General & Others Next Strawhat Crew Members and the Grand Fleet
- Thread starter Guan Yu
- Start date
- Tags #carrot4prison #furries4carrot #larrot #yamato4nakama #yamatofansunite #yamatoisnakama carrot blows cry about carrot furries for nakama furries scurries i need my support carrot body pillow oni princess and the pirate king this thread stupid we're here for jew vs dizzy who wants rabbit stew yamato > carrot yamato best girl yamato finds the one piece yamato hype yamato is the last crew mate
- Status
This... If there's someone to blame why Carrot is even viewed as a candidate, it is probably Naito...
I'm sorry but they do matter, at least with some literary works such as One Piece... Oda is very easy to be influenced and pressured by his peers to insert or remove stuffs in the story that won't hurt his main storyline... Naito with the Carrot extra panels in WCI is the most recent known example... Another one is that, correct me if I'm wrong, WSJ pressured Oda with the 11 Supernovas thing in Sabaody...
You may think that editors don't matter but they actually do unfortunately...
Sorry, you're not an authority or a governing/sanctioning body with how each authors work...
This... Editors aren't placed there for nothing, it's just that they heavily influence Oda at times...
I'm sorry but they do matter, at least with some literary works such as One Piece... Oda is very easy to be influenced and pressured by his peers to insert or remove stuffs in the story that won't hurt his main storyline... Naito with the Carrot extra panels in WCI is the most recent known example... Another one is that, correct me if I'm wrong, WSJ pressured Oda with the 11 Supernovas thing in Sabaody...
You may think that editors don't matter but they actually do unfortunately...
Sorry, you're not an authority or a governing/sanctioning body with how each authors work...
This... Editors aren't placed there for nothing, it's just that they heavily influence Oda at times...
I’m wheezing when Carrot fans use the victim card and accuse others as:
Sexist
Racist
Toxic Masculinity
Misogynists
Ignorants
And pretend nothing happens when the same furry fans slut-shame Yamato, calling her a “bitch” just because of her DF.
When you thought being furry isn’t low enough, Carrot fans always dig a new low
Sexist
Racist
Toxic Masculinity
Misogynists
Ignorants
And pretend nothing happens when the same furry fans slut-shame Yamato, calling her a “bitch” just because of her DF.
When you thought being furry isn’t low enough, Carrot fans always dig a new low
Yamato joining seemed pretty apparent for a while. Hopefully she has nice, enjoyable moments with the crew from here on out, as is she's already fitting in well.
Personally, I already stopped holding my breathe for Carrot to join but I still like the character and her joining would've been something I appreciated. Regardless, what happens happens and no need to be bitter about the outcome like if she doesn't join. Wano's wrapping up, we'll see what Carrot does, whether she heads back to Zou, follows in Pedro's footsteps and sails with a crew allied with Luffy or joins the crew but with so little foucs on her this arc, I doubt it (I'd still enjoy it).
I don't really care much for speculating on editors messing with the story since it requires a lot of assuming about stuff we'll never actually know about it.
Personally, I already stopped holding my breathe for Carrot to join but I still like the character and her joining would've been something I appreciated. Regardless, what happens happens and no need to be bitter about the outcome like if she doesn't join. Wano's wrapping up, we'll see what Carrot does, whether she heads back to Zou, follows in Pedro's footsteps and sails with a crew allied with Luffy or joins the crew but with so little foucs on her this arc, I doubt it (I'd still enjoy it).
I don't really care much for speculating on editors messing with the story since it requires a lot of assuming about stuff we'll never actually know about it.
But the thing is, Yamato telling the crew she was gonna join was played off as a minor gag that lasted a single panel and got immediately dropped as soon as it happened. Chopper didn't even give a shit
And then in the next two chapters, Yamato saying she wanted to join never got any kind of follow-up. She got a couple of minor gag panels with the Strawhats in the next few chapters, but again nothing substantial. Hell she wasn't even included in the big party spread in 1053. Yamato's big "meet the crew" moment was played off as a minor gag and was follow up by other minor gags.
If Yamato really does join the crew, this is actually terrible writing. None of the Strawhats were treated as afterthoughts in their own arcs. Yamato hasn't gotten any meaningful development at all. She (seemingly) doesn't have any personality beyond wanting to be Oden. Her backstory was shorter than Kawamatsu's. She's spent the entire arc with Momonosuke and only gets a couple of one-off minor gags with what are supposed to be her best friends for life. If Yamato's meant to just be a minor character then that's all fine. But if she's meant to be a main character then this is fucking inexcusable.
And the difference with Zoro is that being the "fight guy" of the crew behind Luffy is pretty much his whole thing. That's been his whole niche in the crew dynamic. A character like that works when he joins at the start of the series, but you can't do that with another character this late into the game. Plus, Zoro arguably has the role of "swordsman" since that's such a major part of his character.
I could go on and on about why neither Yamato or Carrot will likely join, but you get the idea. Neither of them offer anything unique to the table. There's nothing either of them can do that none of the other Strawhats can't do just as well if not better.
If Yamato really does join the crew, this is actually terrible writing. None of the Strawhats were treated as afterthoughts in their own arcs. Yamato hasn't gotten any meaningful development at all. She (seemingly) doesn't have any personality beyond wanting to be Oden. Her backstory was shorter than Kawamatsu's. She's spent the entire arc with Momonosuke and only gets a couple of one-off minor gags with what are supposed to be her best friends for life. If Yamato's meant to just be a minor character then that's all fine. But if she's meant to be a main character then this is fucking inexcusable.
And the difference with Zoro is that being the "fight guy" of the crew behind Luffy is pretty much his whole thing. That's been his whole niche in the crew dynamic. A character like that works when he joins at the start of the series, but you can't do that with another character this late into the game. Plus, Zoro arguably has the role of "swordsman" since that's such a major part of his character.
I could go on and on about why neither Yamato or Carrot will likely join, but you get the idea. Neither of them offer anything unique to the table. There's nothing either of them can do that none of the other Strawhats can't do just as well if not better.
- Status