Future Events Luffy vs Saturn or Luffy vs Kizaru Round 2 which do you think is most likely to happen at this point?

Which fight are we getting?


  • Total voters
    87
Debunked.

Stop using this nonsense argument. I'm sure your 3 brain cells can do better than that.

Why do you keep ignoring this Shonen jump cover?



Or this one?



Or even this one?



What's this?

You're just as illiterate as you are blind it seems.

None of these covers feature two characters who are enemies

The Big Mome one has fucking Sanji being just as prominent as Luffy and her

The others are fucking irrelevant.

You haven't debunked shit. Keep coping about Laturn being a fraud and your headcanon dream of Bonney realizing Luffy is nika when he saves her for Saturn having gone to shit
 
It’s not just about strength, you have to think about how Oda wants readers to be excited for the EOS war.

If we accept the premise that Oda wants the entire OP world to come together to fight against the inner World Government, then the Government not being at its full strength would just be anti climactic. Oda summoned the entire damn Navy and all the Warlords against Whitebeard, first and foremost, because it was fucking awesome to read. It’s no surprise that Marineford sold as well as it did, it felt like Oda was pulling every character he had ever drawn together for one giant war. The EOS OP war will be that on steroids.

Plus I think the people who want to see Kizaru defeated don’t even know what they’re asking for. Kizaru isn’t evil, he doesn’t even really want to oppose us on Egghead but people want to see him permanently removed from the story…why? People want Luffy to break every bone in his body…why? What has Kizaru done that would warrant Luffy going so aggressively hard on him lmfao? Oda didn’t even remove Crocodile or Doflamingo from the story fully and those guys were 100x more evil than Kizaru lol.

People want to see Luffy beat Kizaru because it fulfills their power level headcanon, these people are not reading the manga. Saturn falling would be more realistic but again Oda won’t nerf the WG like that just before the final world war.
I disagree mainly because I don’t think it’ll be the entirety of the one piece world, it’ll be luffy, the grand fleet, revs, and some friends made along the way like Yamato

I also think if Saturn is the weakest gorosei (based off planet order and introduction) and he solos the entire island I’d say it’s safe to say there’s gonna be plenty hype if there’s 4 other ones much stronger than him. If the weakest gorosei potentially solos the main character, his entire crew, and extras and there’s 4 more of him that’re way more powerful, Akainu, other admirals, AND IMU I’d say we’re in good standing. I guess we’ll just have to see how Saturn performs and how this arc ends
 
Funny how we Admiral fans can have different opinions about certain events even though we stan the same group of characters, really makes you think which side is actually trying to read the narrative and which is just trying to push an agenda.

Anyways I disagree with this being an escape arc with no antagonist losing. I actually think Saturn especially is not walking out of this arc. I think his seat will go to Garling. His role is to be the villain of Kuma's and Bonney's life and he will get beat here.

Egghead is not just a recharge and continue sailing station, it's pretty much a war between the newly crowned Yonkou crew and the WG. Luffy always gets a full fight in an arc with a major confrontation and he obviously always wins. As it stands I believe Elbaf will be a short arc.

And if he fights Kizaru then Kizaru should go down here. Luffy beats an Admiral here so that Zoro and Sanji can do it as well an arc or two later, just like with the commanders. Having Kizaru lose in an arc in which he's emotionally invested in honestly I like that better than getting random 2 panels every other chapter while Luffy is fighting the boss, Akainu.


Luffy and Saturn will clash at the beginning of next chapter, they should be right in front of each other while Kizaru is a distance away.
Btw, I agree.

I think both Kizaru and Saturn will be defeated here.
 
I know Loda is capable of contradicting him but Saturn himself said they would remain while everyone else were evacuating:jordanmf:
I've always said, Oda highlighted three antagonists arriving on Egghead, which matches the monster trio.

Saturn V Luffy
Kizaru V Zoro
Lucci V Sanji

It isn't rocket science. Oda doesn't deviate from a successful model much.

But it occured to me if Oda wants to wrap up egghead real quick, Saturn could legit just grab Kizaru and split.
.
.
.
Lucci might just get off-paneled

I'd rather see these three fights, but just saying it could happen.
 
Beats me.

Luffy has every narrative reason to fight Saturn, but he is clearly built-up to fight Kizaru... again. And in their first fight, we clearly see Luffy does not have much stamina left if he actually wants to beat Kizaru so I doubt he is taking both on.

I definitely think there will be some gimmick with technology that will help them, maybe Straw Hats even decide to escape. We'll see.
 
What are you mocking people for "narrative analyst" and "One Piece professional" BlackLegFring?

Didn't you claim in your previous posts that you were agenda free and that we should envision all possibilities?

You really can't make this stuff up!
:risitameh:
Nope. Again, putting words in my mouth never works for you Pringles.

I didn’t say envision all possibilities because that’s just dumb. ZKK is just a dumb option, period. That’s common sense, not agenda.

This isn’t kindergarten, there are indeed such things as stupid questions…well, predictions in this case. Seeing as you’re -6 in the hole, maybe you should consider it friendly advice.

You really can’t make this stuff up!
:gokulaugh:
 
Luffy vs Saturn will 100% happen.

Luffy will be the one to defeat Saturn, anyone who says the opposite or disagrees is coping and doesn't understand narrative at all.

One Piece follows 2 basic rules:
- it is a shonen -> it's a manga for a male audience with a main protagonist
- it follows the damsel in distress narrative device -> Bonney is the damsel in distress that is oppressed by Saturn and Nika is her savior

Regardless of that, Nika is the Warrior of Liberation that will free Bonney (and Kuma).
- Bonney contracted Sapphire Scale from Saturn
- Bonney was still oppressed by Saturn in Egghead (she was held and almost killed)
- Bonney is waiting for Nika through the legend of Nika spread by her dad

Outside of Bonney, the other characters are secondary "damsels in distress".
- Kuma is a slave who was turned into a robot by Saturn, he is also waiting for Nika
- Vegapunk is also waiting for Nika, he is on Kuma's side, he danced to Nika, and he was brutally hit this chapter

More importantly, Kizaru, the admiral who came to Egghead is the perfect damsel in distress:
- Kizaru is only a cog in the machine so he doesn't decide what he does
- Kizaru is conflicted, his justice is unclear
- Kizaru cares for his friends but he has to do his job
- Kizaru obeys to Saturn, no matter if the decision hurts his friends

Bonney, Kuma, Vegapunk, Kizaru and Sentomaru are all waiting for Nika to free them from Saturn, period.



Now, who will fight Saturn?

I think it will be mainly Luffy's fight but I'm expecting to see Bonney land a punch on him with Nika-ish future and maybe some action from the ancient robot.

I don't think that the ancient robot is there to focus on Saturn. Instead, in my eyes, it will most likely replace Vegaforce and carry the Sunny to the coast.

What about Kizaru?

Kizaru is conflicted and his justice is unclear. Kizaru will not betray Saturn before his defeat by Nika, so what about him?

It is possible that Kizaru intervenes to fight Luffy but that's not what will mainly happen.

When the ancient robot carries the Sunny and it tries to escape with the Straw Hats, Kuma, Bonney, Sentomaru and Vegapunk, Saturn will most likely order Kizaru to go after the escaping crew.

Luffy may be unable to go after Kizaru since he'll be focusing on Saturn and he may be preparing his finisher attack. Also, Kizaru travels at the speed of light.

I think that in that instance, Zoro will step in and protect the Straw Hats from Kizaru. Zoro will knock Kizaru out and have his revenge on Sabaody, which will perfectly mirror that moment.

Then, Luffy will defeat Saturn with Bajrang Stamp, crushing him like an insect/spider, and using a stronger variation of gum gum axe, the attack that Kuma saw Luffy train. Which is fitting because in Hindu mythology, Bajrang Bali (Hanuman) steps onto Saturn (Shani) with his mighty feet to control him.
Brokers when?
 
I was Team Luffy vs Kizaru since day 1. I'm of the firm belief, that Kizaru is definitely going to be awakened and the official logia awakening drop for me was always going to be more of a problem than whatever Saturn could have in store, that was always going to make him a much more inferior version of Kaido anyway.
It's just the way it is: Kaido is a big limiter for other Zoan fruit users, even if they have powerful special quirks and CoC themselves, and a regeneration based or whatever based immortality gimmick imo won't bridge the gap for it to make it an entertaining fight.

I can rather see Saturn getting handled by a team effort or the Giant robot, than awakened Kizaru. Seems very likely that Saturn is just going to be a regeneration based big monster type of fight. Such would be target practice for Luffy.

It all could potentially change if Saturn really has an uber powerful quirk, which allows him to stay this big and stationary against a guy like Nika 2.0, while Kizaru really turns out to be not awakened, BUT I just don't see it happening.

Edit:
- the reaction shot from Luffy back then, when Kizaru entered the island, while he's not bothered by Saturn
- Kizaru still being there as Saturn's bodyguard
- Kizaru still being part of the strongest force of the WG
- Kizaru still haven't shown more than 4 or 5 named attacks iirc, and already being too difficult to handle for anyone else, means that Kizaru could freely do, what he tried to do the whole fucking time before, if Luffy now suddenly decides to go for Saturn, which is to kill everyone else, while having shown like 30%
- Group effort attempts vs light man = useless, group effort attempts vs big spider monster = Franky
...
 
Last edited:
I go with Kizaru luffy . So far Saturn looks like someone weaker member can smoke but he can regen everything . Kizaru tought is a realy strong fighter so I go with him vs luffy . I think the way to beat saturn is those bubles the Mach 6 are using if he get in that he is done with .
 
Top