General & Others Next Straw Hat Crew Members and the Grand Fleet
- Thread starter Uncle Van
- Start date
- Tags #c4ng2g carrot fans are still losers carrot haters are real losers seethe at the rabbit carrot is doing nothing because she doesn't matter carrot will never join the straw hats carrot's story never even began cry about carrot everyone else in the verse neg diffs the bunny imagine thinking stussy won't join its over furry bros keep the bunny on zou nobody else needs her let it go furry bros momo is breeding yamato no character is less relevant than carrot oden larper fans can't read stussy > carrot & yamato stussy supremacy who will be the next nakama of the week? yamato always had a better chance than carrot yamato story is over
I don't want to be that person, but look at the first two pages of the chapter: Vegapunk states that the SHPs already have saved him and that a lot had happened. This means that during all this, Bonney had not had bonding/interacting-time with the SHP. Instead she stayed in the Kuma-memory-chamber the whole time. The only contact she had with a person was with Vegapunk after she came out of the room, no one else. 
Please, consider that Oda now does the exact same thing he did in Wano with Yamato:
- Yamato had mostly interacted with non-SHPs.
- Here in Egghead Bonney mostly interacts with Vegapunk... a non-SHP ... . 😥
Please, consider that Oda now does the exact same thing he did in Wano with Yamato:
- Yamato had mostly interacted with non-SHPs.
- Here in Egghead Bonney mostly interacts with Vegapunk... a non-SHP ... . 😥
We have actively seen Bonney interact with several Strawhats on panel in Egghead. Bonney had more panel time with Luffy than Vegapunk before this chapter. You really using "offscreen" interactions?
Also just ignoring all the stuff before the invasion.
I don't want to be that person, but look at the first two pages of the chapter: Vegapunk states that the SHPs already have saved him and that a lot had happened. This means that during all this, Bonney had not had bonding/interacting-time with the SHP. Instead she stayed in the Kuma-memory-chamber the whole time. The only contact she had with a person was with Vegapunk after she came out of the room, no one else.
Please, consider that Oda now does the exact same thing he did in Wano with Yamato:
- Yamato had mostly interacted with non-SHPs.
- Here in Egghead Bonney mostly interacts with Vegapunk... a non-SHP ... . 😥
Please, consider that Oda now does the exact same thing he did in Wano with Yamato:
- Yamato had mostly interacted with non-SHPs.
- Here in Egghead Bonney mostly interacts with Vegapunk... a non-SHP ... . 😥
At this point I think there's only 1 of 2 possibilities going forward with Bonney's character.
A: she joins as the final Strawhat
B: she becomes a major recurring ally like Law
As of the current chapter, Bonney and Kuma have appeared more this arc than Luffy has. The only non-Strawhats who got focus comparable to what they're getting were Law in Dressrosa and Vivi in Alabasta (and Vivi's an honorary crewmate anyway).
I think the issue here is that Kuma's effectively dead. He's operating on pure primal instinct to protect Bonney fron Saturn. Kuma's whole character seems to be built around the idea of him being a martyr. He's going to perform one last sacrifice to protect Bonney. I know One Piece has an issue with fakeout deaths, but they've explicitly gone out of their way this arc to say "Kuma is dead and there is no bringing him back."
Also I really don't think they'd be giving Kuma such a heartfelt sendoff if he was going to make it out of this arc alive.
A: she joins as the final Strawhat
B: she becomes a major recurring ally like Law
As of the current chapter, Bonney and Kuma have appeared more this arc than Luffy has. The only non-Strawhats who got focus comparable to what they're getting were Law in Dressrosa and Vivi in Alabasta (and Vivi's an honorary crewmate anyway).
Post automatically merged:
I think the issue here is that Kuma's effectively dead. He's operating on pure primal instinct to protect Bonney fron Saturn. Kuma's whole character seems to be built around the idea of him being a martyr. He's going to perform one last sacrifice to protect Bonney. I know One Piece has an issue with fakeout deaths, but they've explicitly gone out of their way this arc to say "Kuma is dead and there is no bringing him back."
Also I really don't think they'd be giving Kuma such a heartfelt sendoff if he was going to make it out of this arc alive.
Last edited:
I just want to say that I think her interactions with Vegapunk are more regular and pronounced than with the crew - this is my impression and does not mean she will stay with Vegapunk - it fells just odd to me (and familiar because of Wano). :zorothink:
Oh, and I have to add: I think, Oda will show us what was happening in that time skip in the near future and that Bonney will play a minor role in the story, since she was in her father's memory-room. It was off-screened, but I think we will get to see it soon.
Post automatically merged:
Oh, and I have to add: I think, Oda will show us what was happening in that time skip in the near future and that Bonney will play a minor role in the story, since she was in her father's memory-room. It was off-screened, but I think we will get to see it soon.
I like Bonney, I don’t think she will (nor should) join but I won’t delude myself into thinking she doesn’t have a solid connection to straw hats.
Luffy and her grew close it seems, she has a unique friendship with Sanji, Franky jumped down from safety to find her, and I wouldn’t be shocked if we get more throughout the arc.
Showing fondness for and being connected to isn’t the same. Let me explain using previous characters:
1. Yamato - Although introduced with Luffy, most of her time on Onigashima was with Momo and she was constantly being connected to Wano as a guardian
2. Carrot - Although she had an arc with the straw hats, she was a minor character in WCI but moreso than that when she was on Wano she was instantly relegated to the minks and more than that her plot was connected to the minks
Bonney currently her plot is connected to Luffy and Kuma she really doesn’t have much future connection to Punk anymore and her scene this chapter felt more like a child reconnecting with a relative
Luffy and her grew close it seems, she has a unique friendship with Sanji, Franky jumped down from safety to find her, and I wouldn’t be shocked if we get more throughout the arc.
Post automatically merged:
Showing fondness for and being connected to isn’t the same. Let me explain using previous characters:
1. Yamato - Although introduced with Luffy, most of her time on Onigashima was with Momo and she was constantly being connected to Wano as a guardian
2. Carrot - Although she had an arc with the straw hats, she was a minor character in WCI but moreso than that when she was on Wano she was instantly relegated to the minks and more than that her plot was connected to the minks
Bonney currently her plot is connected to Luffy and Kuma she really doesn’t have much future connection to Punk anymore and her scene this chapter felt more like a child reconnecting with a relative
At this point I think there's only 1 of 2 possibilities going forward with Bonney's character.
A: she joins as the final Strawhat
B: she becomes a major recurring ally like Law
As of the current chapter, Bonney and Kuma have appeared more this arc than Luffy has. The only non-Strawhats who got focus comparable to what they're getting were Law in Dressrosa and Vivi in Alabasta (and Vivi's an honorary crewmate anyway).
I think the issue here is that Kuma's effectively dead. He's operating on pure primal instinct to protect Bonney fron Saturn. Kuma's whole character seems to be built around the idea of him being a martyr. He's going to perform one last sacrifice to protect Bonney. I know One Piece has an issue with fakeout deaths, but they've explicitly gone out of their way this arc to say "Kuma is dead and there is no bringing him back."
Also I really don't think they'd be giving Kuma such a heartfelt sendoff if he was going to make it out of this arc alive.
A: she joins as the final Strawhat
B: she becomes a major recurring ally like Law
As of the current chapter, Bonney and Kuma have appeared more this arc than Luffy has. The only non-Strawhats who got focus comparable to what they're getting were Law in Dressrosa and Vivi in Alabasta (and Vivi's an honorary crewmate anyway).
Post automatically merged:
I think the issue here is that Kuma's effectively dead. He's operating on pure primal instinct to protect Bonney fron Saturn. Kuma's whole character seems to be built around the idea of him being a martyr. He's going to perform one last sacrifice to protect Bonney. I know One Piece has an issue with fakeout deaths, but they've explicitly gone out of their way this arc to say "Kuma is dead and there is no bringing him back."
Also I really don't think they'd be giving Kuma such a heartfelt sendoff if he was going to make it out of this arc alive.
If Kuma lives, then she has options (both can join or they both just go off and do their own thing until the EoS)
