Who will be the next Strawhat


  • Total voters
    895
Status
Not open for further replies.
Well, I have seen from some of the characters but carrot isn't one. Btw I watch One piece Youtubers and they don't get what you have been saying from reading carrot fight so who is the problem?
The problem is that most One Piece youtuber are not analyst. They are conspiracy theorist. Only a few are analyst in the sence that they have a high degree of what storytelling really is (Morj / Joy Boy (when he doesn't bs/) the thing is, they don't focus on Carrot so it would need a lot of work for them to arrive at my conclusions.


unlikely cause I implied that you need to rethink things a bit since you're missing some major points
I'm not. In fact I'm one only individual here looking at the big picture. In other word looking at the story of wano as part of the Yonko Saga, not just one arc. A saga where ALL the storylines are linked together. A saga where a setup created at the very beginning (Zou) can have an effect on the very end (Onigashima). A saga where a storyline has an impact even if it was put under the shadow on one or other part of it, a saga where one storyline was carefully crafted in the shadow of all the arcs and Big character arc: the story of Carrot in wonderland.
 

AL sama

Red Haired
i'm fine with that i have always been of the opinion that neither Yamato nor Carrot is joining:jordanmf:
I can see that happening but currently yamato's chances are really very high
Post automatically merged:

I'm not. In fact I'm one only individual here looking at the big picture. In other word looking at the story of wano as part of the Yonko Saga, not just one arc. A saga where ALL the storylines are linked together. A saga where a setup created at the very beginning (Zou) can have an effect on the very end (Onigashima). A saga where a storyline has an impact even if it was put under the shadow on one or other part of it, a saga where one storyline was carefully crafted in the shadow of all the arcs and Big character arc: the story of Carrot in wonderland.
sometimes you need to take a few steps back to see the bigger picture
 
Last edited:
The problem is that most One Piece youtuber are not analyst. They are conspiracy theorist. Only a few are analyst in the sence that they have a high degree of what storytelling really is (Morj / Joy Boy (when he doesn't bs/) the thing is, they don't focus on Carrot so it would need a lot of work for them to arrive at my conclusions
All of them do have good analysis, or it's just because oda isn't showing carrot like u actually think is happening cause I know for a fact they would have picked it no matter what.
 
Yes it was shown clearly. You just choosed to ignored it.

Carrot's naivety toward adventure and the sea is in the center of her character arc. You can spot that with different narrative data throughout her story, let look at those data:


- The first time she expresses how she viewed a mission heading toward a yonko territory :




> Wanda had to reprimand her




- The second time she was introduced. Thinking that she would just go on a pyjama party for 1 day with the strawhats bringing only one teeshirt and one snacks





> Pedro had to reprimand her



(note in those instance that Pedro and Wanda are using the same rethoric)

- The way she faces her ennemies (head on) but doesn't really think about it (much like Luffy in that instance)




- The way she interacts with the strawhat and Chopper, listening blindly to his orders even thou he doesn't know what to do (funny enough "Choniki" is the title of that chapter):




Again.. the way she attacks blindly her ennemy without even a notion of danger:




Interestingly enough, we can see that this "naivety" completely dissapears at the very moment where she is in perfect sync with her purpose and the memories of her master while letting the anger at the door:




But her naivety didn't disappeared and she keeps rushing toward the ennemy without a mear sence of danger (note here that Luffy and Carrot are both showed in a similar position, in a similar direction and in a similar panel .. heading toward their ennemy and they will both fail):



Finally Perospero is the onewho will "give the truth" to Carrot: "You are too naive, return home":



------------

Again. Naivety is the core of Carrot's characterization and it's in the center of her character arc. This naivety will be again tested in the future. Only this time, Carrot won't be defeated.

Because the thing is: Naivety is not a weakness. It's a gift.

---------------
Post automatically merged:



You will care. Trust me, you will ;)




There is no hypocrisy. Therefore I don't have to reply to this invective. Copy ?
So if naivety is a core part her character then that interferes with Chopper.
Post automatically merged:

did you really get what I implied there??
Nope, he's clueless. That and he twists words to fit his agenda.
 
All of them do have good analysis, or it's just because oda isn't showing carrot like u actually think is happening cause I know for a fact they would have picked it no matter what.
No. In fact Morj is a good analyst but we completely disagree on the next Nakama. The difference is, he has valid narrative arguments for his picks. The rest of the youtubers are not so lucky.


how about you reread the arc again??

I stopped reading one piece after chapter 957 and I picked it up this week again now my takes are vastly different
Al Sama. When I read One Piece...

I read it two time at first read. Around 5 times more while watching reactors, 2 or more time before the next chapter comes out. ANd I'm constantly coming back to them again and again during the arc in order to explain my reasonning.

I've been doing this since 2016. (When I started the Carrot theory) before that it was only two or three times per week.

So trust me when I say that I know this saga like the back of my pocket. I have a very good idea of what the big picture of this Saga really is.

:sanmoji:
Post automatically merged:

So if naivety is a core part her character then that interferes with Chopper.
No. Chopper don't struggle with naivety. He struggles with self confidence.. or rather strugglED with self confidence.
 
No. In fact Morj is a good analyst but we completely disagree on the next Nakama. The difference is, he has valid narrative arguments for his picks. The rest of the youtubers are not so lucky.




Al Sama. When I read One Piece...

I read it two time at first read. Around 5 times more while watching reactors, 2 or more time before the next chapter comes out. ANd I'm constantly comming back to them again and again during the arc in order to explain my reasonning.

I've been doing this since 2015. (When I started the Carrot theory) before that it was only two or three times per week.

So trust me when I say that I know this saga like the back of my pocket. I have a very good idea of what the big picture of this Saga really is.

:sanmoji:
Post automatically merged:



No. Chopper don't struggle with naivety. He struggles with self confidence.. or rather strugglED with self confidence.
He's still relatively naive.
Your statement doesn't matter.
Chopper as a character clashes with Carrot.
She's a pointless character with no substance to her.
 
Yamato look like she will be guide for Momo how to rule wano .
‘So I say Momo will join straw hat fleet for final war.

Yamato have 50% chance join luffy crew . Otherwise she stays in wano.

About carrot , she will join straw hat fleet with mink armies.
That is how I see in my opinion.
Post automatically merged:

I don’t care if carrot join luffy crew . It is win for carrot fans.
If Yamato join luffy crew, it is win for Yamato fans.

All I care for Bartolomeo greatness in future :myman::kata::goyea::finally:
 
Yamato look like she will be guide for Momo how to rule wano .
‘So I say Momo will join straw hat fleet for final war.

Yamato have 50% chance join luffy crew . Otherwise she stays in wano.

About carrot , she will join straw hat fleet with mink armies.
That is how I see in my opinion.
Post automatically merged:

I don’t care if carrot join luffy crew . It is win for carrot fans.
If Yamato join luffy crew, it is win for Yamato fans.

All I care for Bartolomeo greatness in future :myman::kata::goyea::finally:
Sadly, I don't think that there will be any more member in the strawhat fleet.
 

AL sama

Red Haired
Al Sama. When I read One Piece...

I read it two time at first read. Around 5 times more while watching reactors, 2 or more time before the next chapter comes out. ANd I'm constantly coming back to them again and again during the arc in order to explain my reasonning.

I've been doing this since 2016. (When I started the Carrot theory) before that it was only two or three times per week.

So trust me when I say that I know this saga like the back of my pocket. I have a very good idea of what the big picture of this Saga really is.

:sanmoji:
you totally missed my point but whatever
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top