleet Admiral) attack to save Luffy and preventing Strawhats of WCI from dying to Big Mom

You really want me to list all the times zoro and sanji saved luffy and the crew?

 

[Herrera95]

You really want me to list all the times zoro and sanji saved luffy and the crew?

For what reason? Jinbei is perfectly fine to do that too. That's my point. Why are you bitchying about it?

 

[Ask D question]

For what reason? Jinbei is perfectly fine to do that too. That's my point. Why are you bitchying about it?

I'm just pointing how stupid it is to think that jimbei will replace zoro and sanji in terms of saving others when it's one of their defining traits

Jimbei just saved luffy and the crew twice. Zoro and sanji been doing that ever since they joined

 

[Herrera95]

I'm just pointing how stupid it is to think that jimbei will replace zoro and sanji in terms of saving others when it's one of their defining traits

Jimbei just saved luffy and the crew twice. Zoro and sanji been doing that ever since they joined

Stupid is to think roles can't be changed in a crew. Jinbei is already saving others same way Zoro and Sanji do. If Jinbei does that Zoro and Sanji can focus in other things like take big enemies that Jinbei can't. Simple.

 

[Ask D question]

Stupid is to think roles can't be changed in a crew. Jinbei is already saving others same way Zoro and Sanji do. If Jinbei does that Zoro and Sanji can focus in other things like take big enemies that Jinbei can't. Simple.

Makes sense, but I don't think oda will change the dynamic at this point, sure jimbei will save others but not as much as zoro and sanji

 

[Master OF Haki]

Yamato is a wild card to me, she's simply too strong for the "mid trio" or anything in between, and considering her young age and the potential to grow further, she's definitely on "monster trio" tier for sure–and she's not going to lag behind Zoro and Sanji in the future either. There's a clear distinction between Jinbe and Yamato: Yamato is young [28 years old], she has adCoC, and she has one of the most powerful DFs in the series. She has so much raw potential for future arcs that I'd even argue that Luffy doesn't have; I mean, obviously Luffy is the MC and he's stronger than Yamato and he has future power ups as well etc. But Luffy is reaching to his peak, unlike Yamato. Disclaimer for Luffy fans: yes, Luffy is always going to be stronger than Yamato, obviously lol. He's the MC after all, ok!!

Yamato has one the top 4 defensive DF abilities in the series, only behind Kaido, Jozu, Cracker and Bartolomeo–and she has yet to awaken it. She also has advanced haki potential as well: she has yet to learn advanced CoA and advanced CoO either. Unlike Jinbe who is in his "mid to late" 40s [he's 46 years old] and doesn't really have much potential for growth, especially considering the fact that he doesn't have CoC, Yamato has ton shit of potential to grow. If she joins the crew, then she's definitely going to be on par with Zoro, Luffy, Sanji; at least on the same tier for sure.

 

[Geo]

They are already monsters

 

[dirtyLarry]

His left and right nut?

 

[Jew D. Boy]

Crew mates…truly, what is so hard to accept about either of them?? I’ve had to watch people I respect lose the entirety of their rational minds while trying to delegitimize both characters, can you autistic fucks REALLY not handle your worldview being challenged in the most benign way possible??

 

[vikas]

titles are useless. There were no wings till now...even now it's just a shitty title. Same as how Roger became the PK but there was just one person who was essential for that i.e. oden....others pretty much were numbers with their roles.

 

[Sadistic Senpai]

Yamato long legs

Lol I was gonna say nuts but I didn’t want the dialog to shift into Yamato being male or female lol

 

[Sanji D Cook]

People are going to have aneurysms trying to make tiers wthin the SH crew. Its very simple. There is the M3, and then there is everyone else. That's it. You ask what Jinbe and possibily Yamato role is? Its the same as everyone else on the crew. To help Luffy become PK.

 

[Tejas]

Franky 2 and Franky 3

 

[Malio]

Do not know about Jimbei, but Yamato will joining the AdCoC trio group

 

[Zaretball]

Drinking buddies

 

[DonWick]

I think Jinbei & Sanji will be grouped considering Fishman Island, WCI & early Wano.

In terms of relationship Yamato will be closed to Luffy. They will be his YC1,2,3&4 I doubt they’ll have a name for it.

I won’t put whose what spot to avoid World War 3

 

[Ask D question]

I think Jinbei & Sanji will be grouped considering Fishman Island, WCI & early Wano.

In terms of relationship Yamato will be closed to Luffy. They will be his YC1,2,3&4 I doubt they’ll have a name for it.

I won’t put whose what spot to avoid World War 3

Jimbei and sanji are not a duo lmao, just accept it


Even Franky are chopper are grouped together more than these two

There isn't gonna be a YC 3 in the crew simply because

1)luffy is gonna be pirate king, he isn't gonna have a yonko like crew

2) there's a canon term for luffy's "commanders" and it's wings of the pirate king


It's really not complicated, Yamato will get better treatment than jimbei, but she won't be luffy's third commande specially when oda went out of his way to group together zoro and sanji and even clarified the hierchy of the crew in the same arc Yamato was introduced

 

[Sir Yasheen]

I think Jinbei & Sanji will be grouped considering Fishman Island, WCI & early Wano.

In terms of relationship Yamato will be closed to Luffy. They will be his YC1,2,3&4 I doubt they’ll have a name for it.

I won’t put whose what spot to avoid World War 3

Zoro and Sanji are the groups. Jinbe and franky are closer grouped now than Jinbe and Sanji.

Luffy - Captain
Zoro/Sanji - Wings
Jinbe/Brook/Robin/Franky - Mature Adults
Nami/Chopper/Usopp - Weak trio