General & Others Next Strawhat Crew Members and the Grand Fleet

[RobinsFeet]

Must be hard to see the anime Including Carrot as a strawhat 😔😔

What the fuck are you talking? Go watch the new opening lol

 

[Zihark95]

What the fuck are you talking? Go watch the new opening lol

Go watch the last episode

 

[KenshiraSonata]

Zoro KILLED a magistrate XD

Dude SHs will never kill an unconscious man, if Carrot wants to do that to avenge Pedro who "killed" himself, I find her deranged.

 

[Roo]

Go watch the last episode

The episode before she was introduced with the other minks. Basically telling the viewer who she belonged with lmao

 

[Electricmastro]

Must be hard to see the anime Including Carrot as a strawhat 😔😔

Carrot doesn’t have an ambition she can steer herself towards and away from her troubled past if you ask me.

 

[Staticshadic]

Carrot doesn’t have an ambition she can steer herself towards and away from her troubled past if you ask me.

Sad thing about anime carrot hasn't done anything to help the crew

 

[Ponelglyph]

chances of Yamato to join SH much higher now.

Tama probably will stay at Wano with her Kibi dango Gifters army.

 

[Electricmastro]

chances of Yamato to join SH much higher now.

Tama probably will stay at Wano with her Kibi dango Gifters army.

Luffy gave Yamato freedom and Yamato is willing to go up against an Emperor for his sake, in contrast to Big Mom’s children hesitating to stand up against Big Mom, and seems like a strong start to a friendship. I suppose after Wano opens, Yamato’s new dream could involve her bringing the rest of the world to the dawn, like she was saying to Momo.

 

[Red Night]

chances of Yamato to join SH much higher now.

Tama probably will stay at Wano with her Kibi dango Gifters army.

Tama will create the new beast pirates with Yamato as her second-in-command!

 

[Warchief Sanji D Goat]

Yamato is 100% joining. Tama and Momo will stay in Wano. Carrot's chances are 50%.

 

[Rootbeer]

If Carrot somehow by some miraculous chance joined the Strawhats, it would be the worst job Oda has ever done on a predominant character bar none. She has never been important, from insignificant in Zou to unimportant in WCI to non existent in Wano. She's always been an out of place useless eyesore..

Lets see a list of allies by Sagas who are objectively better characters than Carrot..

East Blue Saga
- Coby
- Rika
- Shushu
- Boodle
- Gaimon
- Kaya
- Zeff
- Gin
- Nojiko
- Gen-san
- Johnny
- Yosaku

Alabasta Saga
- Crocus
- Laboon
- Vivi
- Carue
- Igaram
- Pell
- Dorry
- Broggy
- Kureha
- Dalton
- Cobra
- Mr. 2 Bon Kurei
- Ace

Skypiea Saga
- Cricket
- Gan fall
- Conis
- Wyper
- Aisa

Water 7 Saga
- Kokoro
- Paulie
- Iceberg
- Zambai

Thriller Bark
- Lola
- Kuma

Shabondy Archypelago + return to + Fishman Island
- Camie
- Pappagu
- Hachi
- Shakki
- Rayleigh
- Perona
- Boa Hancock
- Duval
- Shirahoshi
- Neptune
- Fukaboshi

Dressrosa Saga
- Law
- Tashigi
- Smoker
- Kinemon
- Momonosuke
- Brownbeard
- Bartolomeo
- Cavendish
- Sabo
- Sai
- Don Chinjao
- Rebecca
- Kyros
- Viola
- Baby 5
- Leo
- Bellamy
- Koala

Whole Cake Island Saga
- Pekoms
- Pedro
- Wanda
- Nekomamushi
- Inuarashi
- Pudding
- Reiju
- Chiffon
- Capone
- Reiju
- Pound
- Gastino

Wano
- Yasuie
- Tama
- Tenguyama Hitetsu
- Ashura
- Denjiro
- Hiyori
- Shinobu
- Kiku
- Onimaru
- Kawamatsu
- Yamato
- Marco
- Hyogoro
- Toko
- Tsuru
- Drake

 

[Ponelglyph]

If Carrot somehow by some miraculous chance joined the Strawhats, it would be the worst job Oda has ever done on a predominant character bar none. She has never been important, from insignificant in Zou to unimportant in WCI to non existent in Wano. She's always been an out of place useless eyesore..

Lets see a list of allies by Sagas who are objectively better characters than Carrot..

East Blue Saga
- Coby
- Rika
- Shushu
- Boodle
- Gaimon
- Kaya
- Zeff
- Gin
- Nojiko
- Gen-san
- Johnny
- Yosaku

Alabasta Saga
- Crocus
- Laboon
- Vivi
- Carue
- Igaram
- Pell
- Dorry
- Broggy
- Kureha
- Dalton
- Cobra
- Mr. 2 Bon Kurei
- Ace

Skypiea Saga
- Cricket
- Gan fall
- Conis
- Wyper
- Aisa

Water 7 Saga
- Kokoro
- Paulie
- Iceberg
- Zambai

Thriller Bark
- Lola
- Kuma

Shabondy Archypelago + return to + Fishman Island
- Camie
- Pappagu
- Hachi
- Shakki
- Rayleigh
- Perona
- Boa Hancock
- Duval
- Shirahoshi
- Neptune
- Fukaboshi

Dressrosa Saga
- Law
- Tashigi
- Smoker
- Kinemon
- Momonosuke
- Brownbeard
- Bartolomeo
- Cavendish
- Sabo
- Sai
- Don Chinjao
- Rebecca
- Kyros
- Viola
- Baby 5
- Leo
- Bellamy
- Koala

Whole Cake Island Saga
- Pekoms
- Pedro
- Wanda
- Nekomamushi
- Inuarashi
- Pudding
- Reiju
- Chiffon
- Capone
- Reiju
- Pound
- Gastino

Wano
- Yasuie
- Tama
- Tenguyama Hitetsu
- Ashura
- Denjiro
- Hiyori
- Shinobu
- Kiku
- Onimaru
- Kawamatsu
- Yamato
- Marco
- Hyogoro
- Toko
- Tsuru
- Drake

out of your long list before Wano Arc, only Vivi is acceptable as an Honorary SH Crew

while after Wano Arc, pretty interesting if Drake somehow join SH Crew as part of his spying mission I wonder.

 

[Electricmastro]

out of your long list before Wano Arc, only Vivi is acceptable as an Honorary SH Crew

while after Wano Arc, pretty interesting if Drake somehow join SH Crew as part of his spying mission I wonder.

He’d probably come across as too suspicious anyway even if Drake did help them out. It’s not like with Robin, because he switched sides before the enemy was defeated.

 

[Zihark95]

If Carrot somehow by some miraculous chance joined the Strawhats, it would be the worst job Oda has ever done on a predominant character bar none. She has never been important, from insignificant in Zou to unimportant in WCI to non existent in Wano. She's always been an out of place useless eyesore..

Lets see a list of allies by Sagas who are objectively better characters than Carrot..

East Blue Saga
- Coby
- Rika
- Shushu
- Boodle
- Gaimon
- Kaya
- Zeff
- Gin
- Nojiko
- Gen-san
- Johnny
- Yosaku

Alabasta Saga
- Crocus
- Laboon
- Vivi
- Carue
- Igaram
- Pell
- Dorry
- Broggy
- Kureha
- Dalton
- Cobra
- Mr. 2 Bon Kurei
- Ace

Skypiea Saga
- Cricket
- Gan fall
- Conis
- Wyper
- Aisa

Water 7 Saga
- Kokoro
- Paulie
- Iceberg
- Zambai

Thriller Bark
- Lola
- Kuma

Shabondy Archypelago + return to + Fishman Island
- Camie
- Pappagu
- Hachi
- Shakki
- Rayleigh
- Perona
- Boa Hancock
- Duval
- Shirahoshi
- Neptune
- Fukaboshi

Dressrosa Saga
- Law
- Tashigi
- Smoker
- Kinemon
- Momonosuke
- Brownbeard
- Bartolomeo
- Cavendish
- Sabo
- Sai
- Don Chinjao
- Rebecca
- Kyros
- Viola
- Baby 5
- Leo
- Bellamy
- Koala

Whole Cake Island Saga
- Pekoms
- Pedro
- Wanda
- Nekomamushi
- Inuarashi
- Pudding
- Reiju
- Chiffon
- Capone
- Reiju
- Pound
- Gastino

Wano
- Yasuie
- Tama
- Tenguyama Hitetsu
- Ashura
- Denjiro
- Hiyori
- Shinobu
- Kiku
- Onimaru
- Kawamatsu
- Yamato
- Marco
- Hyogoro
- Toko
- Tsuru
- Drake

Bro just be patient her arc aint finish trust oda

 

[Dr_Professor83]

Tama

 

[Rootbeer]

out of your long list before Wano Arc, only Vivi is acceptable as an Honorary SH Crew

while after Wano Arc, pretty interesting if Drake somehow join SH Crew as part of his spying mission I wonder.

The list was just to show how poor of character Carrot is overall and as an ally, not as a prospect for the Strawhats.
A ton of characters are more elaborate than her

Even if she's used as a plot device do you want to argue that her character has greater characterisation than Carrot. It's pretty obvious

Bro just be patient her arc aint finish trust oda

Arc or not, she's not receiving the right focus and barely at that. She wasn't treated in any special type of way throughout Wano, she was never built up as a Strawhats aside spending some time on the ship travelling with them.. Even if Oda is going somewhere with her right now, it's not in Strawhat direction.. Else she would need to be involved directly in the main plot.

 

[vikas]

Bro just be patient her arc aint finish trust oda

Her arc

 

[Zihark95]

Her arc

Her story

 

[Dr_Professor83]

Even if she's used as a plot device do you want to argue that her character has greater characterisation than Carrot. It's pretty obvious

I don’t actually think Carrot’s that bad lol. A little bland but she’s far from the worst. Tama isn’t that bad either, I just die a little inside every time I see her name these days. Not her fault, in isolation of this war I like Tama. I would agree she’s better characterized than Carrot.

I’d much rather a Carrot chapter than another Tama chapter though lol.

 

[Rootbeer]

I’d much rather a Carrot chapter than another Tama chapter though lol.

That's a good point, i agree with that. I would also say that i'm sort of interested in what decision Carrot will take. Anyway better than Tama who needs to be protected all the time and serves no other purposes than reverse the tides of the war or even it at least.