Who will be the next Strawhat


  • Total voters
    895
Status
Not open for further replies.
If you think about the enemies the strawhat crew will encounter soon, Yamato clearly is the much better choice.

Also why even Yamato knows Ace and knows the strawhat crew and sees Luffy as the next pirate king? Why Oda made her with all that stuff if she will stay in Wano or will be irrelevant soon because not joining?

Soon her tragic past will come too dont worry
Yeah, Yamato is definitely being set up to be a Strawhat. I'm much more confident in her than I am in Carrot.
 

Jew D. Boy

I Can Go Lower
Maybe something related to her mom? Would be good for her next nakama chance since Nami & Robin got it.
Hey, welcome aboard!! We absolutely need more clarification on who her mom is and what’s become of her...Black Maria seems like a possible candidate based on the horns and her flirtations with Kaido, but knowing Oda, that could just be a misdirection to make the eventual reveal more impactful.
 
Hey, welcome aboard!! We absolutely need more clarification on who her mom is and what’s become of her...Black Maria seems like a possible candidate based on the horns and her flirtations with Kaido, but knowing Oda, that could just be a misdirection to make the eventual reveal more impactful.
In terms Black Maria she might be the same race as Yamato. According one of the latest volume that came out she at least one year older than Yamato. I can imagine some weird thing Black Maria might possible be yamato step mother or something.
 
Last edited:
In terms Black Maria she might be the same race as Yamato. According one of the latest volume one came out she at least one year older than Yamato. I can imagine some weird thing Black Maria might possible be yamato step mother or something.
Black Maria being Yamato's mom theory gets debunked the moment Oda revealed their age.:stop:
 
That "useless pet" disable several Big Mom ships. Just saying :kayneshrug:
These detractors also seem to have forgotten that she also outsmarted being captured by Brulee and is 15 years old at that with the potential to grow and be better. But I guess they figure we're stupid or something huh? These haters will say anything to justify their false narrative of Carrot being unworthy of a Straw Hat despite clearly having the qualities, characteristics and the motive of one.
 
Black Maria being Yamato's mom theory gets debunked the moment Oda revealed their age.:stop:
That’s why I said word “step mother” a step mother doesn’t have necessarily be older it could same as age your daughter and possible younger. Black Maria flirting with Kaido direction didn’t want go after Yamato it’s possible there might something there but who knows.
 
Last edited:
That’s why I said word “step mother” a step mother doesn’t have necessarily be older it could same as age your daughter and possible younger. Black Maria flirting with Kaido direction didn’t want go after Yamato it’s possible there might something there but who knows.
But that would imply that Black Maria is actually married to Kaido, which does not seem to be the case. I think it's entirely possible Yamato's mother will simply never be brought up, kind of like Luffy.
 
But that would imply that Black Maria is actually married to Kaido, which does not seem to be the case. I think it's entirely possible Yamato's mother will simply never be brought up, kind of like Luffy.
I think Yamato’s mother could be shown in flashback or mention. In terms how she died maybe she died during child birth or may have been killed by random person or something.
 

Jew D. Boy

I Can Go Lower
Hey, welcome aboard!! We absolutely need more clarification on who her mom is and what’s become of her...Black Maria seems like a possible candidate based on the horns and her flirtations with Kaido, but knowing Oda, that could just be a misdirection to make the eventual reveal more impactful.
Hahaha, I didn’t know Maria’s only one year older than Yamato...this one’s on me :laughmoji:
 
Thanks for the kind greeting @ Jew D Boy :)

--

Btw, here's my personal note about Yamato so far, about her joining SH

+ is a pro
- is a con
* can be a pro or con
? unknown / misc / random

+ 1-on-1 moment with Luffy
+ Unique (color scheme, weapon choice)
+ A standout character among/around the home/origin area
+ Battled & fought against enemy alongside SH crew
+ Backstory & dreams revealed

* Connection to fight BB Pirates (Moria, Ace)
* Trusted & ordered by Luffy to protect someone important (similar to Franky's case)
* Bonds with Ace
* Knows Luffy years before other SH
* Linked to Luffy since Alabasta via Ace's Vivre Card
+ Strong female combatant
* Asked to join
* Knowledge of Dawn & Will of the D

- No flashback yet
- No role yet
- Synergy between role, fighting style, and dreams


? If she has byakko (mythical cat fruit), it can be a parallel to Devon mythical dog fruit.
? Might be too strong for SH
? If her fruit is Byakko, then it fits the 2.9 DF naming
? Her role may be the long lost stonemason
? If she knows Oden nitoryu, we can get complete 1, 2, and 3 sword users


Any thoughts, everyone?
 
Thanks for the kind greeting @ Jew D Boy :)

--

Btw, here's my personal note about Yamato so far, about her joining SH

+ is a pro
- is a con
* can be a pro or con
? unknown / misc / random

+ 1-on-1 moment with Luffy
+ Unique (color scheme, weapon choice)
+ A standout character among/around the home/origin area
+ Battled & fought against enemy alongside SH crew
+ Backstory & dreams revealed

* Connection to fight BB Pirates (Moria, Ace)
* Trusted & ordered by Luffy to protect someone important (similar to Franky's case)
* Bonds with Ace
* Knows Luffy years before other SH
* Linked to Luffy since Alabasta via Ace's Vivre Card
+ Strong female combatant
* Asked to join
* Knowledge of Dawn & Will of the D

- No flashback yet
- No role yet
- Synergy between role, fighting style, and dreams


? If she has byakko (mythical cat fruit), it can be a parallel to Devon mythical dog fruit.
? Might be too strong for SH
? If her fruit is Byakko, then it fits the 2.9 DF naming
? Her role may be the long lost stonemason
? If she knows Oden nitoryu, we can get complete 1, 2, and 3 sword users


Any thoughts, everyone?
I would say all of the ones you marked as "can be pro or con" are straight up pros except the last one.
 
Well, at least Yamato levels the plain moving story forward against upcoming threats. I mean jinbei was facing against big mom on the thousand sunny. While luffy was fighting against katkruai and sanji was making cake. For me having powerful force can protect the other characters against strong opponent. Since we are strongest sea in series it make sense at least have two forms of strong back up behind you. Just in case the other characters are occupied with something else.
 
Last edited:
Well, at least Yamato levels the plain moving story forward against upcoming threats. I mean jinbei was facing against big mom on the thousand sunny. While luffy was fighting against katkruai and sanji was making cake. For me having being powerful force can protect the other characters against strong opponent. Since we are strongest sea in series it make sense at least have two forms of strong back up behind you. Just in case the other characters are occupied with something else.
I agree... Even Roger recruited Oden even though their crew was very formidable prior to Laugh Tale... Now, it's the opposite for the SHs, they need Yamato's power more than her skills...
 
Hey, welcome aboard!! We absolutely need more clarification on who her mom is and what’s become of her...Black Maria seems like a possible candidate based on the horns and her flirtations with Kaido, but knowing Oda, that could just be a misdirection to make the eventual reveal more impactful.
BMa and Yamatonare of same age. Her flirtations attitude is more to how oda wrote her character like how she wacted with sanji too.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top